Customer Reviews

Fiddlers: A Novel of the 87TH Precinct

5 star:		(18)
4 star:		(6)
3 star:		(6)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

Sadly, Salvatore Lombino, alias Evan Hunter, alias Ed McBain has gone to his just rewards.

No other writer has been as consistently good for as long as McBain, who started this series in 1956. Admittedly, I did not like the 87th Precinct novels at first, but I became hooked when I bought a three-for-one anthology at a booksale. Police procedurals stress plot over characterization and it took me that long to get to know Steve Carella, Meyer Meyer, Cotton Hawes, Burt Kling and the rest.

McBain is a master at weaving together subplots, and FIDDLERS is no different. The detectives of the 87th are on the trail of a serial killer who seems to be targeting senior citizens: a blind violinist, a cosmetics sales rep, a college professor, a priest, and an old woman out walking her dog. We also get a brief look at Carella's personal life as his thirteen-year-old Twins are growing up. There's also some social commentary as Burt Kling deals with his bi-racial relationship. The novel ends with a hook, pointing toward the next in the series: Fat Ollie's love affair with Patricia Gomez seems headed for trouble as he turns to Andy Parker, of all people, for advice.

I have a feeling McBain was working right down to the end, as he often completed two novels a year, as McBain and his alter ego Evan Hunter. But if there are no further Precinct novels, I plan to start all over with COP HATER and THE MUGGER if I can find them. Although McBain always kept some 50s elements in his newer work, it'll be fun to compare the early work with his modern stuff.

God speed, Salvatore!

Fiddlers is the latest (and, given the recent death of author Ed McBain, presumably the last) of the remarkable series of "87th Precinct" police procedural novels -- more than fifty books published over a period of fifty years. The usual cast of detective characters is here: Steve Carella, Meyer Meyer, Kling, Brown, Parker and even Fat Ollie Weeks. And as has been the focus of the last several 87th Precinct novels, the story is as much about their personal lives as about the crimes they investigate. There is a serial killer on the loose, but a serial killer murdering at a furious pace -- a new victim every few days, two bullets fired into the face. But what connects the victims? A blind violinist, a cosmetic sales rep, a college professor, a retired priest ... "Fiddlers" in the end is about relationships. Beginning relationships, ending relationships, relationships too fleeting to have a proper beginning or ending, destructive relationships, redemptive relationship.

If this is indeed the final 87th Precinct novel, then it was a fine note on which to end the symphony.

Though it had to be, what a shame to end the series on such a downbeat note, with Steve Carella's little April, once the apple of his eye, turning into a gang girl, and her opposite number, the boy twin, becoming a snitch, a rat, of the worst description, telling on April as soon as it's convenient. Those twins once were the highwater mark of cute kids in the detective novel, now they're just like slimy movie kids. Their mother seems incapable of keeping up with the changes puberty brings. Yes, she can sign "No drugs!" as loudly as she can, and it may work the first time, but eventually the kids will do their own thing, rebelling against the unusual home setup (obsessed cop dad and signing Mom) and wanting to be like other more normal families.

However, Ed McBain's tragic death deprives us of resolution, and I expect something in the man delighted in this, for he had a pretty good opinion of himself and, much like you and I, considered himself one of the great American novelists. Irreplaceable. I for one don't want any V C Andrews scam occurring to the 87th Precinct series. We loved him for his writing pure and simple.

FIDDLERS is pretty good and it's miles better than that wretched book where Ollie Weeks was writing a novel, remember that? Its lame parody of bad writing, presented in standard 87th Precinct facsimile form? Yikes was that awful. This one is much better, and although the actial revenge plot borrows quite a bit from Cornell Woolrich's two 1940s thrillers THE BRIDE WORE BLACK and RENDEZVOUS IN BLACK, the addition of the red-headed prostitute, Reggie, turns the human interest up a notch, so we become interested in the unlikely pairing of serial killer and call girl.

Why "FIDDLERS" though? OK, the first victim played the violin. Maybe there's some larger, overarching metaphor here. Funny thing that FIDDLERS should be Ed McBain's last book, while FIDDLERS THREE was the last play that Agatha Christie wrote. Nothing but a coincidence, but I'm just saying.

