Evolution on Islands: Originating from contributions to a Discussion Meeting of the Royal Society of London [Paperback]

Peter R. Grant (Editor)

Book Description

Publication Date: February 19, 1998

The study of patterns and processes of evolution on islands has played an important role in the development of general theories of how and why evolution occurs. Isolated from the continental process of gene flow, islands may display remarkable rapidity of diversifying evolution, as well as unique species. Evolution on Islands surveys our current knowledge and understanding of microevolution, speciation, and adaptive radiation on islands. Chapters written by experts in the field cover the major trends and processes displayed by plants and animals, on tropical and temperate zone islands, and in lakes and tropical forest refugia. This groundbreaking volume will be of interest to all students and researchers working in the fields of ecology and evolutionary biology.

Editorial Reviews

Review

"Peter Grant has done an especially fine job of editing, contributing not only an introduction to each of the three sections (evolution on islands, speciation, and adaptive radiations), but also a chapter on speciation and hybridization of Galapagos finches and a long and thoughtful summary of the volume. The contributed chapters are almost all excellent, and the book is well worth reading, particularly for those interested in speciation." --Evolution

"This is a counterpart to several other volumes that focus on island ecology, but give shorter shrift to evolution on islands. The very features (isolation, clear boundaries, relatively small size) that render islands attractive for ecological research also make them important subjects of evolutionary studies. For example, what would we know about speciation were it not for islands? . . . The breadth of coverage is striking, spanning matters as diverse as the species-area relationship, through geological fluctuations in lake levels and geographic shifts in tropical forest islands, to the mathematics of population genetic models associated with speciation and maintenance of variation. . . . Evolution on Islands breathes new life into island biology, a subject that had faded somewhat from attention except in the conservation context of the disproportionate endangerment and extinction of island species."--The Quarterly Review of Biology

"Many of the celebrated instances of island evolution are reviewed and evaluated in this edited volume, including such classical cases of adaptive radiations on remote oceanic archipelagoes as Hawaiian drosophilines and lobelioids, Caribbean anoles, Galapagos finches, Polynesian snails, and Canary Islands lacertines. . . . [C]overage is broad taxonomically, geographically, and topographically . . . A central theme of the book is evaluation of the extent to which novel forms on islands are generated predominantly via founder effects alone . . . versus adaptation via directional selection for new phenotypes in new insular environments . . . Certainly there are challenging questions here to keep us engaged for a very long time . . . I note finally that this book owes much of its cohesion to the several overview chapters that are written by its editor. These essays collectively represent a fine synthesis of current thought on island evolutionary processes . . ."--Ecology

"This book will be useful to anyone, professional or lay person, who is interested in evolution and ecology."--BIOSIS, Volume 50, Issue 10

About the Author

Peter Grant is at Princeton University.

Product Details

• Paperback: 352 pages
• Publisher: Oxford University Press, USA (February 19, 1998)
• Language: English
• ISBN-10: 0198501714
• ISBN-13: 978-0198501718
• Product Dimensions: 9.1 x 6.1 x 0.9 inches
• Shipping Weight: 1.1 pounds (View shipping rates and policies)
• Average Customer Review: 5.0 out of 5 stars  See all reviews (1 customer review)
• Amazon Best Sellers Rank: #2,491,614 in Books (See Top 100 in Books)

Customer Reviews

Most Helpful Customer Reviews

1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:

5.0 out of 5 stars As testing grounds for evolution islands remain the classic models for scientists investigating evolutionary processes, September 1, 2009

By 

Trevor Coote "Trevor Coote" (Papeete, Tahiti, French Polynesia) - See all my reviews
(REAL NAME)   

This review is from: Evolution on Islands: Originating from contributions to a Discussion Meeting of the Royal Society of London (Paperback)

Islands are convenient models for scientists investigating evolutionary processes because they are testing grounds for evolution. And now, as the world's species and populations become increasingly fragmented and/or isolated as a result of human activity, information gleaned from evolutionary studies on islands will be vital in informing conservation and management decisions. However, it may come as a surprise to some that in evolutionary biology the term `island' is used to describe any area or patch of habitat that has become geographically isolated and not just volcanic land formations over oceanic hotspots or fragments cut off from continents due to fluctuating sea levels. So, alongside chapters on the intriguing evolutionary radiations of the Hawaiian (Drosophila, lobeliads, honeycreepers) and the Caribbean (anoline lizards) Islands, there are others considering the speciation of rock-dwelling cichlids in Lake Tanganyika and vegetational islands in the Amazon Basin. As a result of this flexibility island evolution remains one of biology's most enduring paradigms.
This extremely varied and comprehensive volume was just about the first to focus exclusively on the evolutionary processes that occur on islands. It consists of a series of chapters (most published elsewhere but modified for this book)) authored by the leading experts in the field and is aimed at fellow biologists. Some of the concepts are intellectually challenging, even for those working in the evolutionary arena, as is evidenced by the number of controversies that have arisen through misinterpretation or misunderstanding. A number of the chapters are contradictory and old debates about the relative importance of genetic drift versus directional selection in island species formation continue to be heatedly discussed, while new disputes such as the role and importance of the founder effect in speciation arise. Despite the temptation for the more mathematically minded theoreticians, pages of differential equations and Greek symbols are excluded from this book. For those laymen who have genuine interest in evolutionary biology a good knowledge of the terminology is required, as well as an awareness of the history of the subject and the main contributors, notably Darwin and Wallace in the nineteenth century and Sewell Wright and Ernst Mayr in the twentieth. Two volumes that would go some way to aiding those with limited knowledge would be John Maynard Smith's standard text Evolutionary Genetics, and the largely non-evolutionary The Theory of Island Biogeography by MacArthur and Wilson.
Since this volume was published there has been an explosion in molecular data and the generation of phylogenetic trees due to the automation of DNA sequencing. This information had contributed greatly to our understanding of historical and genetic processes but there is a caveat. As one group of authors points out in their chapter, these data can be misleading and lead to discordance between morphological and molecular data. This can arise not only as a result of overzealous use or involuntary misapplication but through natural processes such as introgression through hybridization. As such, caution should be exercised when analysing and interpreting molecular data, and it is best used in conjunction with other data. Sadly, there is though still a yawning gap in information from the field and this may now be irreparable as island species are especially vulnerable to extinction through habitat disturbance and destruction, climate change, and the invasion of aggressive, non-discriminatory alien species which constantly arrive due to increasing global traffic.