Customer Reviews

Fatal Decisions: Errors and Blunders in World War II

5 star:		(1)
4 star:		(0)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

When I first saw this book, it was on sale in a bookstore for very cheap. I had some money so I bought it, figuring if it was bad, at least I didn't waste a lot of money on it. However now that I have read it, it has become one of my favorite books! It tells little known stories of WWII and all of them are very interesting. Like the synopsis says "some will make you laugh, and others will make you cry". I recommend this book to anyone, not just history buffs, because it is a wonderfully written book about events you normally wouldn't hear about from the standard WWII books.

Copy from the front book flip (to me, a very accurate description of the book): In the heat of battle it is all too easy for the fighting man to become disoriented, confused or to misread a tactical situtation. This is true of any fighting unit operating in the air, on land or at sea. By today's standards, communication facilities in WWII were primitive, unreliable and prone to enemy interception. It is these major factors which are generally at the root of the incidents of war that are included in this book.

IMHO, the 69 incidents in this 236 content page book are very interesting indeed. However, I am obliged to comment that if the author had employed a good editor, the outcome will be far better. Frequently I had to read the same passages several times to make sure I understood the whole stuff. In case you are a fan of war stories, this one will satisfy you well. If you know little about WWII and just want to read for leisure, I suggest you to give this a pass.

Below please find one of the shortest incident "The Bodenplatte Aftermath" for your reference.

On New Year's Day 1945, while Allied troops and airmen were to some extent celebrating, over 1000 German planes struck in Operation "Bodenplatte", able to take the Allied air bases on the continent completely by surprise. But, if the Allies blundered by not waking up until too late, the enemy too made an error that proved devastating to the attackers. First, eighteen Polish Spitfires, about twelve other Allied planes and several petrol bowsers went in flames at St Denis Westrem in Belgium. At Brussels, eighty five planes were destroyed on the ground. At Eindhoven in Holland a Canadian unit lost all its Typhoons. The Germans claimed 439 Allied planes destroyed on the ground or in the air, admitting a loss of ninety-three. But on their return flights a further 184 German aircraft fell victim to their own flak gunners, who had not been warned of these planes' routing.