Paul might know most of the story but he does not know it all, at least from my stand point. I read the same historical data that he read in the Digest. I don't remember it the same way he does, although it is pretty close. I agree, no MJ12 documents are listed in the annex to the Digest. But not all information regarding the program or our historical views are contained in the Digest. I can think of numerous things. None of Blue Book Files are contained in the Digest! Project Blue Book is mentioned but none of the files, especially file 13, are not enclosed. How can Paul explain that? What about the exchange program. None of that is mentioned in the Digest. Paul mentioned some emails ago that Yellow Book contained the visitors story. Well, Paul, as you must know, the Yellow Book only went up to just before Roswell. Ebe 2, provided us with additional information from that point on. JROD was a codename for an Entity, I agree, not Ebe 2 but another one. I read the information and I know Paul isn't correct in his statement about JROD.
As for abductions, I agree with Paul 100%. I did the investigations, about two years worth. I studied the phenomena. I did not find one single piece of evidence to support abductions. The FBI did an extensive investigation, as did NSA and DIA and nothing of facts were found.
The Gate 3 incident occurred in the early 80s, not 2002! you got that wrong.
As for Paul's statements about you, they are his statements. Just because your information don't always agree with his, probably most of the time, doesn't make everything you say false.
I don't agree with his evaluation of the book. I think about 65% of the book is accurate. The remaining 35% is either distorted or wrong. You can correct that information in an updated version.
Paul knew a lot and I respect him for making the statements that he did, but I also knew a lot and he has no idea what I knew and didn't know because OSI information was compartmented and Paul did not have access to it." --Rick Doty,Historical Review, October 24, 2005
Rick C. Doty, Author, Consultant & Writer: In the spring of 1978 he was recruited by the Air Force Office of Special Investigations (AFOSI) to become an agent. He passed all the necessary requirements and tests and was sent to the AFOSI Academy in Washington, D.C. Successfully graduating from the academy he was sent to District 17, OSI, Kirtland AFB New Mexico in May 1979. During that first year he was briefed into a special program. The program involved the collection of intelligence and counter-intelligence information for UFOs and "other foreign intelligence." Recent accomplishments (along with other "associates") include consulting work for both the X-Files and Spielberg's "Taken."
Product Details
Would you like to update product info or give feedback on images?
|
|
Share your thoughts with other customers:
|
||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
21 of 23 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A wealth of inside information,
By
This review is from: Exempt from Disclosure (Paperback)
Robert Collins' new book goes places where few UFO books have gone before. The book is not the most useful for beginners, for they may find themselves overwhelmed within minutes (the subject is labyrinthine, and this book delves into the farthest reaches) - but Collins fully acknowledges this in his introduction. Rather, it's primarily written for those devotees and enthusiasts who already have a fairly sophisticated understanding of the phenomenon and its complex history.
This assumption made about the background knowledge of the reader, the book then launches into a fascinating smorgasbord of inside information, supported by extensive documentation and "deep" sources. The book documents the famous "Aviary" - a group of insiders known by code names such as Falcon, Condor, Raven, and so on - and explores the history of various efforts to release the mass of top secret information which has never yet been made available to the public. All such efforts have so far met with failure, for a number of reasons. Political climate is one, and at the same time there have been differing opinions within the intelligence community about how to deal with this monstrous problem. Disinformation - the deliberate obfuscation of facts with fanciful additives - is rife, this being a favored (and effective) ploy of intelligence agencies: the waters become so muddied that reports are inconsistent and no-one knows any more what to think or believe. There is an extensive section written by Richard Doty (the Aviary's "Falcon"), who in this first addition is listed by Collins as being a co-author. This provides - besides much else - fascinating information about the three extraterrestrial "guests" of the US government over a period of four decades, known as EBE-1, EBE-2, and EBE-3. Doty chronicles an interview with EBE-2 at which he was present, at Los Alamos National Laboratories on 5 March 1983. There is also much detail about the location of secret installations within Air Force bases - supported by an extensive collection of maps and diagrams - and an intriguing section about the notorious "Men in Black". Yet another section features a message exchange with an anonymous Los Alamos scientist who explains, referring to the physics of the flying disks, that "You are assuming that ET crafts are made with our technology... Many years ago, we made that same mistake and it took us several years to correct the mistake and start fresh from the drawing board. "Their" technology is nothing similar to ours. We do not utilize our physics or chemistry in a comparison analysis. We started from scratch and learned their principles of dynamics, physics, etc... The ET craft was manufactured using ET technology. This craft was built many years before we developed flight. They used a different physics principle, that we still don't fully understand. We cannot duplicate the craft's material. We have nothing similar to that material on Earth..." All this, and more. I've only touched on the parts of the book that interested me. If you already know a lot about the subject, buy this book, and you'll know a lot more. Furthermore, at Collins' website [...] - or here at Amazon - you can buy a CD which contains a wealth of information beyond what is supplied in this book. This reader has nothing to gain by promoting this! Just wanting to help make this extraordinary and well documented information available to all.
