Most Helpful Customer Reviews
3 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
from the book cover..., August 7, 2003
By A Customer
CUCKOO WAS COMING...No one knew what it was--but everyone knew it was trouble. Designated Object Lambda when it first appeared on the fringes of the galaxy, 20,000 light-years away, it was traveling at one-sixth the speed of light. The astrophysicists said that it was vast...light....and had the potential for utter destruction. So an existing space probe was reoriented to intercept; it was staffed with replicates of both humans and aliens. Then the probe began to leak radiation.... FRom top info page:
Tachyon transmission was a marvelous invention. A man could send infinite replicates of himself anywhere in the galaxy---wherever duty called. If one of the copies got killed, so what? The original would still be alive and well back on his home planet, and he could always send replacements. Such a man Ben Pertin, who lived on Earth. And then there was:
Ben Charles Pertin---stationed on Sun One, central headquarters of the intelligent races in the galaxy.
Ben James Pertin--sent to the probe ship Aurora after Ben Frank Pertin was reported missing on board.
Ben Linc Pertin---dispatched to the artificial satellite orbiting Cuckoo.
Ben Yale Pertin---one of the several Pertins sent to explore the surface of Cuckoo. Some returned---many did not. And most of them were in love with the same woman!"
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2.0 out of 5 stars
Disjointed Loose Ends, July 11, 2011
This review is from: Farthest Star (Mass Market Paperback)
There is a strange object called "Cuckoo" heading toward our galaxy which won't arrive for tens of thousands of years. But the book doesn't say why it is dangerous. Nor why it is already known to be strange about it even before anything much is known about it. (Objects and even entire systems pass through a galaxy all the time and, given the vast empty spaces, don't collide with or interact with any stars or planets.) We find out that it is a huge "planet". It doesn't orbit a star, but we're not told why the inhabitants don't freeze to a solid block of ice with no star to provide heat or energy. These are some of the crucial "plausibility" questions the book leaves hanging out there freezing to death in intergalactic space.
I'm old school: If you are going to raise a lot of really fundamental questions which 'drive' the book and are what keeps the reader in suspense, then don't cheat them. Answer the driving puzzles in some way by the time the book ends (don't leave -all- of them for a sequel which the reader may not have heard of or get to). A much better book which has a strange kind of surface which contains life is Larry Niven's "Ringworld". Unlike in this book, Niven actually does a rather good job scientifically or logically -explaining- things.
A second type of flaw in the book is too many strange aliens and 'replicants' moving in and out of the action without much attempt at character development. Another major flaw: there are several characters pining for the romantic interest in the story. Not only is her characterization thinner than that of "the girl" a summer action movie, but this subplot is wrapped up and resolved in a perfunctory and not very convincing manner.
A positive aspect (which makes me give it at least some stars) is the interesting galactic civilization and the interesting "planet". If only they had been in service of a more sensible, more clear story.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2.0 out of 5 stars
Written by two authors yet still starved of attention!, October 1, 2009
This review is from: Farthest Star (Mass Market Paperback)
Frederik Pohl is a grand master of science fiction with classics from the 1970s such as the Heechee Saga, Man Plus and the Space Merchants. Jack Williamson is another respected science fiction author with popular novels from the 1930s until the millennium. Combining the two forces for the greater good of forming a new science fiction series, what could possibly go wrong? Just about everything.
The sub-genre of BDO (big dumb object) in sci-fi is genre favorite. The premise in Farthest Star is called Object Lambda or Cuckoo which is speeding towards the galaxy and more specifically towards our own solar system. Inhabiting this not-dense-enough object is a collection of mutated aliens (including humans) which mirror the plots' aliens physiology. Part I entitled `Doomship' is a 3-star read revolving around the human-alien cooperation in a ship which is decelerating to a dangerous degree and also spewing radiation on its crew. The plot addition of human replicates from tachyon copy travel is of a little interest, which adds one little star to the novel. Acidic algae, steam powered rocket packs and friggin' dragons were really low points in the plot which had me putting down the book in order to reader another book of better quality (Earth by David Brin). Part II called `The Org's Egg' is three-fourths of the book includes all the low points mentioned above.
The book doesn't warrant a second read through and it doesn't motivate me to read the sequel.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|