Most Helpful Customer Reviews
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Provocative Novel, April 23, 2001
The speaker in Nunez's touching novel struggles with issues concerning her cultural identity, her relationships with her parents, and her relationships with men. She constantly deals with how her genes, her parent's cultures, and her upbringing in America have come together to form a cultural identity. As the daughter of a Chinese-Panamanian father and a German mother, the speaker grows up with two distinct cultural influences. She finds herself pulled in different directions, unsure of what aspect of her should define her cultural identity more, or if it is possible to find a balance between them all. The speaker also reexamines her relationship with her parents and her obsession with ballet through nostalgic memories and insight. Through her writing, the speaker comes to terms with her parents' unhappy marriage as well as the notion that her love of ballet stemmed from a desire for perfection and escape from her dysfunctional family. The reader will find that Nunez spins a memorable story that thoroughly engages the reader, and is a must read for anyone interested in issues concerning immigration, multiculturalism, coming of age in a culture that rewards beauty and thinness, identity, and international relationships.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
honest and spare, October 15, 2001
There were many reasons I felt I had to read this book (my interest in writers even vaguely Latin American being one of them) and I am glad that I did. My favorite part was definitely "Immigrant Love," the last section of the book, where the narrator has an affair with a Russian immigrant. "He has no curiosity at all about me. After all, I am only a woman; facts about me can't be very important." One of the most honest portrayals of the complexities of human relationships that I have ever read. As a dancer, I found "A Feather on the Breath of God," the third section, interesting and surprisingly foreign to my own experience, but none the less enriching to read. The novel's spare structure makes you feel the necessity of every word on the page.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
"Human Beings are capable of passion that human experience can never live up to." (TS Eliot), December 21, 2005
The protagonist writes from the perspective of a childhood bound by the separate histories of her parents: a Panamanian-Chinese father who is sixteen years older than her German mother when they meet on V-E Day in Germany, later moving to America with few financial resources. Two daughters later, they marry and the third daughter, the narrator, is born. After the workaholic father's premature death, the German-born Christa becomes the focus of the next part of the story. Christa is an enigma, a beautiful woman who spurns the interests of men and the friendships of women, proud of her English skills, albeit with the occasional slip of the tongue ("They stood in a motel for a week"). This cross-cultural family remains essentially unassimilated, moving from project to project in New York. Plagued by periods of rage and depression, Christa's home holds no warmth, the daughter stepping lightly through her mother's moods.
Drawn to the ballet at twelve, the girl adores the combined smells of sweat, rosin and Jean Nate: "Everything about the world of ballet responds to the young girl looking to escape real life." And for a time, this is heaven. The authoritarianism is familiar, but in ballet it has purpose, a means of transcending the small world of the projects. Ballet celebrates the female, is dominated by her ability to enact precise turns and intricate moves. Of course, the almost boyish figure of a ballerina activates a horror of pounds, eating disorders feeding on the paranoia of weight gain: "In dance, pain was often inseparable from desirable feelings." Although the narrator doesn't claim an eating disorder, this flirtation with dance is but one more chapter in her life. Eventually, she is teaching an ESL class to immigrants and has an affair with a married Russian, Vadim. Her lover shoots up heroin, but that is preferable to the violence incurred when he is drinking vodka. This phase is short-lived, if unexplained, the protagonist headed toward the next chapter.
There is no beginning, middle and ending to this fiction, merely a sequence of events. Nunez is what I call a patchwork writer, relying on anecdotes to move her tale along, but without a passionate commitment. Uses a cast of assorted immigrants to spin out stories, the author fills the years as the girl grows older, but she hides behind this ploy, her identity cleverly obscured by the characters. Nunez supplies the facts (and quotations), as well as the answers to endless rhetorical questions, but that bone deep honesty that allows me to love a writer's work is missing. How much more powerful would these immigrant tales be if Nunez allowed herself to truly inhabit these characters? Luan Gaines/ 2005.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|