Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
11 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Asgardian adventures, mutant massacres, and more Chris Claremont classics!, October 3, 2005
I can thank the X-Men for my present love of Marvel comics. When I was ten, the superlative X-Men animated series premiered on Fox and my good friend Nick offered to share with me his almost exclusively X-Men comic collection (which was begun by his father in the late 70's). I wasn't able to collect many comics myself until I discovered the Essential series five years ago and made the Essential X-Men #1 my first purchase. Also, as a casual moviegoer, I am even more thankful that the X-Men movie of 2000 was such a hit and opened the door for all of the Marvel-licensed movies that followed (which have a way of begetting even more Essentials). Frankly, I think that Chris Claremont's revival of the X-Men is probably the most deserving title to be reprinted in its entirety. It seems that Marvel agrees because we now have six Essential X-Men's (the second since the release of the second movie) and I'm just as pleased as punch.
There are so many enjoyable stories in this collection that I'd better just get right to them. Cyclops duels a still de-powered Storm for the right to lead the X-Men. The child who will one day become the time-hopping warrior Cable is born. Mystique's Brotherhood of Mutants receives a pardon for their acts of terrorism by serving under the U.S. government as the Freedom Force (it makes you wonder if our government would let an al-Qaeda agent work for the CIA). Fans of Wolverine are bound to love seeing their favorite Canuck go claw-to-claw with Lady Deathstrike and Sabretooth in their X-Men comic debuts. In the latest Hellfire Club appearance, we learn that the preferred ensemble of the discerning depraved mutant plutocrat can include headbands and bandito masks in addition to double-breasted suits, powdered wigs and lingerie. Also, a recurring villain, who twice before survived a vivisection from Wolverine, suffers a heart attack in the heat of battle and dies (I found it to be a "comedy = tragedy + time" kind of moment). My personal favorite story would be issue #200, the Trial of Magneto. A repentant Erik Magnus Lehnsherr goes on the stand in front of an international tribunal to answer for his crimes against humanity while the X-Men scramble to stop the attacks made by a radical band of mutants called Fenris who (allegedly) want to free Magneto by force. The issue is a great balance of blistering comic book action and realistic characterization and emotion, plus it expertly ties in the events from an important past issue, and it makes for the most interesting courtroom drama from Marvel that I have read (and I've read all three Essential Daredevils).
One of the greater complaints about the fifth Essential X-Men is the amount of plot threads connected to other series that don't get presented or resolved in the pages of the book, and I'm afraid that's still the case here. It's an unfortunate but understandable drawback of reading these stories in reprints two decades after the fact. At this time in comicdom, all roads pretty much lead to (and from) the X-Men, and so more crossovers were featured in this series to get the recent bandwagon-jumpers to invest in other series. Therefore, some stories can't help but feel a little broken. For example, take the sudden arrivals of Spiral and Psylocke. I know who they are and where they came from thanks to outside sources, but you won't learn that from these issues since it's never mentioned. This book also contains a small fraction of the Secret Wars II crossover issues, so only some of the Beyonder's shenanigans on Earth are recorded. However, in what is perhaps an attempt by the publisher to stave off some of the inter-series mystery, non-X-Men books are included for the first time in an Essential X-Men for two great crossovers.
Exhibit A: X-Men in Asgard. Although the ninth X-Men Annual is well remembered for sending the merry mutants into the fabled land of Norse mythology, the saga actually began in a New Mutants Special Edition. This book is included, all 64 pages of it! After reading it, I felt that, if it had been omitted, I would have accepted the X-Men's sudden quest to free Storm from Loki's fiendish plan and the unexplained transformation of some of the New Mutants (into valkyries and fairies and the like) as par for the course. Not to mention that the Special raises as many questions as it answers. Why is Storm babysitting the X-Kids on the island of Cyprus when she was last seen starving and alone in the Serengeti a couple of issues back? Why is Karma, who was pronounced dead back in the fourth Essential X-Men, now alive and morbidly obese? Regardless, I still enjoyed this story and am happy to have read it, since it wouldn't otherwise be in an Essential volume until the Essential New Mutants #2 (and don't ask me when the first one will even come out).
Exhibit B: the Mutant Massacre. The first crossover that brought all of Marvel's mutant titles together (and Power Pack and Thor, apparently), the Mutant Massacre famously came about because readers weren't becoming enamored with the homely, sewer-dwelling Morlocks, despite their multiple across-the-board appearances. Therefore, author Chris Claremont rolled up his sleeves, crafted a new villain team called the Marauders, and sent them down into the Morlock tunnels to waste anything that moved. A previous reviewer commented that there was little point in offering the entire Mutant Massacre in B&W when it has long been available as its own trade paperback in color. While I agree to a point (I've owned the TPB myself for over a year), I feel that the Massacre was an event that greatly affected the X-Men world and that the entire sordid affair belongs in the X-Men reprint series so that any level of reader can understand it.
That's about all I have to tell about the Essential X-Men 6. I'd say that it's required reading for any true X-aficionado, and still a very entertaining read for anyone. As a longtime fan, I can say that the only thing that would make me happier is a second Essential for the original `60's X-Men. Until then, face front, true believers!
|
|
|
8 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Simply Amazing..., September 14, 2005
Finally, the Essentials line gets into the truly modern age of the 80's with this sixth installment of the X-Men franchise, and it's a doozy. Take a second and look at the "by" line up top - JR JR, Rick Leonardi, Walt Simonson, Art Adams, Alan Davis. If these names mean nothing to you now, they will be eternally emblazoned in your consciousness after reading this collection...
For the price of admission, you get, in this comic vet's opinion, one of the GREATEST fight scenes ever rendered in a comic book - the Wolverine/Sabretooth slugfest from Uncanny #214 rendered by none other than Alan Davis and Paul Neary in their Detective Comics-era prime. If you didn't see this when it came out - hoo boy, you are a lucky little true believer, because you get to read it for the first time!
Another outstanding issue in this collection is the Rick Leonardi/Whilce Portacio (who?) collaboration on Uncanny #201, which has a pretty cool (though for this fan, disappointing) fight between Cyclops and Storm over who gets to lead the X-Men, and, coincidentally, also marks the first appearance of Cable. Another winner.
This time out, Marvelously Marvelous Marvel has decided to include some issues of other comics to fill in story gaps - issues of X-Factor and Power Pack that rounded out the overdue "Mutant Massacre" storyline that wipes out the crappiest characters ever - the Morlocks. The highlight here is the Walt Simonson/Bob Wiacek rendered X-Factor #10 - 11. I always had a fondness for that run on X-Factor (which are, fyi, cyclops and the rest of the original X-Men), and the only negative thing I can say about this is that right about here you actually start to miss the coloring, as the 80's X-titles had the best hues in the industry... but a small price to pay for such an imppressive package.
There are other gems included, but I had to cover the essentials...no pun intended! This marks the era when the X-Men and related titles really started rolling, turning into the artistic showcase for hot talent in the comic book industry, so if you weren't around for these, or are new to comics, you have to pick this one up... but only AFTER you get Essential X-Men vol.2 and vol.4! Tammum Shud!
|
|
|
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Solid Era of X-Men in Affordable Format, February 24, 2006
I love this "phone book" format - I remember reading these and have since sold mucgh of my collection. This book gives me the opprtunity to enjiy those issues in one setting! Only way to improve this is to add color and better paper but that's not the point - this is made for people who love to read comics!
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
by Chris Claremont
by Chris Claremont
by Chris Claremont
by Chris Claremont
by Chris Claremont
