23 of 26 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The Most Compelling Evidence I've Ever Seen!, November 10, 2003
This review is from: Evidence: The Case for NASA UFOs (Paperback)
Without a doubt I can entheusiastically say that this is the most compelling evidence for extra terrestial intelligent life that I've ever seen in over 35 years of investigation. Genuine NASA videos! Russian videos! Clear, coherent, logical analysis! All questions are meticulously addressed. But, it's the videos themselves that are absolutely compelling to any inteligent observer. There is more in the book than in the videos alone so I recomend everyone peruse both, and then come to your own conclusion.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
8 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Compelling, yet confusing!, January 4, 2006
This review is from: Evidence: The Case for NASA UFOs (Paperback)
As a UFO believer I have seen the DVD and read the book, and David Sereda DOES offer up some very compelling video footage from various NASA missions. The infamous "Thether" video is explained in full detail and he also offers up some rather "fantastic" theories and solutions of how these UFO crafts are getting around our Galaxy and solar system in literally a few minutes.
David makes a very worthy case of explaining and backing up his throries and assumptions by showing footage and images, but unless you have a firm grasp of physics and how propulsion dynamics and jet engines work, after a while you'll find it hard to chew through.
I really do think that a lot of the footage shown both in the video and the book are explainable as space dust or particles which as been jettisoned from the NASA crafts, HOWEVER that does not account for the rest of the footage that simply defies logic. There are clear cut instances where you really can see "something" displaying intelligence and purpose. These are not just blobs of light all flying around randomly, they appear as disk shaped objects entering and leaving the atmosphere. Some just appear out of nowhere, then dissappear. Some pass close to the camera and you can see the craft like properties.
David also talks about various frequencies these things utilize, which also explains why some are not always visible. Once again it's a "fantastic" assumption, but it might just be true? Even if 10% of his theories were true, then we've got more than enough reason to bump this investigative field into the mainstream and find out what these things want and where they are from?
After reading this, I personally am not still 100% convinced that they are indeed UFOs but they are definately some form of pheonomena that science is still yet to explan. Interesting enough is the radio communication footage from NASA astronauts to Housten - not even the astronauts know what this stuff is, so this also leads me to believe that NASA are either with holding information for good reason, or they are also in the black about what these things are. But when you have retired astronauts coming out of the woodworks to support these claims that UFOs are indeed real, because they've seem them on various missions etc, one cannot help but be skeptical as to NASA's official response to UFOs. After all NASA is mainly made up of Government and Military officials with very little private sector, and it's supposedly various elements within Military and the US Government that are covering all this information up, and have been since the 40's.
I think this book (and the DVD ) are worthy of purchase for any hardcore UFO buff and investigator, as David Sereda does offer some compelling theories. But yes, the DVD is very badly produced, bad video quality and terrible audio and music. But worth the purchase anyway to see these UFOs in action.
With so many books, movies and documentries on the subject, all claming that they have some new startling evidence that's gonna crack open the case it's hard to know where to look for real scientific investigation. Most stuff out there on UFOs is the same old information and footage just re-hashed differently. But this book does give the reader a rather different theory on UFOs. And that alone is a nice break from the usual X-File-ish propaganda that's over flooded the market.
I recommend this book and the DVD, but know that it's not going to be easy reading or watching, but the results can be rewarding for any UFO buff like myself - someone looking for real scientific theories, not just another "Unsolved Mysteries" segment.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
This is a great theory, August 4, 2006
This review is from: Evidence: The Case for NASA UFOs (Paperback)
People who are looking for a superproduction, should not buy this video. For those who want to learn about a new theory regarding physics and UFO cover up, this is the best available.
This video is like a class at school. A blackboard, a teacher and the student. Some nice original footage from Nasa and conclusion by Sereda.
Of course, there are points that you may not agree , but the analisys of the NASA footage is great. His space travel theory is also very convincing. His coclusion about past civilzations that causes more controversy. But these are just assumptions.
Skeptics and video producers, stay away from it!
Open mindeds, ufologysts, physisists and young scientists, buy it, it will open your eyes about many things.
This is a must have for "futurists".
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No