| ||||||||||||||||||
Product Details
Would you like to update product info or give feedback on images?
|
|
Share your thoughts with other customers:
|
||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
8 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Read It and Weep -- and laugh a lot, too,
By kbwong (United States) - See all my reviews
This review is from: Field Guide to the Irish Music Session: An Authoritative Guide to Enjoying Irish Traditional Music in its Natural Habitat (Hardcover)
The only people I know who don't like this book are people who don't do well at Irish sessions for the very reasons Mr. Foy gives. Funny thing, that. If you want to fit in and aren't Irish (ie: didn't grow up in Ireland, and are therefore completely experienced in the intricacies of Irish society), get this book, read it, and believe it. If you don't end up using the stuff in here, great. You're gold. If you DO need it, then you'll have it. Great. You're gold.The people I know who don't like this book always call it "elitist" -- interesting, if you think about it long enough. I should also point out that Irish people think a book of something like this is ridiculous -- unless they've lived outside of Ireland and regularly suffered through a session that has been so hammered into another shape that it's really not a session anymore, and then they are ALL for this book (and you'll note Martin Hayes writes a plug for it, among others). Irish sessions are often changed beyond belief to the point where they're no longer Irish sessions (or at least, sessions of traditional Irish music). Anyway, it's called "traditional" music for a reason, and if you don't like it or all the etiquette attendant upon it, then go make your own music, just don't sully either your own music nor Irish traditional music by calling it by the wrong name. Oh, and by the way -- "etiquette" has somehow become a bad word, I'm not sure how. It's worth remembering that there's an "etiquette" to inviting your friends over for pizza and beer or hanging out at the mall -- "etiquette" isn't relegated only to weddings and formal occasions. An extremely famous Irish fiddler once told me that there are sessions where he's glad that the participants are having fun, that they're doing something better than watching TV and all, but he would rather not be there. If you don't want to be the one to make an experienced player feel that way, get the book. P.S. Oddly enough, I recognize most of the names giving reviews. This is a very small society over the globe, this society of Irish musicians.
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Indispensable guide to listeneing, watching, playing...,
This review is from: Field Guide to the Irish Music Session (Hardcover)
A definite must for the ignorant hoi poloi (such as myself). Extremely witty, from the acknowledgements, in which the author acknowledges his own genius, to the glossary (Alpha male/female: .. the woman with the loudest instrument or the man with the biggest one). The rather odd illustrations indicate why the Irish are known for literature and music, but not for graphic arts.
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Sarcastic Guide to the Irish Music Sessions,
This review is from: Field Guide to the Irish Music Session (Hardcover)
Let me say up front that I am an experienced amateur musician; I have played in groups for years, although not Irish sessions. However, I am of Irish descent and I love Irish trad music, so I bought this book as a way to prepare myself to work into sessions. I completely appreciate that sessions have "rules" and need to, and that a newbie needs to work into sessions slowly and learn the ropes. I also have to admit I got a chuckle or two out of the book, because despite my better instincts, I like understated sarcastic humor and the author has a knack for that.
But I have to say this book was very discouraging and no help at all. It seems more intent on lampooning beginners than helping them, which seems mean-spirited. I saw no useful advice in this book for helping people actually work into sessions. The advice seems to be "Those who can play in sessions know who they are. Everyone else should just sit out. If they try to fit in, they will be the object of ridicule." Unfortunately, I have actually seen this kind of behavior at Irish sessions, much more so than in jams/sesssions for other genres. It's a shame. I think this is not in the best traditions of the Irish culture. I do believe that it is more characteristic of Irish sessions in the US than Ireland. Other musicians I know who have gone to Ireland and played in sessions have found a much more welcoming atmosphere than this book describes. So, if you are an experienced US Irish session player, this book will give you some good laughs at beginners' expense. If you are a beginner, this book is just discouraging and a waste of time and money.
Share your thoughts with other customers: Create your own review
|
|
Suggested Tags from Similar Products(What's this?)Be the first one to add a relevant tag (keyword that's strongly related to this product).
|