Customer Reviews

With Fire and Sword (The Trilogy, Book I)

5 star:		(45)
4 star:		(6)
3 star:		(2)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

I've read Kuniczak's translation of the Trilogy and greatly enjoyed it. It was my introduction to Seinkiewicz. However, while reading it, it seemed somehow incoherent, like something was missing. It also seemed impossible that the companions of Zagloba would be so credulous of his boasting.

I went and found a copy of the 1890 translation of the Trilogy by Jeremiah Curtin. What a difference! Though the language is somewhat archaic, the story flows so much better and the character of Zagloba is much more believeable. There is more context to his antics, and his companions are presented as far more skeptical of his boasting, making the story much more realistic.

Kuniczak seems to have omitted and simplified much that appears in the Curtin translation, to the detriment of the story. Many believe the Kuniczak version is superior, and maybe it is more accessible, but I recommend you find the old editon in the basement of the local library and read it first.

In my country this book is considered offensive both by Ukrainian majority and Russian minority. Polish people are viewed by Ukrainians as occupants, slavers and religious opressors. Cossacks are Ukrainian national heroes and common people still sing traditional songs about "brave Cossacks" and "foul Poles". The huge statue of Hmielnitsky stands on the central square of Ukraine's capital Kiev. If you have watched movie "Braveheart" about civil war between English and Scots, you will understand the position of Ukrainians - they are brutal and violent and barbaric just like Scots but they enjoy freedom and hate overproud dominant Poles who are like English.
However I like this book - it is interesting as a great Polish mythical tale with great descriptions and memorable characters.
I have an advise to fans of this book: watch the great Polish/Ukrainian movie "With Fire and Sword", which made a lot of noise few years ago and provoked clashes between Polish and Ukrainians nationalists.
Also you should read the "opposite view book" written by Ukrainian writer Nikolai Gogol called "Taras Bulba". "Taras Bulba" is a must-read book in Ukrainian and Russian schools and it tells the story about war between Cossacks and Poles from Ukrainian perspective.

Ask around a bit and you'll find no shortage of folks, men in particular, who became readers via their encounters in youth with class adventure tales: The Three Musketeers, The Count of Monte Cristo, Ivanhoe, the Lord of the Rings, etc. ask again and you'll find almost no one whose heard of half the Nobel Laureates in Literature, fewer who've read them, and none enjoyed many of them. All the more remarkable then that one of the great adventure authors of all time actually won a Nobel and somewhat tragic that so few have read him in recent decades. But Henryk Sienkiewicz has made something of a comeback and it could not be more welcome.

Sienkiewicz is the great author of Poland--indeed, to some extent his works are said to have created and helped to maintain the strong Polish identity that prevailed through the troubled 20th Century. When his books were first published -- mostly late in the 19th Century -- the English translations were done by Teddy Roosevelt's friend Jeremiah Curtin and, whether they were adequate for their time, they are are terribly dated now and have served to put off potential readers. Add in the fact that neither the Nazis nor the Communists had much interest in fostering Polish patriotism and you've the recipe for lost classics. But then, fittingly as the Iron Curtain was crumbling, Hippocrene Books commissioned a new translation of his greatest works, The Trilogy and Quo Vadis?, by the highly-regarded Polish novelist W. S. Kuniczak, and these eminently readable versions won Sienkiewicz a modern audience. New translations of other works followed, then a terrific film version of In Desert and Wilderness, and a massive Polish television adaptation of the Trilogy. Suddenly we've a surfeit of riches and some catching up to do.

If you're just starting out it might be wise to begin with Quo Vadis?, a stand alone tale of Christians in Rome that really deserves a fresh film treatment. But it's well worth your time to dive into the Trilogy, the first volume of which is the magnificent With Fire and Sword. Set in 1647, amidst a Cossack uprising against the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth, it tells the story of a young Polish patriot and hero, Yan Skshetuski, and his love for the beautiful Helen, who is also coveted the brutal Bohun, who fights with the rebels. Pan Yan's twin tales give us epic history and grand romance, while his compatriots offer comic relief. There's his wily servant, Zjendjan, whose semi-faithful service somehow keeps lining his own pocket. There's the mopey giant Pan Longinus, who has sworn a vow of chastity until he lives up to the example of his forebears and takes off the heads of three enemy soldiers with one swing of his massive battle sword. There's Pan Michal Wolodyjowski, whose bravery and feistiness belie his diminutive stature. And, best of all, there's the Falstaffian Pan Zagloba, who makes up in drinking capacity, gluttony, and biting wit what he lacks in zeal for battle, as he keeps his one good eye peeled for threats to his corpulent frame.

It'll take you a hundred to a hundred and fifty pages to orient yourself and get used to the odd names and nicknames, but the subsequent thousand pages go by far too fast. It's one of those stories you don't ever want to end.

