Customer Reviews

Final Payments

5 star:		(6)
4 star:		(2)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

Now 39, I first read Final Payments at 18. After college, marriage, and two children, I still get it off the bookshelf from time to time to read for its power, pleasure and insight. Raised mostly motherless, main character Isabel has taken care of her invalid father in their home for eleven years, mostly out of guilt from past events, her intense love for him, and, because this deed is expected by her devoutly Catholic father. All the while, however, Isabel knows it is looked upon as out of the ordinary in the latter 20th century, and mainly, secretly, she wishes it would be over so she could begin to live her own life. Upon her fathers' death, however, Isabel is surprised to find she finds not the relief she expected, but confusion and difficulty understanding how to handle life in the real world. Still a young woman of thirty, she becomes involved with the worst possible men a woman as naive as she could. Her new job finds her only constantly reminded of her former situation with her father, a memory which haunts her until she is forced to make her 'final payments' to her past. The vividity and emotion with which author Mary Gordon has written this book with has made it a stunner. The reader vascillates between sympathy and empathy, humor, outrage, love, resentfulness, embarrassment, and wonder ... and these emotions are written in such firm but elegant prose, she feels herself in Isabel's current situation and is amazed by the logical reality and turns of events of Isabel's life. You will think-- and wish -- you are there.

I am presently reading "Spending" by Mary Gordon and find it interesting but not remarkable. Ms. Gordon's first novel "Final Payments" is one of the best novels I have ever read. It seems not many have read this book and that's unfortunate as I strongly believe that most would agree with me. It helps if you're an ex or present Catholic, but all should find it funny and profound. I've never bothered to write a review, but this book prompts me to take my non-existant time to rave about it. The reader will identify and love Isabel and her struggle to find a place for herself in a world that she unprepared to inhabit. In its own way it is also one of the funniest novels I've ever read. Only Breakfast at Tiffanys and To Kill a Mockingbird have moved me this much-high praise.

I love discovering an author new to me who writes so well that you just know you've been there; you've seen those people; you've heard them talking. And through Mary Gordon's incisive prose, you perceive everything even more clearly than if you'd merely been there.

It's just too bad that so many of the characters are appalling. Although I admired the author's sense of irony, I wish she had been more generous with a sense of humour that occasionally percolated but never fully penetrated.

Talk about dysfunctional. Isabel Moore is finally in a position to set herself free after eleven years of nursing a badly crippled father. First he was crippled emotionally and then he became physically incapacitated by a stroke soon after his daughter did something that disappointed him mightily. The guilt that arises in Isabel will outlast even her widowed father's surprisingly long life. Isabel is 30 when he dies, and considers herself ancient. Today a 30-year-old woman would probably not consider herself passée. Yet perhaps at the same time a young woman today would not devote herself so completely to the care of a disabled parent. Still, Isabel's actions and reactions seem anachronistic even for 25 years ago, when this novel was written.

Isabel's thought processes are incredibly convoluted, but if you can get past her wobbly self perception (why does she attach herself to so many unlikeable people?) this book is worth reading. You may question much of the character motivation, but you will love the words and how the author has strung them together.

Final Payments is an insightful look at love, death, friendships, and religion. Mary Gordon writes with such richness it is a beauty to read. Her style of writing is truly an art. She creates absorbing characters with such depth, especially Isabel Moore. Isabel manages to touch us with nearly every emotion: sadness, sympathy, happiness, frustration, relief, and humor. Her thoughts are so unique, so inspiring. It's an amazing first novel, and definitely worth a read. Since there is no synopsis given at Amazon.com, I thought I'd provide a brief look at the back of the book: "After eleven years of devotion to her father, Isabel Moore suddenly finds herself with what most of us dream of: a chance to create a totally new existence. She is supported by the loving encouragement of two old school friends, rapidly becomes involved with two men -- and then discovers that before she can grasp the present she must make her final payments to the past."

Final Payments by Mary Gordon seeks answers for living a meaningful life. Isabel Moore, Gordon's protagonist, lost her life purpose when her father died, and must reconstruct a new life without old roles, and religious formulas. Isabel Moore had been her father's caregiver for eleven years. After he dies she can finally live her own life, but she is so overwhelmed she can't move forward. What should she do with the sickroom paraphernalia--the hospital bed, the wheelchair, the commode, and suction machinery? What should she do with the dirty house, the stacks of books, the "pileup of things and days and lives" (38)?

Disposing of stuff is simple compared to deciding what to do with her life. Her friends try to help, but she must do this for herself. When she was her father's caregiver the church rewarded her with the "good girl" label. Even though she had already given up her Irish Catholic faith, she took comfort in being known as good.

