14 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Remember When Learning Was Fun?, February 17, 2008
This review is from: Engaging Readers & Writers with Inquiry (Theory and Practice) (Paperback)
When we were kids -- and this is true of both all teachers and all students -- we actually WANTED to learn. We asked questions galore. We were curious about things that interested us, and we were relentless in putting together the pieces or engaging the experts (Mom, Coach, the camp windsurfing counselor) necessary to get our answers. So, what happened to all that enthusiasm once the kid moved on to the classroom? Jeffrey Wilhelm (and the vast body of research he cites) has some answers in his new must-read-if-you're-a-teacher book, ENGAGING READERS & WRITERS WITH INQUIRY.
Wilhelm's book is, hands down, one of the "meatiest" resources I've read. The initial chapters go over definitions and research to give you a foundation in inquiry's history and latest manifestations, but after that it is one practical strategy after another, each rich with examples from Wilhelm's own classes.
The heart of the inquiry method is questioning. Wilhelm teaches us to build "inquiry units" by creating "guiding questions" that students are actually curious about and want to answer during the unit. He also shows how these open-ended questions should be constructed (tips and pitfalls are included) so that they relate not only to your educational goals, but to the kids' lives and our shared world. Here we are putting the "fascinated kid" back into the "formerly bored student." Once you have the question(s), you move to designing the final product(s), followed by the creation of all of those formative tasks (from simpler to more complex) used to get to that final product (this is known in educational circles as "backwards planning").
As you get into the heart of the book, Wilhelm offers an array of strategies, including secret prompts; walkarounds; entrance and exit tickets; and before, during, and after questions. He gets into questioning schemes that take students up the ladder of complexity. Some of the schemes involve mentoring the students so that THEY ultimately create schematic questions for each other. So if you think you really learn something by preparing materials to teach it, consider the benefits in teaching your KIDS to do this for each other, thanks to your modelling and mentoring.
Among the questioning schemes Wilhelm covers are "The Questioning Circle," "ReQuest," and "QARs, or Question-Answer Relationships." Then he focuses on author-reader transactions by sharing two authorial reading strategies utilizing inquiry, one called "QtA, or Questioning the Author," and the other called "Hillock's Questioning Hierarchy," which is George Hillock's ladder of increasing complexity. Hillock's Questioning Hieraarchy does for reading what Bloom's Taxonomy does for education as a whole. If you're tearing your hair out trying to get kids to grow more adept at literary analysis, you've hit paydirt at last.
In the final chapter, Wilhelm demonstrates how all of these inquiry-based strategies can be used across the disciplines. He provides examples from math, science, and social studies, proving that inquiry's applications go way beyond the province of language arts. He also makes a point of providing examples from Grades 4 all the way up to high school. All of this work can be customized to fit the age-group you teach.
Bottom line: This is a great book for a community of teachers to read and discuss. I plan on buying copies for two of my fellow teachers (same discipline), so we can roll up our sleeves and go to work on making our units inquiry-based. I'm convinced it will show results and know that, once I've migrated to this method, my students will not only be happier, they'll be smarter and more enthusiastic. In fact, they'll be a lot like that little kid they once were -- the one who not only paid attention to stuff, she kept asking, "Why?" until she was fully satisfied.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
12 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Wonderful!, July 30, 2007
This review is from: Engaging Readers & Writers with Inquiry (Theory and Practice) (Paperback)
Another great book by Jeff Wilhelm. A comprehensive book that outlines how teachers can easily engage students with guided questions using inquiry. Very practical resource that will move students from surface knowledge to meaningful and relevant understanding. Will work in all content areas.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
15 of 16 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Very Frustrating, June 2, 2008
This review is from: Engaging Readers & Writers with Inquiry (Theory and Practice) (Paperback)
I have read many of Wilhelm's books and have heard him speak. He is full of positive energy and passion for his vocation. I have found the same problem, however, with all of his books: vagueness.I have read and re-read this book, the first edition of You've Got to Be the Book and Getting it Right looking for something I missed. Yes, he gives some examples, but never follows a lesson to completion. What is offered are highlights. Maybe I am supposed to connect the dots, but this book is especially uneven. I felt like I had to slog through the many pages theory only to find there was not a big payoff. He alludes to techniques like secret prompts and walkarounds, but none are carefully detailed. I have been teaching language arts for twelve years, but I felt like I still didn't have the correct vocabulary front loaded to use these techniques. He provides a skeleton, but does not flesh out what inquiry really looks like in a classroom. Unfortunately, I was frustrated and unable to put much of this information into practice. It's kind of like when a colleague shares handouts from a terrific conference you didn't attend. It looks good and you want to use it , but ultimately you cannot because you just weren't there.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No