I bought this book via the Internet as a gift for a friend who, after reading it (he finished in 6 sleepless days), recommended that I go through it myself. "Naah...I prefer to play golf." He said, read the first chapter, and I did. The result? I finished reading this 1,200-page blockbuster, and reread it twice, in 14 days. I gave up six games of golf, two TV interviews, at least a dozen meetings (how can I put the book down when the siege is about to start?) which I realized I could efficiently run via phone, and skipped at least a meal a day. How can a 100-year old book, bought on-line, fascinate me so? I'll gladly give up playing golf if I get hold of the next two books in the Trilogy. On the practical side, the book made me understand what's happening in Eastern Europe (I have German business partners born in the Ukraine and Poland) and its people. If there's one book you have to read, this is the one. By the way, I plan to read it a fourth time

I concur completely with the wildly enthiastic reviews above. Reading "The Trilogy" was one of my greatest reading pleasures (and finding the two-volume "The Deluge" was one of my greatest reading adventures). This Polish national epic has it all, fascinating and important history, adventure, romance, memorable and delightful characters and great humor. Those of my highly literate friends who stopped rolling their eyes at the massive length of The Trilogy long enough to read With Fire and Sword accused me of ruining their vacations. They too could not put it down, despite their wives' entreaties. These are truly magnificent and significant works, but they are also enormous fun to read.

I fell in love with this series 30 years ago as a college student after having first read "Quo Vadis" in high school, as well as "The Deluge" as a Classic Comic Book. One should note that Sienkiewicz was awarded the Nobel Prize for literature, in great part because of the achievement of this great trilogy. I also read "The Teutonic Knights" at the same time, and would recommend this tale as well.

One thing that always intrigued me in my original reading was that the translations were done by Jeremiah Curtin in Costa Rica in the early 1900's. In my mind, I wondered at the thought of someone named Jeremiah living in Costa Rica at the turn of the century translating Polish novels into English.

This is a classic of world literature. With Fire and Sword is grouped rightly with The Three Musketeers, Ivanhoe and Gone with the Wind as a grand historical epic adventure. But in some ways, it is so much more.

The world it recreates of the great Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth is filled with gallant knights, fierce Tartars warriors, wild Cossacks, witchcraft practitioners and great princes. The land, with its castles, rivers, great cities and the endless tall grass of the steppes, is described in great detail. Great battles and strategies are portrayed with such clarity that you feel as if you had a saber in your hand. Overall, the comprehensive recreation of such a lost world and time reminds me more of Middle Earth in J.R.R. Tolkien's Lord of the Rings than a mere historical novel.

Plus the characters are unforgettable and complex. Hymelnitski and Prince Yeremi are torn between their loyalties and their ambitions for power. The passions and frustrations of Bohun are palpable. Even a minor character like Zjendjan is so well developed that you feel as if you had met him personally. And as for Pan Zagloba, well, let's say he is a CHARACTER SUPREME like no other!

Another measure of the greatness of this book is the timelessness of the themes it presents. The "Wild East" that Poland tried to tame in the Ukraine reminds one of the struggles to tame the American West 200 years later as well as the current struggles for power in Russia and the rest of the former Soviet Union.

But Sienkiewicz doesn't let all this greatness overwhelm you. The novel is such a page turner that you will find yourself reading it at every spare moment until it is finished. I virtually guarantee that if you read the first 50 pages you'll finish the book.

This book, along with the remainder of the Trilogy (The Deluge, Fire in the Steppe) was the main reason Sienkiewicz won the Nobel Prize in Literature. With Fire and Sword has also been made into a movie (which I heartily recommend, although you should read the book first). In Poland, the movie sold over 7 million tickets, outgrossing Titanic!

While this book is hard to find, it is definitely worth the effort.

This is an epic in every sense of the word. Ceaseless adventure, heroic battles, astonishingly vivid characters, vast tracts of land, a narrative that stirs the soul - all this combine to give the reader a truly unforgettable experiance, a grand musical saga that is really like a life lived. One feels that this is what great literature was meant to be. It is unpardonable that this book should go out-of-print, and its sequels in modern translation should be so hard to find. Sienkiewicz's Trilogy is world treasure, and they should be treated as such.

The three books, "With Fire and Sword", "The Deluge", and "Fire in the Steppe" are what epic adventure stories should be. Brave knights, beautiful maidens, treacherous dogs, beloved kings, comradeship, hardship, sieges, massive battles, and almost anyything you can imagine are covered in these books. I found them particularly interesting because they delt with the Polish and Lithunian Commonwealth in the 1600s and their wars with the Cossacks, Tartars, Russians, and Swedes. These books are a great read and lots of fun with most memorable characters. But, allow a lot of time, because all tolled, there are about 3500 pages of enjoyment to absorb. It took me two years to find "The Deluge". I finally found the two volume set of "The Deluge" at the University of California (UCSB) library. Why it is out of print and the other two are readily available, I haven't a clue. Be sure to read the modern translations by W.S. Kuniczak

Having read the Classics Illustrated version of this masterpiece when I was a child, I picked up a copy of the book at a used book store nearly 30 years later. I could not have been more pleased. This is without a doubt the finest book I have ever read (and I read alot) and my only regret is that the 1200 page tome seemed far too short. The author paints his characters with such intensity that the reader is even intrigued and often touched by not only the protagonists like Zagloba and Pan Michael, but also such antagonists as Bohun and the tormented Cossack Hetman, Hmelnytzki. Even now I am desperately trying to find a copy of The Deluge to continue this magical trip through the pages of Seinkeiwicz' awesome trilogy