Isabel struggles with ethics and morality in a world without her father, and without the restraints of her childhood faith. She relishes sensuality. She has sex with her friend's husband, and then falls in love with another married man. Shocked at her own behavior she fights to make up for her sins. She needs purification. Her self-imposed punishment is to live with, and become caretaker for her old housekeeper Margaret Casey, a repulsive witch of a woman, whom she has hated since childhood. She reasons if she can overcome her hatred for Margaret, she will be redeemed. A nun once told Isabel she didn't have to like someone to love them in God. But Isabel never understood this. How could she love Margaret if she didn't even like her?

Mary Gordon, through the consciousness of Isabel, looks for answers to living a good life, a life of pleasure, of love, of pain, of loss--a life of meaning. She tells the truth about Catholicism, the place of women in the church, the gospel's mandate to love human beings. Her conclusions are sensitive and intelligent. Final Payments is real. It is about human redemption, but has no absolute answers.

What will a self-sacrificing daughter do when her life of caring for her invalid father ends abruptly with his death? In the midst of her loss and pain, she must now make decisions that will determine her future. Will she go ahead and cut her ties to the life she led? Will she find an independence she lacked all these years?

These are the questions before Isabel Moore upon her father's demise. She had loved him, looked up to him, and now she must create a new life without him.

Isabel's friends Liz and Eleanor begin to step forward to aid in this metamorphosis. But it's Liz's husband John who offers Isabel an opportunity for a job she seems well-suited for. A job assessing the caretakers of the infirm, who are doing so with a government stipend.

First she must sell her family home, but she does so; she moves into a small apartment in the suburban town where she will work.

Another side-effect of Isabel's new life includes the reawakening of her sexual being. Two men become a part of her new life, but in an oddly unexpected way, the men bring about a self-doubt that will ultimately result in Isabel's turning away from her new life and returning to a life of self-sacrifice. But will she find what she seeks? Or will she ultimately decide that self-sacrifice is not the answer after all.

I enjoyed this passage which describes the conflicts Isabel faced in her new life as she was struggling to decide if she should go forward with her lover Hugh, whose wife had unleashed her fury upon Isabel in a very public way:

"There had been a gradual darkening in the background of my life with Hugh since he had first suggested leaving his wife. But after she had publically accused me of theft I began to accept the identity of a thief. I lived as though I had been forced into a hideout. It was February; the light was bad, as I imagined the light to have been bad in wartime London. I was afraid to go out of the house. It took a new kind of courage for me to go about the business of my daily life. I drove around the supermarket several times before I went in, trying to calculate the possibility of meeting anyone who had been at the party. In the years that I lived as the daughter of my father I had always been greeted with reverence and delight by shopkeepers, by people carrying groceries. I was the good daughter. I took care of my father. I had nothing to fear. Faces were open to me, for mine, they believed, was the face of a saint. Now faces would be closed to me, and I myself would learn to close my face...As the daughter of my father I was above reproach....."

Exploring themes of good vs. bad; the pull of desire weighed against the unique place of self-sacrifice in one's life; and the joys of the flesh contrasted with the possible rewards of giving to others, especially the undeserving--these provocative issues, and characters acting out these issues, populate this very compelling novel. Final Payments is all about what can happen when one makes choices, and it's also about the consequences of those choices.

I could not help but award this wonderful book five stars. I would recommend it to anyone who is a fan of Mary Gordon's work, as well as those who enjoy the exploration of these issues.

Mary Gordon is one of my favorite authors. I loved the biography of her mother "Circling My Mother" and that of her father "Shadow Man"and also "The Other Side". But it is "Final Payments" that I find most powerful and challenging. I read this book many years ago not long after it was published. I picked it up again this past fall (I am now 69) for a re-read and I am so glad I did. I found it so insightful concerning the Catholic Church with the confusion and conflicting "lessons" it presents to young adults especially in the areas of sexuality, pleasure, shame, guilt, sacrifice, and love. It was not unlike what I experienced as a young adult growing up in a very Catholic household. The idea of sacrificing what Isabel felt she had to sacrifice (if even for a short time) because of her shame and guilt was profound. No wonder so many Irish Catholics become alcoholic. The different and conflictual emotions I felt for Isabel reading it was a trying experience at times. Anyone who was raised Catholic and especially Irish Catholic will find this book astounding.

Mary Gordon's Final Payments is a great American Novel. Through her tale of a girl from Queens, the reader is taken on the classical hero's journey. Written in a voice as honest as Isak Denisin's and with insights on mortality as powerful as Virginia Woolf's, readers reckon with the narrator as they come to terms with themselves. The result is powerfully redemptive and enormously healing.