10 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
unpretentious and valuable; unique among adoption literature, December 27, 2006
This review is from: A Euro-American on a Korean Tour at a Thai Restaurant in China (Hardcover)
My shelf for adoption-related books has four partitions--one for texts that explore the sociological implications of Chinese adoptions (Dorow, Johnson, Evans); one for books by social workers and psychologists advising how to raise the adopted child (Brodzinsky, Register among them); one for selections about living in China during the Cultural Revolution (Azaleas and Swans); and one for accounts by Asian Americans who tell of varying degrees of melding into our society (Trenka, Nam, Zia).
Winston's book fits best in the second section, though she writes as neither social worker nor psychologist. She is an advocate and a grass roots organizer, the founder of KAAN (Korean American Adoptee Adoptive Family Network) and one other organization designed to benefit adoptees and their parents, birth parents and others in the adoption circle. Her book recounts her organizing efforts and her main motivation--to raise her children with a truly dual heritage.
The book is more about linking one's adopted children to their birth country than it is about validating one's decision to adopt internationally, which is my major complaint about so many parents' adoption stories. As someone who adopted from Korea in the `80s, Winston provides an inside look at the breaking out of the one-time recommended mode of raising internationally-adopted kids: assimilate, assimilate, assimilate--for love is all they need. No, there's a lot more to it than love and acceptance. Winston, whose children are now young adults, traces some of the issues that can arise with identity development.
Winston tells, with unabashed honesty, of her experiences, successful and not so, connecting not only with the Korean American community but also with Koreans in her multiple trips overseas. She provides enlightenment and encouragement--most if not all non-Caucasian adoptees will encounter some measure of racism and parents need to do more than merely acknowledge it and hope that it'll go away.
With the current trendiness of international adoption among the rich, famous and religiously-inspired, it is apt to read from Winston: "We do not have to prove our children are better off with us than they might have been somewhere else. To think that way, I feel, is a detriment to a good relationship. It has helped me that whenever I have had thoughts about my own children's probable fates had I not adopted them, that I have not stayed in that space. ... I adopted them because I wanted more kids, they were available, and it seemed right. I do my best to give them the brightest lives I can. I feel lucky to have them, and I value our relationships."
I value Winston's unpretentious account of her motherhood and organizational efforts. Another benefit of reading the book is becoming aware of KAAN's website. Its reach has gone beyond the Korean adoptive community to Families With Children from China and other transracial adoption groups. KAAN emails a weekly newsletter with items of interest from all over the continent.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
8 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Finally! a book that explains HOW to establish connections, January 10, 2007
This review is from: A Euro-American on a Korean Tour at a Thai Restaurant in China (Hardcover)
Many books explain why cultural connections are critical for the families with children adopted from other countries but this is the first book I have read that actually explains how to make, and more importantly, maintain those critical connections. Chris Winston takes the reader on a journey with her as she builds genuine and strong connections with Koreans and Korean Americans. I wish I had this book when my children were young.
This is a story of a mother's determination to get her children what they needed. It is full of frustration, misunderstandings miscommunications and all the many things that can go wrong when we try to establish cross cultural relations. It's also filled with how a strong woman's determination leads to compromise and listening and finally some very strong bonds that surpass even her own expectations.
It really can be a how to manual for families wanting to go beyond language school, culture camps or Sunday church services. Ms Winston articulates the complexities of perspective and the dangers of thinking we can actually ever really experience other's perspectives - try as we might.
I think this book should be mandatory reading for anyone considering adopting a child from another culture.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Must Read..., June 8, 2007
This review is from: A Euro-American on a Korean Tour at a Thai Restaurant in China (Hardcover)
... for every person considering transracial adoption, or has already done so. Ms. Winston shares so much for herself in this book, her faults, her successes, but most of all, her determination. She stresses the importance of adoptive parents getting out of their comfort zone, and expanding their perspective of raising a child of color in the States. "Frog in the well" and "to catch a tiger, you have to go into the tigers den", are some of the examples she uses to make her point about building bridges to your child's ethnic community. Her longest chapter is about racism which she gives personal situations that her children have faced. She discusses how she handled it when her children were young, then eventually how they handled it as they got older. She reveals her own struggles with race. Unlike some other books about adoption, her tone is *not* self-rightous (I know best) or condesending. Rather, it reads like a good friend discussing her often complicated trajectory of being an adoptive parent to two transracial children.
This is a great book for parents who want to go beyond dressing their child up in their ethnic costume at Chinese New Year with other white parents and calling that culture. This is a book for parents who want their children of color an opportunity to have decent chance at forming an authentic racial/cultural identity. Her point is Asian culture can't be given by white parents. It is not ours (I am white) to give. This is why Ms. Winston places great stress on forming relationships with your child's ethnic community, or at the very least, the Asian American community.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No