"Cloudburst" is a welcome addition to the expanding library of recordings of Eric Whitacre's choral works. Here, Polyphony sings expertly, as always, and brings new life to many of Whitacre's pieces with their remarkable intonation, musical phrasing, and spine-tingling dynamic range. This is a special choir made up of some special voices. Conductor Stephen Layton offers some fresh perspectives, with musically sound conducting choices throughout the album (with one major exception, see below). Certain selections stand head and shoulders above any previous recordings, especially "i thank You God..." and "Sleep," where Layton strikes a glorious balance of momentum and rubato, and the nuanced singing evidences the discipline and artistry of the group. (If Polyphony's sopranos don't take your breath away at the climax of "Sleep," nothing will!)
Fantastic recordings of newer Whitacre pieces add to the value of the album. These are some of the strongest tracks on the CD: Her Sacred Spirit Soars, A Boy and a Girl, and This Marriage, all excellent and evidence of Whitacre's development as a composer. Conspicuously absent is "Leonardo Dreams of his Flying Machine," one of Whitacre's most popular choral compositions.
Despite Polyphony's many successes here, there are several less than stellar moments interspersed throughout this album of outstanding choral artistry. Occasionally it sounds as though there are 2 separate choirs battling it out here: the high voices and low voices. The pitch-perfect high voices consistently sing in traditional English straight tone, while the the men occasionally vary from their usual gorgeous unified choral tone to a wobbly male Wagnerian opera chorus several times throughout the album, especially on forte passages. The unfortunate result is a mismatched, uneven blend that robs some of the dense, stacked chords of their signature Whitacreian magic.
Also, the interpretation of "When David Heard" is a real misfire for Layton and is the low point of the album. Layton frantically rushes the choir through the staggeringly huge, mournful piece as though he's got a dinner appointment to get to. This is especially evident during the dramatic climax of the piece, where one can feel the singers' natural musicality dragging against Layton's unrelentingly fast tempo. It's an odd choice by Layton, especially considering his expert treatment of most everything else on the album.
Overall, Polyphony's recording proves to be a must-have for any Whitacre fan and is a stand out addition to the catalog of Whitacre choral recordings.