Customer Reviews

Fire in the Mind: Science, Faith, and the Search for Order

5 star:		(19)
4 star:		(2)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(2)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

This book started out slow and then became an epiphany. The book is set against the backdrop of the greater Santa Fe area of New Mexico. Johnson uses places and cultures in this area as a vehicle to lead into his description of current scientific thinking in cosmology and evolution. I didn't understand the connection at first, but one piece of rationale did emerge: the various high-powered scientific conferences held at the Santa Fe Institute beginning in 1989 that dealt with information and physics. This is where the epiphany came in, but I'm getting ahead of myself. The other reason he used this backdrop, I believe, is his obvious love for the area - its history, geography, and cultures.
The first part of his book is a fairly straightforward tour of cosmology, albeit at a bit more intellectual level than most popular descriptions. One theme he starts with, and to which he returns several times throughout the book, is that our interpretation of the universe is determined by our inherited ability to understand, by our genetic evolution. That is to say, we see the universe through our own lens, tempered by our limitations. Nothing startlingly different here from my previous readings. In fact, it's rather intuitive. However, he delves into chaos theory, with which I am only slightly acquainted, and brings attractors into the discussion, about which I know nothing. The point about attractors is that they may account for the evolution of the universe (and, as I would see later, the evolution of complex organisms on Earth). Things were starting to warm up.
He goes on into an understandable discussion of quantum mechanics and quantum physics. Wrapped in here is the epiphany: the fundamentals upon which the universe are built (as we understand it) are mass, energy, space and time. To these we have added information -- a fifth fundamental that is as much a part of existence and evolution, and cause and effect as any of the other four. His weaving of the significance of information into the tale of the evolution of complex organisms is all new to me, as is the concept that information is such a "real" player in the universe. It plays a role in entropy and a fundamental role in evolution, starting with organic molecules -- order leads to complexity, which leads to chaos.
I struggle with how to summarize him. I have flagged several dozen pages. To try to review them will be like rereading most of the book. This is one that I may, in fact, reread.

In his book "Fire in the Mind" George Johnson explores the frontiers between religion and science, between chaos and order, and between complexity and simplicity. This exploration forces the reader to rethink what "reality" is. In the process we realize that we "know" very little about reality. Despite the huge databases we are developing we actually have not answered the big questions about existence. Nor are we likely to do so in the near future.

Fundamentalists who try to fit earth history (and indeed the history of the whole universe) into 6,000 years are almost certainly wrong. However, because of the nature of science we cannot congratulate ourselves just yet. While our data tell us that the earth itself is several billion years old, we also have made some unsupported assumptions (certainly not as many as the fundamentalists, but more than a few). Even mathematics and physics are not completely free of assumptions that cannot be tested, at least not yet.

Researchers such as Murray Gell-Mann and Stuart Kauffman at the Santa Fe Institute are busily probing the frontiers of complexity and in the process may be starting to get glimpses of just how weird our universe really is. Johnson, who is not a scientist, but a science writer, captures the excitement of this possibly ground-breaking research which may eventually show us a universe much different from that we had previously imagined. Questions arise about our immediate corner of that universe, the part with which we should be the most familiar. Is the evolution of life contingent as Steven Jay Gould might imagine it, or is it inevitably to result in creatures such as ourselves, as Simon Conway Morris believes? Are we just lumbering robots carrying our genes around (as Richard Dawkins has said), or something more significant? Can adaptationist' "just so stories" explain life? Or are we creating all of our own "reality" because of a deep need for order? My guess is that the answer is somewhere in between these extreme views, but the actual reality (if we ever glimpse it) is probably going to be very strange to us.

Johnson has brought up these questions and exposed them to our view, along with the researcher's views and doubts. It is perhaps the latter that is most instructive because it demonstrates that, despite our often arrogant opinions on the matter, we still don't really know for sure.

George Johnson has taken on some of the most difficult issues and questions woven into the fabric of science and religion and seperates them into their component threads to be examined by ordinary readers. He explores various world views as seen from the mountains and plateaus of northern New Mexico, truly a Land of Enchantment. The vast majority of modern human beings take most of the information we process each day on faith, no less our ideas of science than our religious verities. Johnson explores these faiths in the context of the pueblos, mountains, cities and research institutions of this ancient land, and presents each of them with no hint of condescension or disparagement. A truly remarkable feat given his subject matter which ranges from bar fights in remote villages to sunsets brilliantly firing the walls of the Sangre de Cristo mountians to the rituals and traditions of the Catholic Church and the Assemblios de Dios, to those of the Tewas and the myths and rites of the most primative peoples of the region. This is the best book exploring the escatologies of science and religion that I have ever read. It makes me anxious to retire so that I can attend lectures at the Santa Fe Institute and explore the mesmerizing landscape of nortern New Mexico. Read it. You will never again think of the struggle between science and religion in the same way.

