Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
23 of 24 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
I Was Disappointed, December 8, 2008
So far the other reviews all seem satisfied with this new volume so don't let my review put you off from taking a look. Especially if you're one of the few people who's gone through the first ten-plus volumes because your going to want to go ahead and graduate with this one.
Ever since the very first volume when all of the fables made a toast to winning back the homelands the series has been leading up to what is the last three issues collected in this paperback. Willingham says this himself in his afterword and calls the 'War and Pieces' arc a milestone in the series so far. We've been waitng 72 issues for this and here it is, the climax, summed up in three slim issues. I wanted so much more than this and I don't understand how the script came out the way that it did. All of the pieces for a great story are here but it's the execution that leaves it flat. It's filled with excellent and entertaining ideas but it moves so f***ing fast that it feels like more of an outline rather than an actual story. Literally half of the action is gotten out of the way by word baloons. Characters aren't so much the characters we've come to know anymore but vehicles for plot points; they speak in plot points. Subplots from previous arcs that took themselves several issues to be set up are solved here in a single panal. I don't understand how after so much careful planning and time went into this series it would all just be slapped together in the end. I would have been willing to pay twice as much money to have seen this arc spread out over seven or eight issues, maybe more. (Good Prince was 9, and Wooden-soldiers was 8)
I suppose that by now Willingham knows that he has a sure audience and that all they really want is those damn plot points. But I feel, as a reader and fan of the series, that I deserve more than just flashes of sensationalism that the writer thinks I want rather than something I can really immerse myself in, as I could in the first six or so paperbacks. It's really a shame how little this feels like an epic.
After 'War and Pieces' things actually are going to change; alot. Unlike most comic book promise's that the "-universe will change forever." The series is going to have to take an entirely fresh, deep breath which I hope will force Willinham to go back to basics and telling his story without anything to lean on, as he had to do in the beginning. I'll no doubt be buying the next collection so good luck to him.
|
|
|
14 of 16 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Fables at war, November 26, 2008
Some SPOILERS for those who haven't yet read prior FABLES TPBs.
The man crush continues. I'm a late comer to FABLES, but I've been down with Bill Willingham for some time now. I've long held the notion that Willingham's ELEMENTALS was the utter shiznit, but, now, while I still have love for that 1980s series, it's clear that FABLES has surpassed that earlier work. In the multi-award winning FABLES Willingham juggles with dexterity a large cast of characters and continues to develop rich, complex story arcs.
Willingham takes characters from classic fairy tales, from mythology and folklore, and even from literature, and plants them collectively in a residential Manhattan neighborhood (referred to by those in the know as Fabletown). Even as these exiled fables strive to hide their magical nature from the unsuspecting human (or "mundy") population, they exist in constant dread of the terrible Adversary, who drove them out of their Homelands so, so long ago.
Alarming events have shaped the recent years. After centuries of indifference, the Adversary had finally set his eyes on Fabletown. When his attempted invasion failed (see Fables Vol. 4: March of the Wooden Soldiers), Fabletown took retaliatory measures against the Adversary's Empire and struck a devastating blow. The Adversary - whose true identity is none other than Pinocchio's erstwhile kindly woodcarver, Gepetto - means to exact serious friggin' revenge. So it's war now, on the horizon.
By the All-seeing Eye of Agamotto, this series is crazy good, and so enthralling. Bill Willingham has done a wonder with his world-building, and one can sense his love of mythology and folklore by the care he puts into his storytelling. As ever, he lends a gritty believability to his fairy tale cast, invests them with real emotions and fleshed-out histories. And, hurrahs and huzzahs for me, brother, because, after several weeks of catching up, I'm finally to this most recent trade paperback. FABLES Vol. 11: WAR AND PIECES collects issues #70-75, and arrives at that thing Willingham had been working up to from issue one. Fabletown goes to war against the Adversary.
But, before the main event, issue #70 presents "Kingdom Come," which is basically a calm-before-the-storm sort of tale, noteworthy for the last-minute war council among the leaders of Fabletown and also for Boy Blue's confession of love to Rose Red. Niko Henrichon provides cool guest artwork and colors.
Next is the two-part "Skullduggery" as Cinderella, Fabletown's intrepid super spy, takes on a deadly mission to recover an invaluable package but runs into enemy agents. Cinderella, Cinderella - can stomp on any fella. Cindy demonstrates why she's the world's greatest secret agent, and there's also a further development with Rodney and June, spies for the evil Empire.
Even as Cindy is doing her covert thing, the war is already in progress. Narrated in three issues, "War and Pieces" brings to a climax what has been the overriding storyline for this series' entire run thus far. In depicting this all out war between Fabletown and the Empire, Willingham manages to tell a compelling story. The core characters are deeply involved, including Bigby Wolf, my favorite dude. With the Fabletown refugees so outmanned by the Adversary's minions, they have to resort to unconventional war tactics (unconventional in the fairy tale sense). As such, they make good use not only of magic but also of modern mundy technology (guns, explosives, and, yes, bungee cords). The battle plan hinges on three main deployments: a flying wooden ship - manned by European and Arabian fables alike, and powered by many, many magic carpets - out to target the Empire's interdimensional gateways; a secret camp in the Imperial Homeworld, established to serve as Fabletown's last getaway resort and supervised by Bigby Wolf; and the infiltration in the heart of the enemy's capital of a classic fairy tale character, armed with a needle (some points for originality taken away on this one, as this ploy had already been used by Bigby; however, as a military course of action, it really is brilliant).
It starts out well for the good guys as Gepetto's puppet Emperor is befuddled by this unfamiliar brand of warfare. But, then again, he's got the advantage of overwhelming forces, and he employs that. Willingham goes into good detail about the minutiae of running a war, of presenting both sides' military tactics and strategies. And it's nice to see that, with things on the line, there's no one more efficient or reliable than Snow White in running the home office. Most of the story is told thru Boy Blue's perspective, and that's cool, as I've cottoned to this unassuming guy. He and the Witching Cloak are pivotal in Fabletown's schemes.
"War and Pieces" is a rousing story, but not perfect. Firstly, it should've extended past its mere three issues. For an event which took 75 issues to build, this should've been as long as the magnificent nine-part epic "The Good Prince," which came just before. As it is, "War and Pieces" doesn't resonate quite as richly as "The Good Prince." Also, the war felt a bit too one-sided, therefore shedding a bit of that sense of jeopardy. However, having read the ominous issues which follow "War and Pieces," the exiles of Fabletown may soon regret this war even more. Without the Empire's rigid control, old powers again roam the Homelands. There may be worse things than the Adversary, after all. If I read it right, the next FABLES volume will be titled "The Dark Ages," and it should be another excellent entry into the trade collection. It's gratifying to see that Willingham isn't yet parched for plot ideas.
Mark Buckingham and Steve Leialoha are the workhorse artists, and they bring a consistent visual look. As ever, James Jean's covers are marvelous stuff. FABLES: Vol. 11: WAR AND PIECES also features a Willingham afterword and a Buckingham sketchbook. FABLES is very much for mature readers (the content - and, definitely, the language - can get a little raw). Anyway, few can match the richness and complexity of this series. Throw in the occasional snarky humor and Willingham's always diverting fairy tale twists, and what you have is, for my money, the best comic book currently going. I have no doubt that those normally not into comic books will still become rapidly hooked with Bill Willingham's terrific storytelling. And, so, the man crush continues.
|
|
|
5 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
It's War, November 27, 2008
"War and Pieces" is the latest graphic compilation of Bill Willingham's brilliant Fable series. The premise of this series is the characters of folklore and fairy tales really exist. They have been driven to our mundane world by the Adversary, a ruthless conqueror who has taken over their worlds. They now live in New York state either in Fabletown (located in Manhattan) or on the Farm in upstate NY.
If you have not read any of the other graphic novels in this series, don't read any further. In order to understand the series, events and characters, you need to start at the beginning.
The series starts on a lighter note as Boy Blue and Rose Red discuss their relationship as the Fables prepare for war with the Empire. Earlier in the series, Cinderella had incurred a debt to Frau Totenkinder, the Black Forest Witch. In order to pay this debt, she most dodge the agents of the Adversary in order to retrieve and deliver a `package'. In the process, we find out just how formidable Cinderella has become as secret operative. For one she's every bit as ruthless as Bigby. This is something alluded to earlier in the series.
There is a shuffling of the leadership of Fabletown. No one is making a power play. It's more of a reorganization so that the community may more effectively fight the war. The least informed of the inner circle proves to be the Deputy Mayor Beauty. Her confusion is both amusing and disturbing. It's obvious why she was left out of the planning. Despite their `unofficial' capacities, Snow White and Bigby play pivotal rules in the execution of the war.
They launch their attack with daring and cunning. But there are mishaps along the way. We find out exactly what Prince Charming is made of. Fan favorites are injured or worse.
While I found this to be a satisfying addition to the series, it is not the end. There are a lot of questions and loose ends needing resolution. That was fine with me. I really enjoy this series and I can't wait for more stories.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
by Bill Willingham
by Bill Willingham
by Bill Willingham
by Bill Willingham
by Bill Willingham
