Most Helpful Customer Reviews
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Wimpy--And not just the male protagonist!, March 30, 2004
Okay, I realize from the other reviews, that I am in the minority of people who really didn't like this book. To me, though, this book lacked passion, originality, a believable plot, and likeable characters (including the little four-year-old girl who needed a lot more discipline than she was getting). Without saying too much as to spoil the ending (but, honestly, was anyone REALLY surprised by the ending?), I just have to say that I just found the whole premise, including the love story, to be ludicrous! Who would list someone as guardian of their child without consulting that person first to make sure that your child would be left in capable, welcoming hands? Did Amy and Arthur really consider Becca and Edward as the parental types? What groom-to-be of such wealth would be such a doormat that he would just meekly go along with a forced wedding in which he didn't love the bride, and really was only expected to show up the day of the wedding? Also, with Edward's incredible wealth, I didn't buy for one moment that he and Becca would have had that much difficulty getting Emily into a preschool. And, I want to know what happens after the book ends (again not to give away the "surprise" ending) (...). This book was filled with unflattering stereotypes and occurrences that were neither plausible or interesting. For those other reviewers who applauded this book for being good "light reading," I think for my light reading, I'll stick to books by Sandra Brown or Linda Howard.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
6 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Predictable, flat and boring, June 20, 2005
Becca Reinhart is a Wall Street workaholic, who has three reactions to anything that happens: she laughs, she smiles, or her eyes sparkle. These are the only personality traits the author has seen fit to give her, and that shallowness persists throughout the entire book. When her friend Amy is killed in an accident, Becca learns she has been named guardian of Amy's four-year-old daughter Emily. A few days later she learns that Edward Kirkland, one of Manhattan's most eligible bachelors, has also been named as Emily's guardian. The three of them move in together into the Upper East Side six-bedroom apartment (count 'em, six) Emily has inherited. (Emily also likes to go to Rumpelmayer's, an ice cream place that actually closed in the 1980s, leaving the reader to wonder if the author knows anything at all about New York City.) The situation -- single man, single woman, one apartment -- is ripe for romance, although for quite a while nothing happens. Given how flat and boring the characters are, it's not surprising neither can find anything attractive in the other. Instead, Becca and Edward spend their time together going to disastrous pre-school admissions interviews for Emily, Becca laughing merrily all the way, and trust me, she's the only one laughing. I assume these scenes were meant to be funny. They're not. Eventually, of course, Edward shakes off his conniving fiancee who wants to send Emily to boarding school in Switzerland (think the baroness in The Sound of Music) and the three do end up one happy family. It's an ending that anybody can see coming from the opening pages of the book; there' s no element of surprise anywhere, although Becca does wear a long orange tutu-like dress for the last chapters. Moreover, you have to wonder where the editor was, since the book is full of passages that would make any English teacher cringe: "'Thanks,' she said, 'but here's the real star,' she said, lifting Emily, who beamed at the pleasure of meeting new people in all her glorious dressups." According to the front of the book, Amanda Brown wrote the book upon which the movie "Legally Blond" was based. The back of the book shows glowing reviews of the movie "Legally Blond." Presumably the plan is sales by association, but it would take more than Reese Witherspoon to help this one.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
decent but nothing extrordinary, July 9, 2004
This review is from: Family Trust (Mass Market Paperback)
I'm a big chick lit reader, and after reading a couple of reviews of this book i decided to get it. I guess my expectations were so high that i was slightly disappointed when i began reading. its hard to have a light and funny story when the first few chapters dive into explaining the contrasting personalites of the two people, and then into the tragic accident. there was not much chemistry or interaction between Becca and Edward. the shining star of the story was little Emily with her bright personality. Even though the book was a decent read, i wouldnt recommend this book as a must read but as a if you are bored and have nothing else, why not read. some books i definitely recommend are "Can you keep a Secret" by Sophie Kinsella, "Boy Meets Girl" & "Boy Next Door" by Meg Cabot. make sure you bring extra books because you will fly through these books.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|