Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
5 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Eco-friendly reissue of effective career overview, October 25, 2008
Several of Legacy's two-disc Essential releases have been upgraded with a third-disc and plastic-free eco-friendly packaging. In Bruce Springsteen's case, the original 2003 Essential set already included a third disc of rarities, and all three discs are reproduced here verbatim. The only difference with this 3.0 reissue appears to be the new quad-fold cardboard case. That said, Springsteen's Essential -- 1.0 or 3.0 -- is an effective overview of a career that couldn't be summarized to everyone's satisfaction in only three discs. Disc one samples tracks from 1973's Greetings From Asbury Park, N.J. through 1982's Nebraska, disc two samples from 1984's chart-topping Born in the U.S.A. through 2002's The Rising, and disc three provides odds `n' sods from throughout Springsteen's career, many officially unreleased anywhere else. The collection highlights seminal works with the E Street Band, solo recordings, hit singles, live tracks and soundtrack contributions, providing an overview that's musically inviting to Springsteen neophytes and debate-inducing to long-time fans. What's missing easily compares to what's here, but such is life with a compilation; there's not enough room to capture everyone's favorites, and Essential's producers haven't tried.
By sampling in chronological order from Springsteen's releases, the first two discs compact twenty years into two hours, flashing through two decades of artistic development. The set opens with Springsteen's love of wordplay in full bloom, stuffing immense wads of vocabulary into the rhymes of "Blinded by the Light," "For You" and "Spirit in the Night." His poetry turns to romantic imagery on "4th of July, Asbury Park (Sandy)," and the E Street band's epochal sound finally comes to the fore on "Rosalita (Come Out Tonight)," "Thunder Road," "Born to Run," and "Badlands," with Clarence Clemons' husky sax swelling alongside the band's propulsive rhythms. Springsteen's urban landscapes of last-chance lovers and desperate adolescents are cinematic in form and epic in length stretching well past the two-minutes-thirty of AM radio hits. Starting with 1978's Darkness on the Edge of Town the selections develop a sense of Springsteen's introspection and social conscious, including the class distinctions of "Badlands" and "Darkness on the Edge of Town," the restless wandering and despair of "The Promised Land," and the hard-scrabble fatalism of "The River." Even The River's hit single, "Hungry Heart," with the Turtles' Mark Volman and Howard Kaylan providing sunny harmony vocals, is based on themes of dissatisfaction and leaving. The darkness turned absolutely bleak on Nebraska's 4-track demos, with the title track's first-person rendering of spree killer Charles Starkweather, and the fatalistic crime and corruption of the grim, pre-makeover "Atlantic City."
Disc two opens with the similarly dark title track to Born in the U.S.A., but pumped up with a pounding, radio-ready rock arrangement. Like many of Springsteen's upbeat works, the lyrics are at odds with the music's anthemic qualities. Max Weinberg's drumming pounds out oversized studio beats for the nostalgic "Glory Days" and the synthesizer riffed "Dancing in the Dark." Three years passed between the massive success of Born in the U.S.A. and its follow-up, Tunnel of Love. The latter album is a more personal effort, with Springsteen choreographing members of the E Street Band, rather than gathering them together for planned sessions. The album's title track comments on the unexpected complexities of married life, and the Brill Building baion-beat "Brilliant Disguise" expresses painful uncertainty and ambivalence.
Another five years passed before Springsteen issued the 1992 album pair Human Touch and Lucky Town, and neither advanced his legend. As a songwriter, he still had something to say, but musically he drew from generic rock production. Of the two, Lucky Town is more engaged, and the two songs here, the title track and "Living Proof," resound with poetic word craft and emphatic vocals. The following year's soundtrack contribution, "Streets of Philadelphia," stripped Springsteen's sound to a drum beat and synthesizer wash. Its stark arrangement and subdued vocal reflect the emaciation of the film's protagonist, but also echo Springsteen's earlier themes of desolation, desperation and loss. Two years later he'd return to the Americana-themed works of Nebraska with the modern day dust bowl folk songs of The Ghost of Tom Joad. The confusion and dislocation Springsteen had expressed on Born in the U.S.A. turned to anger and bitterness, as a decade further along the problems of the underclass had been swept further under the rug rather than improved.
Springsteen toured Tom Joad as a solo acoustic show in 1995 and 1996, and then went silent until a 2000 live reunion with the E Street Band. The reunion in New York City is documented here with the social documentary "American Skin (41 Shots)" and the optimistic and inclusive declarations of "Land of Hope and Dreams" that provide a contrarian's response to Woody Guthrie's "This Train is Bound for Glory." The question of whether Springsteen and E Street would reunite for studio sessions was answered with 2002's The Rising, the full band's first album since 1984's Born in the U.S.A. The title song is a classic Springsteen anthem, with a sing-along revivalist chorus that belies the lyric's dire story of a firefighter's tragic climb of the bombed World Trade Center tower. The celebratory soul of "Mary's Place" recalls the band's early work, but without the dark undercurrents of "Lonesome Day."
