48 of 51 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
My own limited opinion, February 25, 2001
By A Customer
This review is from: Entering the Circle: Ancient Secrets of Siberian Wisdom Discovered by a Russian Psychiatrist (Paperback)
I am by no means a shaman, and I don't want to get caught in a debate over the authenticity of this book, but I can make a few comments that might be helpful. I had the opportunity to hear the author interviewed on the radio. I taped the interview and listened to it several times, both before and after I read the book. One thing that is not in doubt is that this woman is highly intelligent, articulate, and unaffected. She is an MD and also a psychiatrist, and whether you think much of those fields or not, a manipulative fool she is not. She was much more intelligent than the woman who was interviewing her. She was also completely spontaneous and candid about her experiences. Please note also that she remarks in the beginning of her book that she condensed her experience for the sake of better story flow. Also note that Umai did (does?) speak Russian. I found this book way way more believable than Castenada (and of more value!) but the final word on what is 'real' and 'not real' in the human experience will have to come from someone else.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
50 of 56 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Comments by a Siberian Shaman, July 31, 2000
By A Customer
This review is from: Entering the Circle: Ancient Secrets of Siberian Wisdom Discovered by a Russian Psychiatrist (Paperback)
I give my opinion as a shaman trained in Buryat Mongolian shamanic traditions. While Ms. Kharitidi's book is the first popular book in the English language that handles the topic of Siberian shamanism, it is nevertheless not a true reflection of Siberian shamanic beliefs. The Altai share almost identical shamanic beliefs and customs with the Buryats and I found very little in this book that was familiar. I did find a lot of ideas drawn from contemporary Russian mysticism, which has nothing in common with Siberian shamanism. If one reads carefully one realizes that the author's contact with the shamaness Umai (I question this name because it is the name of the Siberian womb goddess and not a name given to human babies) is very limited--less that 24 hours--and they were unable to communicate because they had no language in common. The writer's supposed apprenticeship to the shaman is based on a series of dreams, not that I as a shaman discount the value of dreams, but this nevertheless seems to be a rather shaky basis on which to base her teachings. If you want to read a book that presents authentic Siberian shamanic beliefs and practices try Riding Windhorses by Sarangerel. You will learn very little about real Siberian shamanism if you read Dr. Kharitidi's book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
23 of 24 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Entering the Circle: a journey well worth taking, September 10, 2008
This review is from: Entering the Circle: Ancient Secrets of Siberian Wisdom Discovered by a Russian Psychiatrist (Paperback)
Olga Kharitidi is a Russian physician and psychiatrist now residing in the USA. She was born in Siberia and worked for some years in a Novosibirsk psychiatric hospital. She has traveled in Uzbekistan, Kazakhstan and Siberia in search of secrets of healing, long the property of isolated, ethnic enclaves which she believes can have a global impact on mental and physical well-being. Dr. Kharatidi first encountered such hidden knowledge of healing in a seemingly chance encounter with a `kam' (shaman) in the Altai, a mountainous region of Siberia that increasingly appears to be the source of many of the world's mystical traditions.
Northern Asia, particularly Siberia is regarded as the 'locus classicus' of shamanism. It is inhabited by many strikingly different ethnic groups and many of its Uralic, Altaic, and Paleosiberian peoples observe shamanistic practices even in modern times and many classical ethnographic sources of "shamanism" have been recorded among Siberian peoples. According to historical research, many civilizations had begun their migrations across our Earth from this area. Human settlements dating back as far as 300,000 years - long before the remotest thought of recorded history - have been found there. Legends say that this region, called "the navel of the Earth" is energetically connected with outer space, the name of the chief goddess of the region being the Altaic word for the star system known to us as the Pleiades.
Coterminous with the land of Altai there exists according to legend the realm of Belovodia - the blessed land - a fabled Shamballa-like civilization of highly spiritually evolved beings devoted to guiding the planet's destiny; apparently however one can see the entrance to Belovodia only whilst in a modified state of consciousness as it is said to lie in a different dimension. And one can visit only at the express invitation of Belovodia's enlightened inhabitants.
The orthodox, materialistic views of health, and indeed of reality, so long inculcated by her upbringing, education and work in the then-USSR were challenged by her serendipitous experiences with the living traditions she met in snowbound Siberia, meeting people and undergoing experiences that reinforced her sense of an ancient and hidden knowledge of healing, that it might be possible to bring out into the open, if it could be done in the right way. Of the nature of trauma as transformation and development, she writes, 'Ancient cultures understood that human life is a journey with inherent transitions that are innately traumatic, and need to be managed.
Dr. Kharitidi's debut book, "Entering the Circle," is a remarkable account of her spiritual adventure over the course of a few days and the long process of her integrating the transformative experiences she underwent into her life and work.
Joining an ailing friend on a spontaneous trip to the Atai Mountains, Dr. Kharitidi is taken into apprenticeship by Umai, a native Shaman who guides her through a series of (to her) bizarre, magical, and often terrifying experiences that open her eyes to a wellspring of deeper learning and another facet of reality. On the road to Belovodia, she encounters revolutionary mystical teachings while discovering ancient secrets of magic and healing, even of the conquest of physical death, that had been the exclusive property and practice of a lineage of shamans. Returning to her life as an urban professional, the author finds some of her experiences in the Altai confirmed as fact by a physicist friend deeply involved in quantum research.
At once a modern odyssey and a timeless dreamscape, "Entering the Circle" is an inspiring story of personal growth and an insightful work about the limitless potential of human spirit.
Olga Kharitidi is a gifted storyteller. She invites the reader to taste, smell, hear and see the Landscape and people of another time and dimension.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No