|
23 of 25 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
For Collectors Only, April 23, 2003
As a Lips fan, I enjoyed this EP, it's nice to have something to tide you over between major releases. It could have been better though. Here's the song by song breakdown.Fight Test: This is the album version of this song. Great song, but if you've got Yoshimi you've already got it. The next three are live covers- Can't Get You Out of My Head: Don't know the original artist, but yes its THAT song. Amusing at best. The Golden Age (Beck) - The Lips are in a pretty good position to play this song, given that they both opened for Beck and also played in his backing band on his most recent tour. This is a fairly straightforward version of a pretty good song. Wayne sounds a little funny singing so low. Knives Out (Radiohead) : Another fairly straightforward cover. Interesting, but not remarkable. Now we're back to studio tracks: Do You Realize??(Floating in Space Mix): The original version of this is an awesome song, but probably not the best choice for a 9 minute long quasi techno remix. This remix adds little other than length, a lame dance hall drum beat, and the occasional warbly filter on wayne's voice. The Strange Design of Conscience: Finally, a new song. This one's pretty good, with a similar vibe to the stuff on Yoshimi. Almost makes up for the butchering of Do You Realize, but not quite. Thank You Jack White (For the fiber-optic Jesus that you gave me): This is the saving grace of the EP right here. The song has a countryish vibe and tells the presumably true story of Wayne's run in with Jack White of the White Stripes, and the fiber optic Jesus he gave him. Fun song. Bonus Material - This cd also contains a video for fight test, and a trailer for the upcoming lips movie Christmas on Mars. Haven't yet got to watch either of them, but bonus material is always a good thing. Bottom line, this looks like a 'For Collectors Only' item, especially since at [money] its almost the price of a full length album. Definately buy Yoshimi Battles the Pink Robots and The Soft Bulletin before you think about getting this.
|