Most Helpful Customer Reviews
27 of 27 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
One Man Dog of a Book, December 4, 2000
By A Customer
This review is from: Fire and Rain : The James Taylor Story (Hardcover)
The artist is richly deserving, but the book falls woefully short, to the point of irritation. It's filled with so many inexplicable flubs I found it insulting to someone of James Taylor's stature. The first meeting between 13-year-old Taylor and long-time musical collaborator Danny "Kootch" Kortchmar describes Kootch as a "peace-loving hippie-type teenager." In 1961? Hello? On a single page describing the failure of Apple records to adequately promote "James Taylor," JT's first album, the author writes "..."if Apple had been on more solid financial footing, Taylor's album would have received much more attention than it did." Two paragraphs later we read, "Taylor's album was destined for failure from the start because of Apple's financial troubles." One paragraph later we are informed that the album "was a disaster only because Apple Records did not spend enough money promoting it." Can you say redundant? Did anyone proof this puppy? The first paragraph of Chapter 7 says Taylor's London phase began when he arrived in Great Britian "in March, 1968." The first paragraph of Chapter 9 says Taylor "returned to the United States in October 1968, after being in Europe for more than a year." Was there an editor involved here or what? For so many of us, JT's music has been a touchstone in our lives...evocative, honest, evolving, poignant. His voice is richer than ever. His live concerts are legendary to this day. Perhaps at some point Taylor will make himself available for an authorized biography, absent the predictable focus on his love life, drug use and early episodes in mental institutions. I hope so. There's a story to be told here, but this attempt is sophomoric; simply not commensurate with one of the most thoughtful artists of our lifetime.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
21 of 21 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Amateurish and Shallow, July 23, 2001
This review is from: Fire and Rain : The James Taylor Story (Hardcover)
I was drawn to this book entirely because of its subject matter. I have been a JT fan for well over twenty years and know his music extremely well. I approached this book with positive enthusiasm. The whole book spends more time talking about the drug problems and sex parties than the music. Throughout the book, Halperin rightly stresses the importance of music in Taylor's life. However he spends virtually no time discussing the music or the lyrics, none of which are printed anywhere in the book. There's no discussion or analysis of the art that made the man. Halperin brushes over the releases of albums and sums them up in little paragraphs, sandwiched between cheesy gossip-column-like accounts of conversations to which he could never have been privy. Halperin talks about a whole array of people in Taylor's life--parents, siblings, fellow artists, managers, wives, children--it makes the reader want to see pictures of them. The most important ones, save for Carly, aren't here. No childhood photos, no pics of old homes, no copies of scrawled lyrics. Rank amateur. The book is generally favorable toward Taylor. If Halperin really wanted to show us James Taylor, he should have done his homework and immersed himself in the music. He even quotes James saying that if you want to understand him, all you had to do is listen to his music. It's all there. Halperin is a hack. He's selling this schlock to buy a new Mercedes. I don't know of a good biography of James Taylor to recommend, but this, I can promise you, is not one of them.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
8 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Poorly Written. JT deserves better, January 4, 2001
This review is from: Fire and Rain : The James Taylor Story (Hardcover)
I got Fire and Rain as a Christmas present and immediately began to read it. From the start it was apparent that Ian Halperin had probably knocked this book off while on a weekend getaway...not to Martha's Vineyard. It is so poorly written that as much as I love JT's music and know a bit about him, I am having a hard time just reading the book. Throughout the book, Halperin infers motives and thoughts to JT's parents, friends, teachers and JT with little or no supporting information. He says that because JT's father, Isaac, took a job in the mid-sixties that kept him away for two years, Isaac and his wife got divorced in the late 70's...12 years later! (again, with no supporting information) One minute James is suicidal and so he checks into the hospital in Belmont, the next, he checked-in to avoid the draft. He refers to comments made by James' "burly attendant, Carl" with no last name. He jumps around chronologically constantly, causing confusion. He refers to JT's Silvertone guitar as a "Silverstone", mentions that James lived "IN Martha's Vineyard" not ON MV. How this guy got the contract to write this book I will never know! If his editor had just done some editing, the book had potential, but this book is not worth the star I had to give it to write this review. Somebody call Kensington Publishing and give them the bloody bad news! Everyone else...Save your money!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|