5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
one of the better ones out there right now, March 27, 2009
This review is from: Eternal Journey (Rogue Angel #17) (Mass Market Paperback)
Having followed the Rogue Angel series from the beginning, I've been disappointed in the overall decline of the series over the last few months. When I picked up "Eternal Journey" I wasn't sure how it would be. While it was a pleasant surprise compared to recent offerings, it still wasn't up to the standards of the better books in the series.
Annja Creed is finishing up a shoot on location in Australia for her TV show, Chasing History's Monsters. While the site she is covering - Egyptian relics found on Australian soil - is fascinating, everything else seems to be pretty routine... until her cameraman goes missing and she suspects foul play. With mysterious men on her trail, Annja finds herself in a race against time to save the professionals and students on the dig site, as well as the rest of humanity. Meanwhile, she must also solve the mystery of what - or who - she and her colleague saw while filming that could be so volatile people would want them dead to keep it a secret.
In "Eternal Journey" we finally see the intelligent, good-under-pressure Annja from previous books. Some of the recent releases (like "Polar Quest") had Annja acting way out of character - being belligerent, calling unnecessary attention to herself, making stupid decisions. The only "bad" decision Annja makes here is not talking to the Sydney police right away, but it's also an understandable move. The Annja in "Eternal Journey" is the one we're familiar with (and like) - the reluctant hero who usually tries to go it solo so she doesn't hurt any innocents in her quest for justice and the greater good.
Where I think "Eternal Journey" fails is in using the archaeology aspect as a backdrop instead of the main thing, which is usually what drives the series. In recent memory, the book that has been the best (for me, anyway) at doing that was "Swordsman's Legacy." Annja isn't pursuing some relic or even the site; it just serves as some sort background to fuel the bad character's motives. It felt a little weak to me.
One thing I did find intriguing with "Eternal Journey" was the author tried to deepen Annja's connection to the sword and her Joan of Arc legacy. A lot of times Annja just "feels" something is going to happen, and she has to be there to take care of it. It was a good thought, but since not every book does that, it felt like it came out of nowhere.
I don't mind if the books don't include Roux or Garin every time (although they are usually stronger when they do), as long as the overall story is solid. For what's been recently available, "Eternal Journey" is a better read, although as a longtime follower of the series, I felt they could have done a much better job with keeping in the usual Rogue Angel themes - mysterious archaeological "thing" that Annja must find/destroy/whatever to save the world. A phone call to comic relief Doug Morrell might have been interesting to put in, too.
Longtime fans will find this a welcome change from what's been put on the shelves lately. If you're new to the series, try "Swordsman's Legacy" or better yet, the earlier books in the series (Destiny/Solomon's Jar/Spider Stone).
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Another Fine Rogue Angel Adventure, May 22, 2009
This review is from: Eternal Journey (Rogue Angel #17) (Mass Market Paperback)
Alex Archer and Jean Rabe have given action adventure fans yet another fine entry in the Rogue Angel series. Educational, interesting, and action packed, as always, Eternal Journey takes us Downunder for an archaeological expedition in Australia of artifacts that are surprising and the target of much clandestine interest. Here, our heroine is truly on her own and must cope with a rapidly developing situation on the fly. While I liked the plotline about the artifacts much more than the plotline about the terrorist involved, what makes a continuing series interesting (and what I think most of the other reviewers don't understand), is that each adventure has to remain new and exciting and not simply be a rehash of characters and interactions we have seen before. The publisher, the editors, and the authors all understand the need to vary the mix within the confines of the character and the series and I think more thoughtful readers would agree. In Eternal Journey, we and Annja meet new and interesting characters who get swept into a sinister situation beyond their comprehension, yet meet it with bravery and quick thinking. Isn't that what action adventure is all about?
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
New writers?, April 18, 2009
This review is from: Eternal Journey (Rogue Angel #17) (Mass Market Paperback)
After being disappointed by Polar Quest, I had hopes that this one would get Annja back on track. Again, no.
As another reviewer noted, no mention of Garin or Roux AT ALL, and no real need for this to be Annja rather than, say, Indiana Jones (except that his whip doesn't disappear when not needed).
The writing was decent and the story entertaining, but it just isn't the Rogue Angel from the earlier books and has done ZERO to further the story behind/around the sword.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No