Customer Reviews

The Essence of COM and ActiveX: A Programmers Workbook (2nd Edition)

5 star:		(4)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(2)
1 star:		(3)

 

 

I got the 1st edition of this book when it came out, and will get the next edition when it comes out. The book is exactly what it claims to be; I see some negative remarks in previous reviews saying that this book is a workbook and that other books have more detail. They may have more details (debateble), but don't cut right to the bone with critical info like this book does. The info per page ratio is very high. This book is not for the windows or c/c++ beginner, but is for the COM beginner. (FYI to a previous review, COM/ActiveX are essentially the same thing, OLE is based upon these, and the book doesn't cover any "OLE" technology like linking, embedding etc... and clearly states so at the beginning)

This is a good solid book for a person wishing to teach themselves COM from the basics up using practical examples.

As an aside, I was the lead developer for a successful commercial MFC/C++ class library that used COM, and this book was essential to the development of those parts of the project. Interestingly enough, some competitors of this product had certain bugs; the solution to which was in this book!

Final thoughts: This is one of my favorite books along with Programming Windows with MFC by Jeff Prosise (had to give it a plug!)

If you need to learn ActiveX programming in a short time then Kraig Brockschmidt's overly verbose book won't help you. This book is the exact opposite of Brockschmidt. It will get you started quickly if you are an experienced programmer.

This book gives provides good hands-on examples of writing ActiveX (OLE) controls. It focuses on OLE, covering COM from the OLE perspective. Lots of examples with good explanations. Platt offers some refreshingly practical information about ActiveX control development. He seems to have lots of real-world experience with the technology. The organization of the book is somewhat quirky. It is built around the example code.

My favorite COM book.

This book is about code. Each page presents or discusses code samples. Each paragraph focuses on one topic and covers it concisely. It is refreshing in a world of excessive prose.

Warning: this book approaches COM as Petzold approaches Windows, at the very base level. It is a good book on fundamentals but won't teach you that much about CComObject, for example. Fine with me, fundamentals are important.

I bought this book one year ago because there were some good reviews from two authors I respected, Jeff and Jeffrey. I wished that I could learn something indepth about COM/ActiveX. Unfortrnately, I found this book one of the mostly unused books among my compter books. I don't think the text in the book explain anything at all. I don't know why he even put texts in the book. We would have a much thiner book if he just put exercises in the book and the quality of the book would be the same.

There's typos on every page. The material's old. It's the size of a phone book. And yet despite all this, I still recommend this book, because it has clear, *practical* language and is very hands-on.

I am sure buried somewhere within this massive text is something really useful about COM. But, I couldn't find it. Mostly its just a bunch of dated material rehashed and renamed. Inside COM and Essential COM show the obviously flaws in this book.

The biggest transformation is from the non-working to the working state. I was given responsibility for COM threading and with it microsoft OLE/COM threading paper from the microsoft developer network.With low morale, I incidentally discovered this book and I knew what I was talking about both theortically and practically. It equipped with the knowledge and power to do the right thing. Absolutely unparalled workbook. Thanks Dave, what's next?

This book has been written more than 2 years ago, and it's about OLE, not COM. In its 2nd edition it was renamed to include the words COM and ActiveX, and a few chapters were added at the end. Looking for a book about COM and ActiveX?. Look somewhere else!.

I bought this book one year ago because there were some good reviews from two authors I respected, Jeff and Jeffrey. I wished that I could learn something indepth about COM/ActiveX. Unfortrnately, I found this book one of the mostly unused books among my compter books. I don't think the text in the book explain anything at all. I don't know why he even put texts in the book. We would have a much thiner book if he just put exercises in the book and the quality of the book would be the same.