A blind violinist. A cosmetic sales rep. A priest. A professor. All over fifty and all shot two times point blank in the face. This horrific scenario is given to the detectives of the 87th Precinct to solve, with no clues. In this suspense novel, it is the dialog that pushes the plot along, a rhythm that builds, clue by clue, character by character. Along the way we get to know the detectives of the 87th Precinct: Carella, Meyer, Burns, Parker and Oliver Wendell Weeks. Sharing intimate portraits of their personal lives, the detectives work a bizarre set of serial murders with their usual professionalism, solid police work.

The detectives take to the streets, hitting night clubs, raves, any and all venues with the potential for shifting quantities of illegal drugs. The trail leads one way, then another, but they can get no fix on the motive for the killings. Meanwhile the murderer keeps busy, dropping new bodies while the cops are mid-stride chasing the last one. As the chapters alternate the crimes and private glimpses into the daily lives of the men who work the 87th, a pattern slowly emerges; it doesn't fit any previously known serial killer, but eventually an identity emerges, a man with a vengeance.

Even in the midst of these heinous crimes, the author inserts humorous asides, usually relating to the detectives' personal problems, humanizing the men who deal with everyday violence, a mix of crime and the mundane details that make up police life. McBain sprinkles the pages with eccentric characters, dope dealers, students, ex-husbands, all with pitch-perfect dialog that feels like eavesdropping on a private conversation. The 87th does their footwork by the book, gradually narrowing their suspects. This particular murderer plots his revenge for a painful past, a revenge he prefers served cold. But that's the thing with resentments...they'll kill you. Luan Gaines/2005.

Five stars for the book, but I'm really writing a tribute here to this man, whom we unfortunately lost this year.
McBain was unbelievably prolific and successful--over 100 million books sold. You would think that a writer with such popularity must be writing lightweight, low common denominator trash. You would be wrong.
McBain knew how to write. He knew character, dialog, and plot as well as any novelist--and better than most.
I teach literature and writing at a Florida university. My comrades in the department are busy writing poetry and exploring obscure "literary" writers. I doubt if many of them have ever read McBain--too lowbrow. Too bad for them.
Good literature involves the reader personally because he or she cares about the characters and what happens to them. Good literature provokes insight and analysis because of the moral and ethical issues that are presented. Good literature appeals to our sense of humanity.
McBain never failed to do that in all his years of writing. I'm going to miss Steve Carella, Matthew Hope, and all of the other great McBain characters. They were real people--good people that we cared about (except for maybe Fat Ollie--but I'm even going to miss him!).

"Fiddlers," by the late Ed McBain, is a worthy finale to the long and illustrious career of a true grand master. An unknown assailant has been murdering both men and women, all of whom are over the age of fifty. The victims were all shot in the face with the same weapon--a Glock. Since the first killing occurred in the jurisdiction of the 87th precinct, Carella, Meyer, Parker, and their colleagues catch the case. The detectives follow up every lead painstakingly, and their thorough investigation reveals a motive that has its roots in a series of events that occurred many years ago.

McBain's writing style is unique and refreshing. He never indulges in purple prose, clichés, or needless exposition. The dialogue is energetic and witty, and the action never flags. Another hallmark of McBain's novels is their ambiguous and complex world view. McBain doesn't present the reader with one-dimensional characters who are easily pigeonholed, nor does he tie up every loose end. Good people sometimes suffer, bad people often go unpunished, and mistakes cannot always be undone. In McBain's universe, life is unfair and it's up to the individual to cope as best he can.

McBain captures the grittiness of modern urban life. He describes how people of various ethnic groups desperately compete for their share of the American dream, either legally or otherwise. All of the 87th Precinct novels convey the dark side of living in the big city, with its profanity, racism, and various criminal elements who routinely deal in drugs, prostitution, and murder. "Fiddlers" has a large and colorful cast, including the aforementioned detectives, a slightly slimmer and mellower Ollie Weeks, and an angry perp with a long memory. McBain humanizes his cops, showing us not only their ability to work a homicide, but also providing a window into their family lives, romances, hopes, and disappointments. We grow to care about them as much as we care about the work that they do. This book is a powerful, touching, and poignant look at what makes us human--our desire for love and respect and for some, the need to blame others for their failures. "Fiddlers" represents McBain at his best. What more could anyone want?

