14 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Participating in the "Gnostic Renaissance", April 27, 2007
This review is from: The Fall of Sophia: A Gnostic Text on the Redemption of Universal Consciousness (Paperback)
Violet MacDermot translated the Pistis Sophia from the original Coptic text found in Nag Hammadi, Egypt into English as part of the Coptic Gnostic Library effort. Her translation of Books One and Two that focus on the fall of Sophia are reprinted here.
MacDermot here supplements her translation with essays on Sophia's story and the significance of the Pistis Sophia and the Gnostic spirit in general in Western history. The foreword by Stephen Hoeller, "Sophia and the Gnostic Renaissance" adds further to understanding the place of the Pistis Sophia and the ancient Gnostic enterprise in human history.
MacDermot observes that the Gnostic Christians have views that conflict both with that of orthodox Christianity and materialism. Orthodox Christianity seemed to Gnostic Christians demanding of faith and obedience and fearful of self-knowledge. Science today seems too mechanical. From a Gnostic Christian viewpoint, if orthodox Christians complain about science's materialism, it often seems out of a desire to replace it with literalism. Gnosticism offers a third way, one that remembered favorably the ancient Western mythological wisdom of the Persians, Egyptians and Greeks and is today compatible with Eastern wisdom traditions such as Buddhism.
MacDermot follows the spirit of Gnosticism into modern times, presenting a summary of Emmanuel Swedenborg, Otto Weininger, Vladimir Solovyov, Auguste Comte, Rudolf Steiner, Lewis Mumford, Patrick Geddes, Dimitrije Mictrinovic, and Carl Jung, a wealth of leads who presented an organic vision of life. A bibliography of their works and others is included. One can see how the work of the early Gnostics is compatible with and has contributed to similar thought of more recent times
The Fall of Sophia itself is presented as a mythic way to explain the transition from collective consciousness to individual self-consciousness that occurred in the first few centuries of the Common Era. After Jesus finds Sophia fallen, Jesus and his disciples interpret the repentences of Sophia as she finds herself beset upon by evil powers within a chaotic realm. Jesus helps restore Sophia and then shares the mystery of the Ineffable, which can make one a ruler with Jesus, of this world and yet not of this world. By the middle of this story, you may feel like Sophia, overwhelmed by the evil powers. By the end of this story, you may share with the disciples, in an appreciation of the richness of your spirit, something materialism and literalism do not convey.
Macdermot has provided an exquisite context in which to understand the Fall of Sophia and its relationship to some recent thought. If you choose then to read more of the Gnostic texts and/or more of the more recent thinkers Macdermot presents, you may become a participant in a "Gnostic Renaissance" that might transform our challenged society.
Since I first read this book a month ago, it has weighed on my mind. What I had found to be some repetitiveness upon first reading, I'm realizing was a careful reiteration to convey the teaching forcefully.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
The Mystery of the Ineffable, October 23, 2009
This review is from: The Fall of Sophia: A Gnostic Text on the Redemption of Universal Consciousness (Paperback)
Apparently this material is a reprint of another book originally printed by E. J. Brill back in 1978. While this is a new book, it is not new material. However it is interesting to note that E. J. Brill still publishes the hardback version of the complete Nag Hammadi Library.
Stephan Hoeller puts together a good "Forward" to the book; then the author, Violet MacDermot writes two parts to this book. Part one consists of her perceptions of sparse references to Gnosticism from the time that the Pistis Sophia was written until now. Part two is her translation of the Pistis Sophia from Egyptian Coptic to English.
Part one in my opinion is interesting but is uninspiring. The author's modern parallels to the Pistis Sophia are weak. The strength of part one for me was the Carl Jung and Emanuel Swedenborg references/parallels. While these parts were interesting, they were still weak.
Part two is the author's translation from Coptic to English of books 1 & 2 of the Pistis Sophia. While there are 50 footnotes to help understand the Pistis Sophia myth/belief system, you will be left with many unanswered questions that still need at a minimum scholarly interpretation.
For $25 and with the many good Gnostic books that are out there, this is probably the weakest one I have read and owned.
One of the author's only shimmers of light is located in one small section of her Epilogue:
"The development of modern psychology, particularly that of Jung, has enabled us to interpret the myth of the fall of Sophia as expressing the inner experiences of the human soul during the painful transition from collective consciousness to the individual consciousness of today. The myth can also be seen to foretell a further step which humanity will take when individuals unite to experience themselves consciously as one single entity: universal humanity. At the time when the Pistis Sophia was written, that could only have been foreseen as happening in the distant future. In this account, Jesus reveals himself in paragraphs 92-93 as possessing what today we would call universal consciousness. His inner experiences could only have been described to other less developed individuals in mythological terms."
Thus the supreme goal of the "Mystery of the Ineffable" continues to unfold.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No