Customer Reviews

Enthusiasm: A Chapter in the History of Religion

5 star:		(5)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

If you're British, you'll know 'Desert Island Discs', where celebrities name the eight records and one book they'd want to be marooned with on a desert island. Well, Enthusiasm is my Desert Island Book, and has been for many, many years; re-read at least fifteen times, and known partly by heart, it never palls.

The book itself is a survey of Christian 'enthusiasm' from the Corinthians to Father Divine, though focusing most on the 17th and 18th centuries; the nearest equivalent in recognisable modern times is the charismatic movement. (It was largely this book, together with the same author's 'Belief of Catholics', which converted me from a charismatic evangelical to a Catholic.) It's elegantly written, but that's only the half of it; there's a depth of learning and scholarship worn lightly, wit and humour which few other religious writers have ever achieved (Chesterton springs to mind); and, most of all, a compassion and sympathy for many of his subjects (not all; he's very scathing about the Jansenists and Mme Guyon). In all, a book which is wonderful to read, but also full of almost prophetic insights into the current situation in the Catholic Church, which Knox never saw (he died several years before the Second Vatican Council).

All I can say is "Buy it"!" You won't regret it.

Knox's "Enthusiasm" is a survey of the history of certain mystical trends, which the author dubs "ultra-supernaturalist", throughout the course of Christian history. Knox examines the various outbreaks in detail, especially those of the 17th and 18th centuries. Furthermore, he successfully and profoundly analyzes the psychological basis for all such movements.

This book is necessary reading for anyone interested in the history of fringe religious movements in general, any of the sects described here specifically, or the psychology of fanaticism.

I also recommend that students of Eric Voegelin read this book, as it provides much food for thought in light of his comments about the nature of gnosticism. Likewise, anyone who finds the psychological portions of this book interesting should look at Voegelin's work, which deals with similar issues from a philosophical perspective. I suggest that you begin with "Science, Politics, and Gnosticism" and then move on to "The New Science of Politics" to get a basic grounding in Voegelin. He and Knox share a fundamental insight - that fringe religious groups are motivated by an antinomian hatred for reality and society that seeks to destroy nature rather than to heal it, which is the goal of more mainstream religion. What Voegelin adds to the discussion is a deeper fund of historical examples of such attitudes, an investigation of a paralell set of ideas to be found in modern philosophy, and an understanding of how these ideas have influenced modern culture and politics (for example, Voegelin regards socialism, in all it's forms, as a secularized version of the same kind of anitnomian millenarianism to be found in, say the Montanists, who Knox investigates at length).

I read Mgr Knox's book when I was in high school, but have re-read it several times. I was taken aback by his sympathy & understanding of John Wesley. I haven't read anything more inspiring about Wesley written by a Methodist.His account of the struggle between Fénelon & Bossuet is masterful. One wonders what he would have thought of the modern televangelists. He would not have made fun of them, but would have discerned the basis of their appeal.This is a work of humanism, grounded on faith, but in no way condescending or superior.

Hard not to be very enthusiastic about this magnum opus of Msgr Ronald Knox. It deserves to be republished today--in a lovely paperback edition. This has been one of my favorite books over the years; read and re-read for the sheer joy of reading! Knox takes us on a marvellous journey through history, unveiling some of the mystical and "enthusiastic" movements, going back to Corinth and Montanism, and some of the "enthusiastic" personalities behind these movements. His chapters on John Wesley are the best I know; alone worth the price of this book.  You may be surprised--as Knox himself was--at his conclusions! ENTHUSIASM COMES FROM THE GREEK MEANING "GOD WITHIN!"

It's true, this is one of the few books by Ronald Knox that you can't just flip through in one sitting. You really have to pay attention. This is not "fast food" - and for a previous reviewer to dismiss Monsignor Knox, and this book, as "antimodernist", perhaps says more about the reviewer than about Monsignor Knox. I highly recommend that you print out the sample pages which Amazon.com provides, and read them, slowly, carefully, lovingly. Knox's writing is his own best advertisement - you will see that the slower you read, the more you get out of it, and the more you WANT to read. At which point, buy it!

This is a well-written history of the various sects of Christianity which demonstrated "enthusiastic" characteristics from the year 1 to the Modern age. Written with humor and with sympathy.

Enthusiasim , is unbelievably detailed and precise about the off shoots and derivatives that sprang up like weeds to challenge the Catholic church for hundreds of years. He is very , very detailed and assumes you are a proffessor of history in his approach. Its seems to be aimed at the university student. It does not develop anything and doesnt allow the reader to gain even a tiny bit of information before he writes about the advent of a new religion that challenges the church. I got thru it , but it was painful. If you are already a graduate student in religion , have fun, but for the rest of you , stay away and search for other entry level texts!
M

Reads like an inquisitors manual but unfortunately only repeats tired charges with the same scant evidence and thin standards that the original inquisitors used in their investigations. In the first third of the book only one piece of "solid" evidence is brought forth linking the anabaptist and the manichee. This fact being the common usage of the idea that "Christ passed through the Virgin Mother as water through a pipe." This is about as conclusive as asserting someone is from Alabama on the basis of saying "kit and kaboodle." The book is certainly fun to read, fans of Knox love it, it is full of inuendo and characterizations. "Heretics" meet in "nests" and the "virus" of protestanism spreads throughout the land. Obviously this is antimodernist hoopla which makes fun reading for those interested in Catholic historical narratives before the rise of sound scholarship. -JL