Customer Reviews

Final Cut Pro 3 Editing Workshop (2nd Edition)

5 star:		(8)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(3)

 

 

I'm a working professional editor. I read Tom's first edition. I was blown away by the expert mix of how-to and why edits work which can only come from a veteran master editor who is also a teacher. This is the book that gives you everything needed to learn the application and the principles of editing form, structure, pacing, music-- wisdom you don't get from a dry software-only book. Tom layers in all the FCP operations-- appearing just where they should! It's an exceedingly robust work. You can spend well-structured time with it, as I did, practice the designed edit exercises with the supplied CD along with your keyboard chops from the included KeyGuide™. Both editing skill and software know-how come together here in a dawning experience. In my view, it's either this, or a semester in film school containing separate classes on editing theory, editing practice, and a solid FCP course to boot!

Wow! I can't say enough good things about this book. It's maybe the best instructional book I've ever read. I'm relatively new to video and editing and I needed a lot of basic information, a lot of explanations of the terminology, and I really liked the little tips and sidebars that gave in-depth background information on a subject, like timecode and why people like me (using consumer cameras) should prestripe their tapes before shooting. That alone probably was worth the price of the book! I also liked the way he tells you why you should or should not do it one way or the other. That really helps to keep the beginner from being overwhelmed by FCP's complexity.
The author's writing style is extremely gentle and even humerous, he's obviously one of the top gurus on the subject but he totally avoids sounding like an arrogant know-it-all. And the way the book is laid out, it's like taking a good course, the information just flows at exactly the right pace. The included CD with the tutorial media and projects was very helpful to me, to learn some of the trickier stuff, like using the trim edit window and the best way to create titles in Photoshop and bring them in. I even tried the "Brady Bunch open" and now I can animate and set keyframes. I noticed that all the other reviewers seemed to be professionals or instructors and I just wanted to say that from the perspective of someone just starting out, without a lot of previous video editing experience (just iMovie) this is definitely the book to get. And, you can even ask the author questions on several of the FCP forums and he personally answers them! Amazing.

When I think about this book, I inevitably end up thinking about where I'd be without it: Lost. Last year when I first got FCP I tried to read the revised, but still cumbersome 1000+ page compellation of instruction booklets. Needless to say, I got about 20 pages into: What's new in FCP? Before I made the conclusion that I'd need help. First, I tried going on forums (2pop.com amongst others) with minimal success. Finally, I came across this book, after a last ditch effort to try another instruction book. When the book came in about a week later, I was extremely surprised about how easy it was to read. It was like he was a mind reader, every question I had he answered.

In a nutshell: I'd probably still be trying to figure out how to overwrite a clip or, at best, be learning the transitions if not for this book. If you're a beginner and you're looking for the right book to guide you along the narrow path that is FCP, seek no longer; this is the solution you've been waiting for.

I buy software tutorial books for something more, and Tom Wolsky's book on Final Cut Pro is a marvel. If you're new to video editing, you can use the tutorial footage provided and play along, lesson by lesson. But unlike, say, Adobe Classroom in a Book books (which I like very much), Tom uses sidebar bits to go far beyond the nuts and bolts and give you the tools to make editing decisions that will make your work... work. There is an art to editing, and with all the accessible tools and programs and software out there, Tom's instruction lets you rise above the crowd with finished videos that are elegant and communicate better than if you just competently assembled a story. If you are an experienced editor, the book is organized and indexed so that you can easily find tricks, tips and advice that you need. But if you're like me, you will find yourself reading the in-depth background sidebars and discovering that your understanding of post-production skyrockets.

While other books cover a facet of FCP, Tom's book does something very auspicious and suceeds -

He teaches the concepts of editing inside of the interface of FCP. Why you are using the tools as much as how to use them.

If you are new to editing, you'll get the fastest leg up on "how to" in FCP with this book.

If you're an experienced editor, you'll find it great to have Tom over your shoulder, showing you how to get up to speed quickly.

One of the best books for FCP by far- especially with the new sections on Color Correction.

Now in an expanded and updated second edition, Final Cut Pro3 Editing Workshop by computer expert Tom Wolsky offers the definitive instructional reference into using Final Cut Pro3 for editing and manipulating digital video in service to multimedia projects. The thirteen tutorials comprising Final Cut Pro3 Editing Workshop offers deftly presented instructions for system set-up to ensure smooth operations; getting material into FCP and organizing it; editing to build and trim a particular sequence of shots; using Realtime OfflineRT, and QuickView; adding transitions (including FXScript DVE's); working with audio, split edits, back-timing, and level control; advanced editing techniques (including rhythm and timing); FCP and Photoshop titling; color correction, image animation, special effects filters; compositing for project enhancement; and outputting material. Enhanced with an accompanying CD-ROM, Final Cut Pro3 Editing Workshop is an enthusiastically recommended for personal and professional instructional and reference collections, complete in one volume, do-it-yourself workshop in book form.

I consider myself a pro user of FCP but Tom's book (...) is an incredible learning tool.

I'm teaching a friend FCP and this book has great easy to follow guides for beginners and lot's of great stuff for Pros as well. I especially like the information on color correcting which I needed help with.

This book is a must have and is well written. It's much easier to obtain quality information than using the Apple Manual.

By the way this book arrived a couple days after my Daughter and I've only managed to read a little so I look forward to getting deeper into it.

Thanks TOM and CreativeCow.net

The Final Cut Pro book that every editor needs. Tom hits all the bases in this new release. As a Certified FCP Instructor, I finally have a book that I can wholeheartedly recommend to all of my students.

I knew final cut pro fairly well when I started the tutorials, so I wasn't sure how much more I would learn. But I did learn more. I learned tricks to be more efficient, and now know more techiniques and shortcuts. So it was worth the time spent reading, in time saved later.

Many chapter are dedicated to non-editing stuff, like titling and compositing, which he explains are now important for editors to know. Another reviewer or 2 seemed to think the author was a poor teacher, I didn't seem to have a problem with the text, which was generally well written and logically presented.

I have browsed many FCP guides and after spending five minutes with this one I found quite a few useful things I could not easily find in other books. That is why I am ordering it today. I'm not sure I will run all the editing workshops witht he suppied clips, but I think many will be useful.