K-Gr. 2. The husband-and-wife team known for
Cat up a Tree (1998)
and others considers the human costs of technological advancement through a simple seasonal debate: real Christmas trees or plastic? Lured by the convenience of trees that "go back in the attic till next Christmas," customers bypass farmer Tuttle's genuine evergreens, leaving him unable to buy Mrs. Tuttle a gift. Just when the crop seems destined for the toothpick factory, a mysterious customer requests Tuttle's "finest tree," whisking it away amid telltale elfin footprints and leaving payment behind--a Christmas hat for Mrs. Tuttle. The combination of a small-businessman's economic crisis with this sweet but impractical gesture doesn't really work, and many children will be left wondering how the struggling Tuttles will manage without a livelihood. Despite this loose end, addressed only through a hint in the final painting, there are visual rewards in the Hassetts' folk art-style bustling townscapes and country scenes, which give all the clues needed to identify Mr. Tuttle's final customer.
Jennifer MattsonCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved
Review
"Kids will love seeing the surprise turn of play in the art, which features an evergreen forest so lush and crisp one would swear it emits a pine scent." Publishers Weekly, starred review Publishers Weekly, Starred
"Imaginative illustrations." Horn Book Horn Book
"There are visual rewards in the Hassetts’ folk artstyle bustling townscapes and country scenes." Booklist Booklist, ALA