While the first two discs survey Springsteen's albums, disc three provides the collector's bait of rarities, alternate takes and live versions unavailable on other official releases. The disc opens with a 1979 studio take of "From Small Things (Big Things One Day Come)," a tune Springsteen gave to Dave Edmunds and released in his own voice only on this set. It's followed by the Nebraska-era solo rockabilly "The Big Payback," a raucous New Years live take of "Held Up Without a Gun" and a 1984 live cover of Jimmy Cliff's "Trapped." The Born in the U.S.A. outtake "None But the Brave" offers a classic E Street memory of Asbury Park's 1970s rock `n' roll bars. The mid-90s drum-loop lined "Missing" found Springsteen experimenting, as did his falsetto vocal for "Lift Me Up," the latter from the soundtrack to John Sayles' film Limbo. There's a by-the-numbers cover of "Viva Las Vegas," a live version of the otherwise unreleased rocker "Code of Silence," an off-the-cuff solo country-blues rendition of The Rising's "Countin' on a Miracle," and Springsteen's stark title track for the film "Dead Man Walking." The disc's greatest surprise is the otherwise unreleased post-Nebraska "County Fair," an unusually sentimental ode that drifts away in an unresolved musical tag.
Springsteen's short liner notes acknowledge that this set couldn't possibly please fans weaned on the original albums. There's simply too many emotional connections between times and places and people and songs to capture in forty-two tracks. Instead, the first two discs provide a convincing view of Springsteen's greatness, and a quick tour through many of the endless highlights of his catalog, while disc three offers up rarities that demonstrate what he leaves in the can is often more compelling than other artists' best work. All three discs provide a map to the additional treasures awaiting listeners who take on Springsteen's full catalog, and Bob Ludwig's remastering is particularly sweet on the earlier albums' selections. The set's 44-page booklet includes extensive production and musical credits, photos, and full lyrics for each song. If you're not ready to snap up Springteen's first eight albums plus The Rising, this is a great place to get a sample. [©2008 hyperbolium dot com]
|
|
|
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Righteous Rocker Gets An Exceptional Upgrade, December 3, 2008
THE ESSENTIAL 3.0 BRUCE SPRINGSTEEN (ECO-FRIENDLY PACKAGING) is an exceptional upgrade to the previous ESSENTIAL BRUCE SPRINGSTEEN, this time in environmentally-friendly packaging. The songs are basically the same, but the sound quality is even better, and it's easier to store. Springsteen's advocacies of sanctions on countries that falsely convict foreign tourists, increased funding for law enforcement, and high-school community-service requirements make this anthology, as well as the original albums, essential purchases for both your ears AND your conscience.
|
|
|
2 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
The Essential Replay, November 2, 2008
Since 2001 when The Essential series was released with Billy Joel being the first artist to deliver on the double-album series, many artists have delivered definitive collections that've reintroduced many great songs and classic gems to the next generation. But, out of all of those artists that really have cashed in, Bruce Springsteen definitely has been probably the one who was ahead of its time. Back in 2003, when his essential collection was released, it delivered more to fans than meet the eye, by bringing in classic songs, and an extended disc for hard core fans to keep coming back. But, with a new makeover for the Essential collection series, does this actually deliver a new Bruce, or is that a waste through the Badlands?
The Essential Bruce Sprinsteen 3.0, is actually a re-delivery of Bruce's 2003 Essential collection, which sadly doesn't do enough to appeal to anyone who bought the collection before. Still, it is a simple reintroduction to his legendary career that includes the same songs as before which includes classic staples from Springsteen library from Born To Run and Born In The U.S.A., and the Oscar-winning hit movie song Streets Of Philadelphia, to recent favorites from Bruce's 2002 landmark album The Rising, Lonesome Day and his live surprise song American Skin, which was in regards to a police shooting of a illegal immigrant named Ammado Diallo.
While the album is all fine and dandy to appease in the New Essential Bruce Springsteen 3.0, unlike the other editions in the series which've added a disc of extras songs like Billy Joel, Heart and Michael Jackson, there really should've been a extra disc to add in even more for the hard core fans, which makes those who've bought the original edition feel back in 2003 feel like they've wasted their money. There were a lot of Springsteen staples that were missing from before like One Step Up, the somber Secret Garden from Jerry McGuire, I'm On Fire, and My Hometown. But not only that, with the album not including what should've been an actual 4th disc, there really was a missed opportunity to add on material from Bruce's recent albums including the haunting Devils & Dust, Magic, and We Shall Overcome: The Seeger Sessions. So sadly, you won't find his recent hits like Radio Nowhere, and Girls In Their Summer Clothes on the collection.
All in all, if you've bought The Essential Bruce Springsteen 3.0 really doesn't add in anything to deliver for die hard fans. You actually get the same collection as you did before from 2003 when the original collection was issued. Still, I was honestly hoping there was so much more for hard core fans to have on the album, but misses the marks that feel like The Ghost Of Tom Joad had came back to haunt the human touch.
Album Cover: B
Songs: C+
Price: C
Remastering: B-
Overall: C
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
Interact With Your Music: Discover, listen to, and buy new music, all from the pages of SPIN's digital edition, free to Amazon customers.
See all 15 tracks on this disc
- the new music site from IMDb and Amazon.
