Most Helpful Customer Reviews
8 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
New Book, Old Problem, April 3, 2005
A Kid's Review
This review is from: The Everything Parent's Guide To Children With ADD/ADHD: A Reassuring Guide To Getting The Right Diagnosis, Understanding Treatments, And Helping Your Child Focus (Everything (Parenting)) (Paperback)
Finally someone has written a book that seems to understand the problems that parents and kids have dealing with ADD. She knows that medication is not the only answer to ADD and in fact, bravely offers better solutions by way of food, nutrition, sleep, and PATIENCE...all things that can be done without chemical interventions and will bring about lasting life changes.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Hidden bias, June 22, 2010
This review is from: The Everything Parent's Guide To Children With ADD/ADHD: A Reassuring Guide To Getting The Right Diagnosis, Understanding Treatments, And Helping Your Child Focus (Everything (Parenting)) (Paperback)
Although this book describes itself as an objective resource that provides "clear answers and accurate information", in my opinion, that is a complete misrepresentation. It is actually strongly biased against medication and even ADD/ADHD diagnoses. I don't mind the idea of reading books that are both pro- and anti-medication to get a broad perspective, but this book should not advertise itself as a "one-stop" guide when it only presents one point of view. First it spends one hundred pages trying to convince you that your child may perhaps have lead poisoning, food allergies, or may just be "creative" -- and while these are certainly good things to check out, the book description does not accurately describe how much time is spent on these alternative explanations. There are only a few pages on stimulant medications, most of which is spent heavily criticizing them as pushed by drug companies / horrible side effects / leading to drug abuse, etc. As a parent considering medication, I really needed more than just this brief, biased glimpse at the subject. The "Fact!" sections are a complete joke, in which the author refers to a mysterious "study" which supports her argument, but fails to cite the study or even provide the names of the researchers so you can read it for yourself. I don't understand how this could pass through even the most relaxed editing process to get published. The last hundred pages is devoted to describing how bad parenting is probably responsible for most of the rampant misdiagnosing of ADD/ADHD. Here's a quote from p.125 of the book that pretty much sums up the author's point of view: "Properly used, many over-the-counter treatments produce fewer debilitating side effects than prescription medications. But remember that you are still sending the same wrong-headed, very dangerous message to your child: pills cure problems. Every child (and every adult!) becomes restless and inattentive when bored. It is normal to be upset over problems and to rail at being confined and controlled. The best non-prescription treatments are parenting classes and family counseling. So sign up!" I highly doubt Dr. Sonnes has parented an ADD/ADHD child. To suggest that such children are perfectly normal and just need better parenting is outright insulting and insensitive. I highly recommend the books by Dr. Hallowell instead. He had ADD himself and has parented ADD children, and in addition is a medical doctor, but is not as biased toward medication as you might expect. He still recommends plenty of alternative approaches, but at least he properly backs up all his assertions with real information.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
The perfect guide for ADHD conspiracy theorists, November 26, 2006
This review is from: The Everything Parent's Guide To Children With ADD/ADHD: A Reassuring Guide To Getting The Right Diagnosis, Understanding Treatments, And Helping Your Child Focus (Everything (Parenting)) (Paperback)
This is the ideal book for people who'd like to tell others that their pediatrician or child study team has it all wrong because their kid actually has heavy metal poisoning, Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder, bad nutrition, ineffective parenting, creative genius, or an alternative learning style.
The author writes well and does offer some useful suggestions in child behavior management. However, she appears to have done only the minimal research into ADHD that is required to take snappy pot shots (often in the form of call-outs) at anything that passes for accepted wisdom in this field.
No doubt there is room for debate, but there are many much more informative, more balanced resources if you are genuinely interested in helping a child diagnosed with ADHD. If, on the other hand, you want at all costs to avoid accepted medical treatment -- or are trying to undermine someone else's attempts to help a child -- this is the book for you.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|