Customer Reviews

Engaging the Powers: Discernment and Resistance in a World of Domination

5 star:		(14)
4 star:		(2)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

I consider this book one of the most stimulating and penetrating books on Christian theology I have read. Wink's trenchant analysis of the dynamic of how nations/cultures/societies organize themselves around self-perpetuating "domination systems" is both accurate and profound. Everyone of any religious or political stripe can be illuminated by this aspect of the book, although there are many other contributions on this theme from other quarters.

In general, I am enthusiastic about this book because it is a much appreciated example of a new generation of Christian thinkers who are opening themselves to thinking outside the conventions of rigid conservatism yet marking a pathway for relevant & transforming spiritual vitality. Wink importantly grapples with the conservative traditionalist delineation of the biblical God as the source of sacred violence. A wrathful God who punishes and requires blood sacrifice even to the extent of requiring the sacrificial death of Jesus articulates a schizophrenic understanding of God that in the end is incongruous with absolute love. Wink along with other Christian thinkers such as Rene Girard, Rita Nakashima Brock, Rebecca Ann Parker, Jack Nelson Pallmeyer and many others are attempting to lead us to a more fully integrated concept of a loving God and that is to be heartily congratulated.

I am not a Christian, yet I found this book extremely insightful and compelling in its exploration of the violent basis of our civilization and how the message of Jesus, among others, is not only that of personal salvation, but one of perceiving with clarity the nature of the world, i.e. the Domination System that has blinded us to its true destructive nature.

The type of spiritually grounded, proactive, creative nonviolence advocated in this book is a complete paradigm shift, an entire dimension apart from the simplistic dichotomy of violence vs. "passivism" that most of us unfortunately believe are our only choices.

The book includes numerous examples and interesting Biblical exegesis on top of an incredibly insightful exploration of the myth of redemptive violence and the Domination System that comprises our human society.

Fundamental to Wink's analysis of our society is his assertion that spiritual Powers are real -- but not simply as angels floating in the clouds or demons waiting in hell to gloat over your soul, but as the psychospiritual complexes that are formed from collective human belief and energy. Our governmental and corporate institutions are themselves Powers, having a spiritual existence in the sense of having a Being above and beyond the sum of the individuals that comprise them (as well as enjoying legal status that puts them on the same footing as a human being!). Unrecognized, the Powers run amuck amongst us. We are slaves to our own creation, and blind to our slavery. Our allegiance to the Power of the national security state, for instance, blinds us to its own violence, opens us to being subverted to evil ends, allows us to be convinced that upholding democracy and freedom is synonymous with the killing of others.

A central thesis of the book is that these Powers, having gone unrecognized for so long, have taken on a life of their own and now dominate us. They must be seen and engaged in order to be redeemed and transformed -- and in order for us to redeem and transform ourselves.

Wink spends the book laying bare the way these Powers work, making clear that it is not only spiritual or only psychological or only material, but all of these. He explores in depth the manifestations of violence and its origins in deeply embedded cultural mythology -- as seemingly innocuous as children's cartoons, e.g. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles -- and the nature of the Powers and the Domination System they create. And he explores what he calls "Jesus' Third Way," the path out of the contagious cycle of violence, not only through the example of Jesus but through examples in history of those who have triumphed through nonviolent means.

As a non-Christian, I expected to gloss over parts that were irrelevant to me, i.e. too heavily Biblical, but surprisingly I found that even many of those parts were very interesting and in no way exclusionary. It actually helps me to see the character and mission of Jesus in a new light, one that makes him suddenly much more relevant to this day and age.

I cannot recommend this book highly enough.

The thrust of the book is the world is in control of the Domination System, the powerful institutions that repress us, perpetuate violence upon us, and whose power is based upon the myth of redemptive violence--the idea the violence "saves." Wink powerfully shows that the myth of redemptive violence is the actual religion of our society, so deeply ingrained in us that we are unaware that we idolize it. It is the basis of even our comic book heroes, of whom Wink observes "repentance and confession are as alien to them as the love of enemies and nonviolence." Wink's analysis is profound because it encompasses intellectual, the physical, and the spiritual aspects our predicament. The gospel, or good news, of his book is centered on how Jesus introduced us the "Kingdom of God," the antithesis of the Domination System, and how radical Jesus's teachings were, not only 2,000 years ago but today as well. Jesus's teachings were influential in the early church, but Wink shows how when Christianity became the religion of the Roman Empire, the Church became corrupted itself as an institution, and has remained so to this day--because most of it became part of the Domination System which needs to repress the truth. Using biblical analysis, Wink explains that persons and institution in our world are (1) created by God and therefore good, (2) fallen, and (3) in need of redemption. A first-class biblical scholar, Wink among other things decimates the blood-theory of atonement, citing it as another instance of "redemptive violence" and an idea that could hardly have sprung from God: "Jesus's message reveals that those who believe in divine violence are still mired in Satan's universe." Satan, incidentally, he defines not as some personified boogeyman separate from our institutions, but as the malicious spiritual forces that are woven throughout our world and ourselves. There are many profound insights in this book. One of the most important is although Jesus was non-violent, he was in fact a passionate resister of violence and of the Domination System; in fact for this resistance he paid with his own suffering and his life. He brilliantly analyzes Jesus's sayings to "Turn the other cheek," to "Give the undergarment," and "Go the second mile," not as passivity, but actions taken to bewilder and expose the dominators for what they are, and to undermine the Domination System. Woven throughout the book are many spiritual and biblical insights regarding the world, the powers that control it, and God's plan. This together with considerable evidence he presents regarding the effectiveness of nonviolence in history is a powerful argument. Also present is specific spiritual guidance for the reader, expecially regarding prayer. These are wonderful insights from a spiritually mature perspective, with analysis from biblical passages to support his perpective. I enthusiastically recommend it.

