Customer Reviews

Farmer

5 star:		(5)
4 star:		(2)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

My sister, Christmas 1981, gave me LEGENDS OF THE FALL. I read it with a sinking vertigo occassioned by the haunting question, How - how could the guy write like that? To find out so that I might accomplish a paler emulation, I read every single word the guy had ever written. But nothing touched me as much as his novel, FARMER. Thin as a ghost in a mirage, this novel explores the affair a gimp middle-aged farmer and schoolteacher has with one of his students. The setting, rural middle-Michigan in the 50s, is SO unurbane, so unsophisticated, that you can smell the manure that Joseph, the twisted-legged yet mythic hero, one cold October morning spreads atop his crunching fields while abysmally hung over. And the woman his age that he deeply loves, Rosealee, is so wonderfully rendered that I spent the novel half-hoping Joseph WOULD indeed abandon her so that I could step inside the book and have her for my own. Finally, the story of their heartbreak and loss, is told in what is a poet's visionary and renengade voice, a voice gruff with whiskey, piercing and memorable with despair. If LEGENDS gave me vertigo, FARMER made me leap over the edge.

I was but two pages into the book when I read the line "He pokes at the ocean with his cane,staring at it with the raptness he felt for the northern lights as a child." And I wept. I grew up in the Upper Penninsula of Michigan and have stared at the northern lights with that same raptness. No other author captures the uniqueness and wonder of the place and the people like Jim Harrison. He understands the soul of the land and of the people who live there. His imagery and attention to detail are masterful.

I read Harrison's FARMER in one sitting, then made a pot of coffee, and read it again. I recall that I was terribly sad upon finishing, only because the sublime experience had ended. FARMER has no flaws that I can detect. It is simple and has a fierce ecomomy. Tiny book, BIG,BIG story. This is a fine book.

Jim Harrison is a contemporary american writer worshipped in Europe but, alas, not so well known in his native country. In FARMER, a novel published in 1975, Jim Harrison writes about nature, origins and the heart of America.

Joey is a farmer, an american of the second generation, and the year is 1956. He lives in the northern part of the Michigan state and is one of the teachers of the local school. His sisters have left the country years ago, heading towards the big cities, and abandoning him with their mother. Joey likes to hunt and to fish. It's a simple story.

During a 6 months period, Joey is going to have a kind of rebellion against his so regular life, a nervous breakdown to use a term of the cities. New experiences, long conversations with his neighbour Doc Evans, the contact with nature will replace the tranquillizers. It's an healthy story.

The themes treated in FARMER are universal : love, death, friendship, regrets. The reader cares about Joey's story and understands his simples questions we have all experienced once in our lives. If only we had the courage to face them so openly like Joey did. in this superb novel.

A book to discover.

I "discovered" Jim Harrison while in college thirty-some years ago when I read of his first novel, Wolf: A False Memoir. When he mentioned Reed City in the first line of that book, I was hooked. I never imagined that the little town where I grew up would ever make the pages of good fiction. I shouldn't have been surprised though. Jim Harrison did some growing up in Reed City too. His dad, Win Harrison, was the county agent here. The Harrisons moved away to the Lansing area around 1949, but Jim still credits Reed City as a formative influence in his memoir, Off to the Side. There have been a lot of Harrison books since Wolf, and I've read most of them, but, in re-reading it recently, Farmer still holds up well after more than 30 years. In fact, I still think it is his best novel. It is so much more than just a love story, although it certainly is that. It is a tale of lust and longing, but also one of regret and redemption. Joseph Lundgren, the title character, is at once complex and simple. He is Everyman. In Wolf, the protagonist looked for a wolf in the wilderness mountains of Upper Michigan in the sixties - a time when wolves were all but gone from the state. That same theme - chasing a ghost animal of an earlier time - shows up again in Farmer, when Joseph tries to get a glimpse of a coyote. What he finally sees is no more than a blur for "a tenth of a second." What the middle-aged teacher/farmer Joseph wants in his ill-advised affair with a beautiful high school student is nearly as impossible to define as that search for the elsusive and all-but-extinct coyote. "I wanted to be carried away," he says, trying to explain things to his twin sister. And, at least for a little while, he succeeded. And, while I know there is no "political correctness" about this thirty year-old novel, any man today who can still be honest about his real feelings and simply say the hell with propriety and political correctness, will understand Joseph and what he did. Harrison puts you inside Joseph's skin. You feel his despair, his regrets, his longing for something more. Farmer may be a very short book, but it is as nearly perfect as a novel can ever hope to be. - Tim Bazzett, author of the Reed City Boy trilogy (RatholeBooks.com)

Jim Harrison is a fine writer, I found this a bit hard to get through. It didn't pique my interest. It could have been when I read it, but it just didn't do it for me. It is a stark book. He is a middle aged man and farmer, he's having an emotionless affair with an 18 year old student from the school he taught at which has closed down. The affair fulfills what another woman he is having an affair with can not fulfill. His mother has just died, he seems to resent that he spent his younger years taking care of things and not his own wants. The writing is beautiful, I just couldn't muster up the care to like the story.

I'm buying these books for my husband, seems Jim Harrison is his favorite author. Books arrive very timely and happy with purchases

You can read the summary from the other reviews, so I'll just offer a few brief comments.

The book is small, but it has depth. It's as if Harrison started with a 500 page novel and pared it down to its 176 pages. His economy is remarkable and highly effective.

At first, the book seems fragmented. But as it progresses, Harrison keeps filling in the puzzle, which makes the story exciting and satisfying. Several times I found myself thinking, "I wonder if he is ever going to explain this..." But he takes his time, coming around to key events when he needs to, always to maximum effect. So if some things seem tangential, keep reading. All the pieces fit to fill in the bigger picture.

I read quite a lot, and much of it is "literary" fiction. But I have to say, Farmer is one of the saddest books I've read in several years. That's a pretty good trick from a writer who has a reputation as an outdoorsy "tough guy." But Harrison understands what makes men tick--our good traits, our weaknesses, and that fine like we walk between the two.

Farmer is my introduction to Harrison, but be assured that I'll be reading more. Sometimes big things come in small packages. So be sure to give this one a chance.