38 of 39 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Strong Newcomer In Roman Historical Fiction, April 12, 2010
This review is from: Fire in the East (Warrior of Rome, Book 1) (Paperback)
Fire in the East is a strong newcomer in the category of Roman Military Historical Fiction. The book is smart, finely detailed, violent and exciting.
Author Harry Sidebottom is a published professor of ancient history and he draws very detailed accounts of all aspects of Roman military life in the mid 3rd Century. This is the true victory of what's intended to be a 3-book series titled "Warriors of Rome". Few historical fictions contain the detailed notes, glossary and bibliography that Sidebottom presents in "Fire". He's clearly done his research, and worked his academics into his richly built story.
The core of the story is quite simple. A barbarian from the north, Ballista, climbs the ranks of the Roman Military (quite common during the second and third centuries in the Roman Empire), and is assigned to lead the defenses of a key city on the far eastern outskirts of the Empire. He's strong, smart, witty, emotionally tortured, loyal, and blonde. The fictional city is called Arete, nestled on two sides by deep ravines, on another side by the might Euphrates river, and on the fourth by a desert. Roman intellegence reports that the Sassinid Empire is planning a springtime attack on the city. It's Ballista's job to prepare for a siege and lead the defense of this important outpost at the crossroads of the Eastern World.
While the details are painted with colorful details and make the story unique, Sidebottom has turned a specific kind of military event into as strong of a character as any of the Roman or Persian good and bad guys alike. The true star of "Fire" is the siege - the machinations of defense and attack. Sidebottom tells of ballistae, hidden pits, spies and city-taking siege towers. etc. The story hums along as Ballista prepares for the siege, many items discussed in great detail, but some held back for a literary surprise.
There's no lack of violence. As detailed as Sidebottom is with his descriptions of military life, he's equally as vivid in his depiction of military death. Huge stones take off a man's head while his body still stands. Arrows hit soldiers and Sassanids alike...killing and maiming in any number of ways. It wasn't too gory and added to the effect and realism of the story.
Overall, I enjoyed this book. Sidebottom incorporates a theme of betrayal and espionage throughout the story that's uneven and ultimately disjointed and disappointing. This branch of his story is the strongest reason I rate the book with 3 stars instead of 4. I may revise the relative weight of this negative once I'm able to get my hands on the rest of the series, but as a stand alone, the plot gaps leading up to the flat conclusion were awkward enough to knock it down a notch in my mind.
A strong historical novel should hit on at least two key qualities - an ability to transport the reader to a foreign place and time; and a strong story that legitimizes (at least in the reader's mind) that history. I think Sidebottom does a nice job in both categories...he's at his best, though, with the history.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
22 of 22 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Simply a Great Historical Novel, February 2, 2010
This review is from: Fire in the East (Warrior of Rome, Book 1) (Paperback)
I'm slightly surprised by some of the lukewarm reviews of this book. Personally I thought it was one of the best historical novels about the Roman Empire that I've ever read. It's certainly superior to the Cato-Macro novels of Simon Scarrow although they are entertaining reads in themselves.
Fire in the East is set in 255AD, right in the middle of the 235-284AD imperial crisis which almost brought down the Roman Empire. The main character is Marcus Clodius Ballista, a soldier of barbarian origins who has risen in imperial favour. He is accompanied by his Hibernian bodyguard Maximus and body servant Calgacus. Ballista is appointed Dux Ripae and ordered to hold the town of Arete on the Euphrates river which is under serious threat of being captured by the Sassanid Persians. Arete is actually a fictional place but heavily modeled on Dura-Europos, a site that has yielded much archaeological evidence on the state of Rome's eastern frontier in the early centuries AD.
Ballista must organize the townspeople of Arete and his own limited military forces, some of whom are working against him, to meet the forthcoming attack. At the same time he must also face his own personal demons.
The author's descriptions of ancient siege warfare and Roman third century military tactics is absolutely first rate and he has the ability to create an almost totally convincing historical environment. You constantly feel that you are walking the streets of a Roman town with real third century people. There is suspense as Ballista tries to get to the bottom of treachery within Arete and some sexual tension with the daughter of a town official. This is a real page turner!
Fire in the East is the first book of a trilogy and I am already half way through the second book of the three. It must be pretty obvious that I loved this book and I unreservedly give it 5 stars.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
8 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Good Fun For Historical Action Fans, March 11, 2010
This review is from: Fire in the East (Warrior of Rome, Book 1) (Paperback)
Sidebottom mischieviously admits he's chosen this period of Roman rule (circa 250 AD) to write about because so little is known about it. So he's free to invent characters and situations to hang his story on, and he does an entertaining, if workmanlike, job. History fans will love his sketch of everyday life in a Roman outpost near Mesopotamia, as well as his thorough explanation of the dynamics of siege warfare. Plot and characterization take a back seat, though-- you'll likely figure out who the bad guy is before the big reveal-- well, the not-so-big reveal. This is the first of a planned trilogy, so if you like it, there's 1200 more pages to enjoy. I'll be looking forward to them.
If you're seeking better stuff from Rome (250 years before), try Robert Graves' "I, Claudius" or Robert Harris' novels "Imperium" and "Conspirata." Also fun is Gary Jenning's 1000-pager on the collapsed empire 300 years after Sidebottom's book, "Raptor."
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No