Substitute "domination system" for "world" and Christ's declaration the He is not of this "world" takes on new meaning. Wink explains how the writer of the book of Revelation was a seer who could see the spiritual realm of the domination system. The movie "Bulworth" captures Wink's theme. Jay Billington Bulworth is a U.S. senator, one of the "powers" who has fallen. A black homeless guy spots Bulworth after Bulworth begins his journey to redemption and says "ya gots to be a spirit, you can't be a ghost." Like John of Patmos who portrays the fallen spirits as dragons, the black homeless guy is a seer who sees the "powers" for what they are and instructs Bulworth to "sing your song". Bulworth exposes the powers through rap sing song and renders them powerless by engaging them with ridicule. Wink is on to something here. Non-violence is the major theme of his book but it goes way beyond a treatise on non-violence. Wink introduces his book with a description of five world views which put his theology into perspective. Most of us never think of these world views but we are profoundly affected by the way we view the world. The materialists are clearly in control of the church these days and Wink argues that it is only through an integrated world view that we have the possibility of changing the world. A sub-theme of the non-violence theme is the way our culture is controlled by the ancient Babylonian myth of redemptive violence. In a word, that myth is embodied in the strict Hollywood movie formula of the good guy getting beat up for most of the movie and resolving all matters in the end with an act of terrible violence. Come to think of it that pretty much describes what went on in the minds of the Littleton murderers. Wink's book is a very penetrating look at humanity.

With this book, Wink has entered the top three of all books I have ever read, in terms of overall influence to the way I live my life (with the other two consisting of Anthony DeMello's "Awareness" and Charles Tart's "Waking Up"). He has one absolutely amazing insight for those who pay attention. Unlike traditional teachings, which equate "demons" or "powers" with evil, Wink shows them to be fundamentally good, but 'fallen.' Thefore, these powers can and should be redeemed. This is a huge diversion from those who believe that all demons (which would equate to various items within the Jungian unconcious that manifest, etc) should be exterminated. Wink makes an outstanding presentation of how they cannot be exterminated, and how this is exactly the wrong approach. It is not a book which will give one a lot of comfort, though, so please do not read it as a feel good book. Realize Wink does heap burning coals upon your head, and cause you to have to examine a lot. The other option is to dismiss his position out of hand, which would be unfortunate.

Read this book now. I was reading it on Sept. 11 and it absolutely changed my experience of the terrible violence going on all around us, which continues to wage. The book highlights the essential connectedness of all forms of violence to one another, and ends with a beautiful, intense, and compelling section on prayer.

Reading this book, was a life-changing experience that has remained with me always. Wink leads the reader in detail, down a path of recognition and understanding, which for me, felt simply undeniable. He provides the framework and the language to unmask the subversivity we innately recognize, but feel so unable to effectively name and confront. I didn't necessarily agree with everything, but then, Wink's presentation isn't one that coerces the reader; so there's no feeling of needing to agree or disagree. The book provided a recognition --and a framework-- that has completely changed the way I think, and has thereby changed my most every action -- profoundly for the better. You'll reccognize that much of what he writes about is unabashedly rearing its head now in the US.

This book is must reading for anyone concerned about the way things are going in the world and wondering what, if anything, can be done to usher in better times. Although it is often difficult reading - the author has a very prolific vocabulary - I couldn't put it down...and consider it well worth the effort. I plan to read more of Walter Wink's work. He is not an entertainer, but a generous and knowledgable guide. Don't miss the opportunity to walk with him through "Engaging the Powers". Save the Bible, I can't remember a piece of literature that has had a more profound effect on my moral character.

There aren't that many books that can truly change the way that you think about the fundamental things of the world. This book turned around the way that I think about systems. You don't have to ultimately agree with him on everything he says to recognize that this is one of the most significant books to come out in a while. Both Scripturally based and firmly practical - this has had lasting impact on me 4 years after I first read it.

Traditional language used to discuss spiritual powers no longer translates in a modern scientific world. Wink provides an excellent method for understanding spirits, demons, and angels using contemporary socialogical and psychological tools. He provides readers with a new tool for harvesting meaning from an already rich source - the Biblical text and traditional writings on spirituality and the powers. Although his style varies from engaging to weighty from chapter to chapter this is a great book for anyone wishing to grapple with the spiritual powers in a modernist world.