12 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Cuts to the chase, and doesn't mince words!, June 8, 2010
This review is from: Financially Stupid People Are Everywhere: Don't Be One Of Them (Hardcover)
Right now, books about the Great Financial Crisis are almost falling out of the trees. This one really is different. Instead of (just) building the usual case about how the investment banks and bankers are greedy, evil b*stards (thinking up hyper-complicated ways to take other people's money), Kelly hammers home (even if too close to my home, it turns out!) some simple basic truths about money and personal financial responsibility. He then returns again and again to these essential rules and shows how violating them helped to create and then amplify the mess we are still in today. The rules are "fractal" in nature: they apply to the individual consumer, and to the US government, and to every sized borrower in between. (Even though his first rule of finance is, in essence, avoid or limit having to borrow.) Very quickly, you realize that those evil greedy bankers wouldn't be so damn rich if only people would stop being so incredibly stupid, financially.
The book is a fast read that I didn't want to put down - probably because in every chapter I kept stumbling over another anecdote or scenario that seemed uncannily familiar. Between pointing out the stupid financial choices we all make, and showing just what alternative choices we can make, this book keeps you thinking "yeah, he's right", and "why didn't I think of that?". I especially like the way he skewers the political extremists on both sides of the aisle, showing how financial stupidity and lazy voter apathy may combine to extend the status quo (good for the wealthy elite, not so good for the rest of us), and magnify the messes that occur.
I say, buy it, read it and keep it handy, and you won't "be one of them"!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
13 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
4 Great Ideas and Lots of Fluff, November 10, 2010
This review is from: Financially Stupid People Are Everywhere: Don't Be One Of Them (Hardcover)
Kelly's book has 4 great ideas:
1. Don't spend more than 80% of your income
2. Don't carry balance on your credit card
3. Don't finance your car - pay cash for it
4. Don't put less than 20% down payment on your house
All of this is explained very clearly in Chapters 1 and 2. If you want to get the maximum benefit for the minimum amount of time, read those two chapters and skip the rest.
Chapters 3, 4, 5, and 6 tell you that big business and government work together and that they are out to screw you... as if we didn't know this. You must have the naiveté of an elementary school girl not to know about the big business lobbyist, the oil, war and health care agendas and who makes money from them, and that the whole bailout is you - the tax payer - picking up the tab for the big party Wall Street had in the last several years.
It's great to know Jason's opinion on these topics but it doesn't add much value.
Chapters 7, 8 and 9 are regurgitating Chapters 1 and 2. The last chapters don't add much else besides hype. They are like the super-excited college guys who cheer for someone else's idea.
"Hey, guys, let's get some beer and get drunk", someone says.
The guy cheerleaders then start hyping up: "yeah, man, let's get some beer, let's get crunk, let's get some beer, it's gonna be wild, yeah man, let's go for it, it's gonna be amazing, I'm getting drunk just thinking about it!". Lots of hype but no action.
I understand Jason's challenge - how do you write a whole book of 150+ pages on 4 very simple and practical ideas? The answer is layout the ideas and then fill the rest with fluff. Otherwise, Jason had to publish a pamphlet for which people would hardly pay $20+ and no publishing company would publish.
What would make Kelly's book an excellent one is:
1. a section on how to get out of debt once you are debt ridden
2. a section on what to do after - you've got your savings in order and then what? Jason has written several books on investing - he has the expertise to talk about the subject.
3. a section on how to get more value out of your money. Jason lives in rural Japan. Is this just because he likes it or is it because his money last him longer there? Many people move to other countries when they retire because their money have more value there. Japan is not one of those countries but who knows...
This book has a great potential to be a 5-star masterpiece. I hope there is a revised edition coming with more practical and relevant information.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No