From School Library Journal
Grade 1–4—This simply told tale is based on the true story of Fernando Lopez, who single-handedly changed a barren island in the middle of the Atlantic into beautiful St. Helena, turning it into a stopping-off point for Portuguese sailors as they returned home from Asia. This account gives readers an idea of the recluse's solitary life. The text has a repetitive phrase, "just in case," as groups of sailors visit the island, take what they need, and leave something behind for him to plant or care for. The repetition simulates the back-and-forth motion of ocean waves and the give-and-take transformation of the island. The delicate folk art allows readers to watch as the desolate island becomes a jewel in the middle of the ocean. Large illustrations on every page make this a good read-aloud, and the author's note gives readers additional information on why a man would choose to live in such isolation. Useful as a read-aloud in units on early sea exploration, trade routes to Asia, and Christopher Columbus, this gentle story makes a lovely addition to most libraries.—
Nancy Baumann, Indian Paintbrush Elementary, Laramie, WY Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
An unhappy man jumps ship and swims to a barren island. Over several years, he lives as a hermit, planting grains and fruit trees that grateful sailors leave for him in exchange for fresh food. When summoned to meet a grateful queen, he goes, but asks only to return home. Her seamstress joins him on the little island, which they transform into a verdant garden. According to the appended historical note, this picture book is based on a true story from the sixteenth century. The initial idea that the man wants to be alone because he considers himself “a monster” is not well explained within the tale, but his gradual acceptance of himself as a man, and a happy man at that, is reflected in the gradual transformation of the island from a desolate, lonely land to flourishing garden. Illustrating the somewhat static but ultimately pleasing story are precise, lovely paintings that combine the innocence and directness of folk art with an unusual delicacy of vision. Preschool-Grade 3. --Carolyn Phelan