Customer Reviews

Even Brook Trout Get The Blues

5 star:		(6)
4 star:		(0)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

Gierach has a wit and a love for nature like no one I have ever read. Every story he tells is not only an incredible experience, but most of the time a lesson well learned. As I read along, I found myself wanting to be standing streamside with John,A.K.,and the rest of the boys. Although Gierach seems to have strong opinions, he doesn't come off as "I'm right cause I wrote the book." He is more of, "Here's what I think, you decide for yourself." Thanks John, keep em coming.

This is a great book. It contains the standard fare provided by Gierach, which is good stories, great insight, and vivid imagery. Unlike other books, however, this one is not nearly as preachy as some of his other books which makes it all the more enjoyable. It is well paced, and never fails to offer a similarly themed story. As a result, there is a variety within this book's stories. This is why I suggest you buy this book if you like to fly fish, and must settle in for the oncoming winter.

This book was in good condition as discribed. Shipment was prompt. John Gierach books are always good reading.

John's books are the best - it's hard to imagine how he does it - but we are all thankful that he does. 20 years of writing now - I own all his books but one hard (and expensive) copy...all are wonderful. I would never get rid of any of them and re-read them for 15 minutes or 2 days as needed when I can't get "out there" to restore my soul.

This is a book that is about the authors different fishing memories about fishing different types of water, from farm ponds, rivers and streams, lakes and the types of fish one is apt to find in each locale.

And I am a sucker for anyone who writes about fishing and hunting in Montana so this book didn't disappoint. Guess maybe someone has to either have experienced the small towns he speaks of or has to have a dream of wanting the experience. Again the book doesn't disappoint.

Also liked his Chapter which the book is named after and as usual he taught me something I didn't know about Brook trout. Page 188 'Brookies were originally introduced into the Rocky Mountains back around the turn of the century on the premise that more fish would be better than fewer fish. That seemed reasonable at the time, but it turned out that brook trout out competed our native cutthroats for food and spawning habitat, and some biologists now trace the decline of many cutthroat fisheries to the introduction of brookie'. 'Brook trout also have loose spawning requirements so they tend to overpopulate, stretch the food supply and become stunted, sort of like bluegills in a pond with no bass to eat up most of the little ones'.

Anyway, the book is a joy to read and I would highly recommend it for any serious or authentic fly fisherman's library.

The beginning was a little slow but it payed off. It ended up being the best book I ever read.