14 of 16 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
EXEMPT FROM DISCLOSURE,
This review is from: Exempt from Disclosure (Paperback)
EXEMPT FROM DISCLOSURE
Exempt from Disclosure is one blockbuster of a UFO book, this book is not for the Novice, or occasional ufo reader, now with that said, here is what the knowledgeable Reader will find, How the US Policy of UFO's began, starting with President Truman's Executive order, and the EO classifying this subject, and the turning it over to the CIA, Helms,, Angelton, Colby, the various Generals and military people. Who shaped this policy. The Adam and Eve classified orders, LANL, Wright Patterson FTD, Groom, Nevada test site. And the DIA. The roles played by Oppenheimer,Von Neumen, Dr Bush. And the Highly classified Z division at LANL. The true story of the AVAIRY with the added bonus of both authors being members, MJ-12 the beginning how the group came into being, starting with the classified order Signed by President Truman which classified this subject higher then Nuclear Weapons, Which was the highest classified subject in the US gov. MJ-12 team photos, a reunion photo from LANLfrom 2003. Recent members listed. The real reason SDI was created. Dr Eric Wang at FTD. The Vaults at Wright Patterson AFB, the answer to the Hanger 18 riddle, The OROCA committee, TA-49 ( the DULCE complex, the SCIF underground at LANL. The RED, Book YELLOW book, and the commutation device given to us By the EBE'S The Manzano complex ,plant 3. where the device is kept. The backward Engineered Alien energy device, used on the space station. The Mysterious Raven, An Alien Ambassador, this book has layers, and layers, The Authors take you deeper, and deeper, all the while remember that they are Insiders themselves, as are all the people who talk to them,Collins and Doty Let you peek into the Looking Glass of UFO Intelligence, there is Truth, layered With a touch of disinfo, all wrapped into one incredible book! Then if all this is not enough, comes the blockbuster Interview with an Alien on March 5th 1983 at LANL by none other then one of the authors, Rick Doty! Gives a detailed review of this in a SCIF somewhere in LANL! Then more on LANL, The vaults, time capsule, how LANL was involved since The first crash retrieval, and the names of many of the Scientist who were involved! (And I am leaving so much out, ) From LANL on to Wright Patterson FTD and the Real Hanger 18 story, and the location of the Vaults at Wright Pat From there, The Authors take you to Groom lake and the Nevada test site, where recovered, and Backwarded engineered craft are kept, and test flown! Collins, and Doty, have written a truly incredible book, for the serious researcher! The Best UFO book I have ever read! Frank Colacarro I have studied this subject for over 30yrs
13 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
The book title tells the story per Dr. Robert M. Wood,
By Robert M. Wood "Questioned document researcher" (Orange County, CA USA) - See all my reviews (REAL NAME)
This review is from: Exempt from Disclosure (Paperback)
The title of the book describes the status of classified information on UFOs:"Exempt from Disclosure." The record is unambiguous, powerful, and almost unarguable that there are many aspects of UFO or flying saucer reports that have been classified over the years, and this is the first book that provides enough detail to convince many that we have had a deeply covert intelligence involvement with the UFO topic from the beginning.
Share your thoughts with other customers: Create your own review
|
|
Tags Customers Associate with This Product(What's this?)Click on a tag to find related items, discussions, and people.
|