Customer Reviews

Essential Japanese Grammar: Dover Foreign Lanuage Study Guide

5 star:		(2)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(3)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

You get what you pay for. This short book provides enough info so that one has a VERY basic understanding of Japanese grammar and sentence formulation. Some of the vocabulary is outdated and it could have been written with a more readable layout, but then again, you get what you pay for. Okay for the beginner, but certainly not as a standalone.

I agree with an earlier review that "you get what you pay for", and if you find this book secondhand somewhere it will be worth picking up for two or three bucks. But do not go out of your way for it. I don't mind the datedness too much, but to me having no Japanese script at all throughout the book is a real drawback. I'm a stalwart of the kana-as-soon-as-possible school of thought and I bought this despite its lack of them (I thought I could get enough from my other books that one just in roomaji wouldn't be too bad). But I was wrong. All in all, this is by no means adequate for a good grammar, and I'd say look elsewhere to fill this role (there are some good texts out there these days, for beginner, intermediate, and advanced levels alike).

My interest is in comparative and structural linguistics rather than in learning to speak, so I didn't mind that this is now a fairly old book and some of the information on current usage is dated. I'm not interested in speaking it so much as understanding a little more about how an Altaic family language works in more detail, as I already have a pretty good grasp of Han Chinese, Germanic, Slavic, and the Romance family grammars and patterns. And for that purpose this book was fine.

For example, I learned that Japanese does not have a true future tense--you have to use a version of the present progressive for that--very interesting. In fact, Japanese has none of the complexity that Indo-European family languages show with respect to the handling of time and temporal relationships. However, it is much more complex in the area of modal or mood constructions, which signify a speaker's attitude toward the object, necessity, or probability. Japanese verbs are very regular and are not conjugated for person or number as in many languages, and the few irregular verbs can be counted on the fingers of one hand. What a dream--if only Spanish, Latin, Russian, and French were like that. In that regard, it's very similar to English--as well as Chinese.

Another interesting area where Japanese differs radically from our pattern is that adjectives are conjugated to agree with the verb, rather than declined to agree with the noun, unlike English and the other Indo-European languages, and Semitic family languages like Arabic as well. For example, in Japanese you would say, "That sounds interestingly," for which in English you would say, "That sounds interesting," with the word "interesting" simply being a subjective complement rather than an adjective being treated like an adverb. But in Japanese the adjective agrees with the verb rather than the noun. Go figure. So overall, this was a nice introduction to the subject that filled a gap in my own background.

By the way, in the last 20 years, since I was first studying linguistics, there has been considerable advance in the understanding of Ural-Altaic family languages and their relationships, and there are several good websites that have information on that. So if you're like me and want to pursue the subject further and don't have access to a fine linguistic library like at U.C. Berkeley or Indiana State University at Bloomington, you can find some of that on the web now.

i have never bought anything online until i needed to get cheaper books for school. Dont expect it to be in the greatest condition. I can defently tell that my book was used and you get what you paied for.

This book gives brief, but excellent analyses of Japanese grammar with great analogy as well as insightful comparison between Japanese and English.

This book was my best tool for learning Japanese. I recommend getting the course with CDs or tapes if you can. This course will introduce you to most common words and phrases you will need, and you will need to apply yourself.
I lived in Japan for about 7 years on and off. Japanese is a tough language. I was not fluant, but I had no problem tavelling without an english enterpreter, and I constantly received complements on my accent.
I recomend the 'Essential Language' courses for any language.