The most important new scientific paradigm of the last two or three decades has been the notion of complexity- especially as it figures in the questions of the emergence of structure in the physical (and mental) world. Where do the chemicals that make up life come from? Where, for that matter, does life come from? Is the chemestry of life inevitible- or is it purely accidental? Or is it, as many would still hold, the sign of an intellignet designer?

A good many authors have taken a shot at illuminating these questions in the popular press, with varying degrees of success. Too often the author falls into the trap of proferring metaphor in place of explanaition, and finally settling for a bit of hocus-pocus handwaving- "and then something magical happens, and life arises".

Johnson's book is different. He manages, without recourse to excessively complex mathematics, chemestry or biology, to clearly elucidate the big questions as well as the various theoretical approaches that have been taken to answer them. And the way he does so is as entertaining as it is educational.

Johnson's stories all begin in Santa Fe, where three very different entities serve to illustrate many of the principles he discusses. One is the landscape of Santa Fe itself, the rocky outcroppings that serve not only as an illustration of geography, but also as metaphor for the notion of a "fitness landscape" and as the home of the Pueblo Peoples of New Mexico.

The second entity is the peoples of the Pueblo themseves. Through the evolution of their culture and their biology, Johnsom explore change in a population as it interacts with its environment, including other populations. Last is the newest entity in the area, the Santa Fe Institute, where, for something over a decade, scientists have been meeting to study and debate issues of complexity and the emergence of form and content.

Johnson manages, in only a little over 300 pages, to explore essential questions in the notion of structure in the universe, from the most elemental levels of quantum physics all the way through the emergence of intelligence without trivializing any of it. Whether discussing the philisophical implications of quantum thoery or the problems of explanation in Darwinism, Johnson presents the central issues- not some dumbed down version- and yet does do in a way that never talks down to the reader. Certainly one of thoe most outstanding popular science books of the year, and one that would be an excellent introduction to the universal nature of the questions involved for some specialists, too.

Johnson has produced what can only be described as a brilliant and powerful exploration of the nature of humanity and the way we, in diversity, see our world and our place in it. . . . The parallels he draws between scientific thinking and modern mythological explanations of the world thrill in their revelation of the connectedness of things. . . . "Fire in the Mind" is a masterwork of synthesis . . . Johnson is a beautiful wordsmith. Whether he is describing his own experiences in and around Santa Fe, the arcane ways of difficult science, the entrancing rituals of the Tewa and Penitentes or the philosophical standpoint that brings it all together, his prose is both crystal clear and a joy to read.

"In the spirit of 'Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance.' . . . Compression is the essence of science [and] Johnson proceeds to compress with utter clarity, almost casually tap-dancing his way through particle physics, quantum theory, cosmology and evolutionary biology. . . . 'Fire in the Mind' is a connoisseur's gazeteer. . . . Vibrant and exhilarating and even inspirational . . . a god's-eye view of the terrain. Imagine that this book could have been sent back a hundred years, to the time of Darwin and of James Clerk Maxwell mulling over electromagnetism and entropy. What is the corresponding book from a hundred years ahead which might turn our present perspectives inside out?" -- from the review by Ian Watson in New Scientist.

This was a wonderful book - couldn't put it down! The contrast between the Tewa indians and the scientists at Los Alamos made a wonderful backdrop from which to explore the frontiers of current thinking in cosmology and physics. George Johnson is a great writer. Perhaps being from New Mexico enhanced my enjoyment. Anyway, I loved it!

Johnson delivers a riveting account of how humans construct outlooks on the world by exploring the intellectual landscape of several local tribes - scientists perched on the mesas of Los Alamos, Native Americans arranged in the surrounding valleys, and the Penitentes cloistered in the high peaks of the Sangre de Cristo mountains. Johnson is gifted at explaining both Native American cosmology and particle physics with engaging vividness. This book draws the reader in - and at the end one is left feeling enchanted with the book and in awe of the journey that the reader has been lucky enough to undertake with such a masterful guide as George Johnson.

Fire in the Mind passionately relates mans quest for understanding. Johnson sits backs, smiles and equivocates the Anasazi's expressions of order through their beliefs with Gell-Mann's attempt to orderstand elementary particles with extraordinarily complex mathematics. I think, the distinction rests on the level at which one is willing to quit asking questions and seeking answers. Fire in the Mind does not convince me they are both simply faith based exercises since it does not acknowledge that the hotter fire is fed by the fuel of endless questioning.

Fire in the Mind was extremely satisfying in its treatment of some very complex topics and provided an excellent overview of all the big issues of science today. Johnson ties in a lot of disciplines and draws some very interesting parallels between the work of some very diverse groups. It was also a great vocabulary expander. Apparently, there's a bigger market for big words in the book business than in the pages of the Times.