A very timely and revealing book in light of continued patterns of racially segregated urban housing and discriminatory lending practices; as well as in light of President Obama's community work in Chicago's lower class neighborhoods, Sudhir Venkatesh's three books about the Robert Taylor Housing Projects, and the recent Mortgage Melt-down, to name just a few.
This author has put her finger on the pulse of America's ugly under current and her pen where her mouth is. Mixing family history with sociological facts, Ms. Satter reconstructs the shameful framework of a part of America's racist past that haunts us even as it continues to bear devastating negative fruit for mostly black urban communities across the land, even today.
The overriding fear after reading this book is that this experiment in the most hidden, persistent and pernicious of systemic racism has undoubtedly been that it has been responsible for laying the foundation for a generation of poverty and social misery whose pattern, like an evil template has been repeated throughout the country in almost every major metropolitan area of the U.S.
Arguably, it has been this pernicious pattern that in large measure has been responsible for the hole that other Americans seem to think the black working and underclass has dug all on its own, solely as a result of its own decadent and mal-adaptive behavior.
While the jury still remains out on the final details of the particular shape of America's black social meltdown and the full genesis of its overall pathology, Ms. Satter's book makes a big dent in undermining the logic of that conventional wisdom and makes it unmistakably clear that past racism in U.S. housing policy in the North, played an important if not a decisive role in creating and sustaining the current shameful and embarrassing race-based social order and thus in creating and sustaining the current racist mess our nation continues to find itself in today even with a black President.
Here, with great clarity, wit, with a Sociologist bent, and a profound sense of seriousness, the author shows how redlining, contract selling, lack of access to equitable credit, not only impoverished hardworking and highly motivated blacks, many of them, veterans back from the German front, but these practices also greatly enriched those who benefitted from them and who helped enforce the racist rules and laws. Not surprisingly, as is still the case, among the major culprits was to be found the U.S. Government itself. Just as Fannie Mae,Freddie Mac, and other quasi governmental agencies are implicated today, so too was FHA and other federal housing agencies implicated at the creation of the racist housing mess.
Unfortunately, her personal family tragedy gets played out writ large: Just as her father had no viable recourses to redressing the inequities and unfairness, so too remains the case for a whole generation of black Americans both in the last generation and to a lesser extent, even today -- as is witnessed in the aftermath of the current "Mortgage Ponzi bust-out."
Her research beautifully compliments the ethnographic work of Sudhir Venkatesh and comes to essentially the same conclusions. It also dramatically demonstrates why President Obama's community organizing work in Chicago of a decade ago was destined to fail. A great read.
Five Stars