Most Helpful Customer Reviews
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Her voice is uncanny!, April 10, 2005
This review is from: Filippa Giordano (Audio CD)
Filippa's voice has a hint of the color of Lara Fabian
A wink to the vocal range of Mariah Carey, serious visits to the belting of Celine Dion and the high powerful notes like Patti Labelle (without being screechy).
I think this CD is amazing, her voice is completly gorgeous, such a wonderful vocal range (up to G above high C in "Vissi D'arte" and and "You are the one") and high belting of F's, G's and even A's and B's below soprano high C!
Also very low notes like in "Habanera", she is simply fantastic.
Of course, for someone lookin' for pure opera, stay away from this! but of course, Filippa can sing in an opera voice (like in "Mariah by she sea" where she sings layered vocals in pop and operatic way).
I hope to see more of her soon, her style is different from Sarah Brightman's (who has basically 3 voices), Emma Shapplin (who sings in a classical way but her own songs about witches and vampires), Filippa who is more of a pop singer than anything else is unique and I appreciate that :)
Also her pop songs are far from being the typical Mariah or Celine song, they are "trippy" for lack of a better word, but it's fantastic work.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Understand this album for what it is, and what it is not., February 1, 2007
This review is from: Filippa Giordano (Audio CD)
Opera aficianados take note - she is not an opera singer. It is pointless to consider her as one. You might as well snipe at a nasturtium for not being a rose. She is a pop singer. If you are looking for nuanced interpretations of classic bel canto opera, why the heck did you pick this album up in the first place? You know where to look already.
I completely disagree with the opera buffs who say that it is a travesty that she recorded these albums and besmirched the great masters. She did not record this for *you*. She recorded this for listeners of pop music. Have you heard what passes for pop music? Evidently not, or you would realize her albums far surpass everything currently in play... and if that is damning to pop music, well, so it is.
If one person... a single soul... listens to this album and is inspired enough to go out and listen to "the real thing" then Filippa Giordano has done them a great service and made the world a richer place. Opera aficionados are not born knowing and appreciating opera. One must be exposed to the music in the first place. Many people grow up having NEVER heard opera. This sort of album has a chance at being played in venues where Callas and Fleming couldn't get feet in the door. To the uninitiated, opera can seem bewildering and unintelligible, full of unfamiliar conventions. Filippa Giordano uses pop conventions to put these arias in musical terms that pop music lovers can grasp. Melodic familiarity goes miles toward connecting people to the emotional core of an operatic performance. Before you spew venom, consider that you are potentially thwarting a pathway that may lead to genuine appreciation of "real" opera down the pike. Bite your tongue. Go listen to your own recordings of the masters. You are right. They are infinitely more sophisticated. But this album has considerable value despite its flaws, and it wasn't created for you.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Not really opera, but fun anyway, February 2, 2006
This review is from: Filippa Giordano (Audio CD)
As previous reviewers have said, "purist" opera fans would probably not consider this album to be opera, but it's still very enjoyable. Filippa Giordano will not likely be cast in a Wagnerian role anytime soon; she has a beautiful voice, but it does sound rather thin at times (she's no Maria Callas or Renee Fleming, in other words). It would be very easy to compare her to those other "(p)opera" divas, Sarah Brightman and Charlotte Church, but Filippa's sound is considerably more playful than Sarah's, and more sophisticated than Charlotte's. The highlights of this album are her renditions of "Casta Diva" and "Habanera," and I would recommend it for those two songs alone, but the rest of the album is also very good. This would be a great way to introduce a young person to the genre, as many of the songs could pass for pop songs.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|