Customer Reviews

Essential Ms. Marvel, Vol. 1 (Marvel Essentials) (v. 1)

5 star:		(2)
4 star:		(3)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

At first glance, Ms. Marvel seems like one of the first (if not the original) feminist superhero. Certainly, there were few women who starred in their own comics before her; Wonder Woman was a major exception, but she was created in an era when women's suffrage was a relative novelty and was not exactly a strong proponent of equal rights; in her secret identity, she was perfectly happy in a subordinate role. Ms. Marvel, from her very name to her actual identity, was clearly a 1970s version of a feminist, a woman who either as a superhero or regular person was independent and not defined by the men in her life.

Actually, that is not completely true. Carol Danvers's alter-ego was literally defined by a man, namely Captain Mar-Vell, to whom she owed both her powers and name. Exposed to strange radiation, Carol would adopt the powers of a warrior from the alien humanoid race called the Kree. Initially, this would result in a split personality, but that would reconcile soon enough. Her powers included super-strength, flight and a pre-cognitive "seventh sense". When she was Carol Danvers, she was an ex-soldier (which is when she got her powers) and for the majority of this volume, a magazine editor.

As with any first issue of a new superhero book, we get plenty of guest stars, particularly from the world of Spiderman: Peter Parker, Mary Jane Watson, J. Jonah Jameson and the Scorpion. In fact, many of the villains in this book are familiar from other magazines, including Modok, Ronan, Grotesk, Tiger Shark and Sabertooth. One villain, however, was original to Ms. Marvel's book and would eventually become a more important character in the Marvel Universe than Ms. Marvel herself: Mystique. For the most part, though, the woman also known as Raven Darkholme remains behind the scenes; there is never a real fight between the two.

This volume covers all the issues of her original comic book and concludes with an Avengers Annual that details her pivotal confrontation with another key Marvel character, Rogue. Between the original series and this Avengers issue are a couple issues of Marvel Super-Heroes Magazine that were written later but explain some intermediate events.

For the most part, these comics are entertaining. My main gripe seems to be with her powers, which seem to fluctuate with the bad guy confronted; sometimes she seems quite beatable while other times she is almost invincible. Ms. Marvel never wound up being one of the first-stringers in the Marvel Universe, but she has been around now for thirty years in various incarnations. If you like "classic `70s" Marvel, this will be worth reading.

Carol Danvers is a dream come true!!! She's independent, self-supporting, intelligent, beautiful and, in her spare time, she fights costumed villains!!! This alone'd give her very interesting tales to tell.
Apart from all that joking, this book shows a woman who trades punches with the likes of "The Scorpion" and "The Tiger Shark" (the best stories in the volume), but still looks feminine and, why not, sexy; and she isn't (or doesn't have to be) part of a group just to please us, readers. You are hooked by her personality at the end of issue 1. That's all.
"She-Hulk" is wonderful, okay, neverthless a seven foot tall and muscular girl scares a bit; "The Invisible Whatever" is a tad "Donna Reedish" for any normal man's taste; "The Wasp" is a shrinking violet that masquerades as a "tough broad"; therefore, now and forever...
LONG LIVE MS. MARVEL!!!

The artwork by Dave Cockrum is amazing and writer Chris Claremont does a good job with the stories. Ms. Marvel's first costume (the one you see on the cover) is tres-chic and I don't know how she managed to fight evil in that outfit but somehow she did it! I hope these get reprinted in color.

I like this collection because I think it's a complete chronicle of Ms. Marvel, because the series didn't have a long run. Ms. Marvel is still in the Marvel Universe, and it's a treat to read about her early history. The pages are black and white, like all Essential collections. However, her sixth (or is that seventh)sense is too much like Spider-Man's spider sense. In fact, she even works for J.Jonah Jameson, which makes it way to similar to Spider-Man. If you like female super-heroes this is a good collection.

Marvel cancelled this book just as Chris Claremont was getting going, which is a shame as this was some of his best writing. He'd fixed most of the weaknesses in the book and character (her fainting spells, the costume, dating her psychologist, being an editor AND a hero). Still it's nice that Carol Danvers is finally getting her due.

Well, this was by far the worst of the Marvel Essential series that I've read so far. Ms. Marvel is clearly an attempt by Marvel in the 70s to have a strong female hero who is bashed by men but proves her worth as a woman. The supporting cast is ever changing, and it's hard to keep track of who's who, even though Chris Claremont is the writer for nearly the entire series (wait, maybe that's why it's confusing). The artwork is average, and the villains are sub-par. I bought this since I didn't know much about Carol Danvers other than her time as Binary and a bit now with the New Avengers, but this was a tough read.