From School Library Journal
PreSchool-Grade 1–This unique book is rendered in soft gouache watercolors, bestowing a traditional Old World look that is full of warmth and charm. Simplicity is the key, as nature's bounty is visually transformed into human treasures. An acorn turns into a tree, the Earth's clay becomes an artistic pottery piece, wheat becomes bread, and a caterpillar becomes a butterfly. Children will marvel at nature's wonders and will be ready to join in the dancing as the fiddle produces a song. This is a great read-aloud and a good choice for early readers. Combine it with Verna Aardema's
Bringing the Rain to Kapiti Plain (Dial, 1981) for an artistic visual program about nature.
–Wanda Meyers-Hines, Ridgecrest Elementary School, Huntsville, AL Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
PreS-Gr. 2. While many picture books use foldout pages to reveal what's hiding behind an object, this one shows the potential hidden within the object. "In an acorn . . ." reads the text on the first double-page spread, a picture of a large acorn atop a colorful pile of autumn leaves.^B An opaque overlay on the right-hand page unfolds upward to reveal an oak and complete the sentence with "is a tree waiting to grow tall." Even if they are a bit baffled during a first run-through, repeat listeners will quickly learn to connect acorn with tree, clay with pot, wheat with bread, and so on. One somewhat confusing image ("In the thread is a weaving waiting to be spun") remains forgettable, but the other nine are more precise and satisfying. Gentle hues and rounded shapes unify the gouache paintings, which depict the concepts in a variety of settings from desert to meadow to homespun interior. With rhythmic phrasing and rhymes (or near-rhymes) at some sentence endings, the verse is evident when read straight through. Many children, however, will find it more satisfying to pause and talk about the ideas that arise as the pages unfold.
Carolyn PhelanCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved