5.0 out of 5 stars
sorely needed basic book, July 12, 2008
This review is from: Ethics for Anthropological Research and Practice (Paperback)
A basic introductory text on anthropological ethics has been sorely needed for years, and this fills the bill. It deals especially with fieldwork and publishing problems, and provides a thorough introduction to IRB's, ethics codes, and other wonders. I could comment at enormous length on the issues raised, but prefer to confine myself here to the virtues of the book.
One thing, though, for the second edition (sure to come): It would be more useful if it contained the whole of the American Anthropological Association code of ethics, and also the code of ethics of the International Society of Ethnobiology (ISE), a society which has been especially careful, thorough, and conscious of the issues. Interested readers should definitely go to these websites (easily Googled) and check the codes.
There is a need for an advanced version of this book, discussing Kantian vs utilitarian vs virtue ethics and the whole grounding of social science ethics. These have been shifting from more utilitarian to more Kantian during my lifetime, with many unexpected and so far unanalyzed consequences. One is that any embarrassment or annoyance to consultants is now ruled unacceptable by many, even if that means denying the world an AIDS cure or a solution to global warming. We do not have much guidance in hard choices. Another problem has come with genocide, where concerns for national sovereignty now outweigh concerns for minorities being subjected to genocide. We need a major discussion in anthropology of issues like this. It has begun and is quite intense (see almost any issue of ANTHROPOLOGY NEWS), but a solid background looking at the classic ethical traditions is needed.
This book is the necessary first step, and will be invaluable for classes, field workers, IRB's, and others. Note that its relevance is not limited to anthropology. Aid workers, public health workers, sociologists and psychologists who do field work, and many others will want this book on their shelves.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No