I have read 87th Precinct novels for 45 years and always enjoyed them. I didn't dislike this one but have no trouble believing it was the author's last work. It is very dark and focused on our mortality. His own looming death was obviously on the author's mind as he wrote this story. It doesn't bother me that death is so much a part of part of the book, that's to be expected. It's that depression clings to the whole book. I was kind of sad the author went out on this note.

Ed McBain died in July, but "Fiddlers," the 55th book in his series about the detectives of the 87th Precient, doesn't seem so much like a send-off as a continuation.

A series of killings all tied to the same gun indicate that a serial killer is on the loose in Isola, McBain's reimagined New York City, but this one is not playing by the rules. The majority of them prey on women and go for weeks, even months, between killings. This one is different. The victims include a blind violinist is shot outside the restaurant where he works, a woman killed while cooking an omelet in her apartment, a cosmetic sales rep on her way home from work, an elderly Catholic priest. All shot with the same Glock and all over the age of 50. What is the connection?

It was 49 years ago, with the publication of "Cop Hater," that McBain turned the police procedural into a multi-facted, multiple viewpoint story that took the reader beyond the case and into the private lives of the officers. With the 87th acting as the stage, we followed the officers as they worked and talked and argued, grew older, fell into and out of relationships, moved on to other things and even retired. The passage of time was reflected also in the changes seen in the city, giving the earlier novels the feel of walking into a time machine.

Given McBain's declining health, it's surprising that "Fiddlers" is as good as it is. The story moves along quickly, the dialog sharp and contemporary and the solution understandable and satisfying. And at the end, there's a feeling that life in the 87th will go on, even if McBain is not here to tell us about it. He will be missed.

Having read more than half of the fifty-five 87th precinct novels written by the recently deceased Ed McBain, I think they break down into two categories. First, there are those that grip you from the get-go and, more important, can be read as an enjoyable" stand alone" novel even if you are not a fan. The three that come to mind for me are "Ice," "Lullaby" and "Hark." On the other hand, there are the ones that are seemingly a bit more plodding but if you are into the characters and McBain's style, you will stick with the book more as a fan and a way to continue watching your old pals move on with life. For me, Fiddlers fits into the latter category. Not as good as his previous work(the aforementioned "Hark") but decent enough where if you stick with it, the end result will be bittersweet - a good read tinged with the sadness this is the end of a landmark series.

A series of execution style murders, with the victims all being old enough to apply for their AARP membership, gives just about the entire group of recurring 87th precinct detectives their moment in the spotlight. Most of the detectives we have seen in this series all get a murder tossed their way and the fun is in us following them on their investigation. Of course, the climactic moment when everyone has to come together to connect the dots is vintage McBain.

As I mentioned, this book may not be a great starting point for a non-fans since I believe the investigation is more fun to read when you know the detectives already. Yet if you are a fan, this is a must read just so you can say a fond farewell to a writer who truly set a standard others may never be able to duplicate.

If you have never read an Ed McBain/87th Precinct Novel, where have you been? This end is not the place to start - as the author trusts that we have remembered his unforgettable characters sufficiently that pains are not taken to re-introduce them. Best you start back - way back - in 1956 and enjoy the ride with these all-too-human cops and criminals - who have not aged according to the chronological calendar, but who shall remain, if not forever young, at least forever time-lapsed.
Ed McBain, father of the police procedural as we know it, which spawned Hill Street Blues and other cultural icons, has written his last 87th Precinct potboiler. Whatever will happen to all our beloved and not-so-loved characters? Will April Carella be spared from Reefer Madness? Will Ollie become not-so-Fat and bed Patricia? Is there an heir-apparent to carry on the tales? Pray not Whoever is writing Lilian Jackson Braun's Cat-Who-s or the Gawd-Awful *Scarlett* in response to which Margaret Mitchell should righteously and rightfully rise up from her grave and smite Ripley and her own heirs who allowed that abomination!
Faithful followers of McBain's Boys and Girls of the 87th, plead to his publishers not to let some ghastly ghostwriting idiot fiddle around and ruin it all. Let the legend live on with the same clever wit and crisp, clipped style to which the characters and readers are accustomed. /TundraVision, Amazon Reviewer.