FIRST CONTACT: DIGITAL SCIENCE FICTION VOL. 1
FULL DISCLOSURE: I have a story in Digital Science Fiction Vol. 2, so I have some interest in seeing this series succeed. Despite that, I'll strive for an objective review.
Digital Science Fiction is part of a new trend in small press anthologies that use modern tools to produce books with less overhead and yet high-quality production values. At least, that's what the publishers promise; and in the case of Digital Science Fiction Vol. 1, I think publisher Michael Willis has hit that mark. This is a nice book, with good writing, solid editing, and virtually no proofreading errors I could find (and I do tend to nitpick). Another plus in the digital era is that the formatting for Kindle is superb! A lot of Kindle books have formatting problems, especially if you read them on a PC like I do. I found none of those here.
As you would expect in an anthology, the offerings here are very mixed. There's drama, romance, pathos, terror, and humor - sometimes all in the same story! The quality varies: some are good, some I find excellent, and a few I found only "okay"; but there were none that I would call bad. I tend to read in parallel a lot. As I was reading this book, I was also reading the latest Analog and Asimov's, as well as two volumes of Writers of the Future. And I would say the stories in this volume held their own in that mix, and were better than some. The authors in this volume have published in most of the major markets (including Analog, Asimov's, Lightspeed, and Tor.com), and also have novels to their credit. Some newer authors are also represented.
The only complaints I have are all matters of taste. I prefer hard SF over soft SF, and SF over fantasy, so a general anthology like this is going to miss the mark for me in that sense. And I'm not fond of downer endings or ambiguous endings, and some of these stories fall in those categories. I won't spoil the surprise and tell you which ones. So I marked down a point here and there strictly because this is a personal review and reflects my personal tastes.
Here are the stories in Vol. 1:
"How I Lost Eleven Stone and Found Love" By Ian Creasey. The story of a boy, a girl, and an alien with an unusual diet. I wanted to knock this one down for the "eww" factor (seriously, it's gross!); but Creasey impressed me with the wide range of reactions he provoked. Yes, I went "eww" at points; but I also laughed, and I also was moved and disturbed. This story provoked so many contradictory emotions, I have to give points for skill there. 4 out of 5.
"Biting a Dead Man's Hand" By Ed Greenwood, the man who created The Forgotten Realms. This is an interesting genre-crosser: part pre-steampunk, part mystery, part horror. An officer in a small kingdom faces intrigue and murder when his country discovers a mineral that can power lighter than air craft. I don't want to reveal too much, because it's predominantly mystery. This is a really well-written story, but I'm knocking off a point for the sub-genre. I'm just not that interested in steampunk, even when it's well done. 4 out of 5.
"The Caretaker" By Ken Liu. This is a nice, quiet tale about a man learning to live in a world of technological loneliness and isolation. An old man receives a robotic caretaker from his family when they don't have time for him, and he learns to accept robotic assistance. I liked the characters and the technological extrapolation; but I'm knocking off a point because I thought the social commentary was a little heavy handed. 4 out of 5.
"Masks" By Jennifer R. Povey. This is a post-apocalyptic story, with interesting societies and politics that arise in the aftermath of disaster. (And the disaster is both unusual and integral to the story.) A young woman goes on a journey from one settlement to another, meets the enemy along the way, and has to decide whom she can trust. The story is engaging, but I thought it was too short. 4 out of 5.
"Hera's Tempest" By Rob Jacobsen. A band of warriors travel to a planet to investigate the loss of a scientific research station. At least, I think that's what happened. I had trouble following some of the timeframe shifts, and I thought the message was a little heavy. 3 out of 5.
"Roanoke, Nevada" By Edward J. Knight. A doctor gets drafted for a very unusual house call. The ending shocked me. With a nice mix of humor and drama, this one gets 5 out of 5.
"Nectar of the Gods" By Jessi Rita Hoffman. A young man learns his true heritage, and rebels against it. There's promise here, but I think it needs to be longer. 3 out of 5.
"The Tortoise Parliament" By Kenneth Schneyer. This one's ingenious, and I want more stories in this setting: an interstellar society, but without FTL. The story tells of the complexities of diplomacy when it can take decades to get new orders from home. There's so much I shouldn't like about this story: it's slow; it relies heavily on sexual intrigue, which I find trite; and it's mostly a bunch of diplomats talking and plotting, which isn't my cup of tea. But the whole thing is so well done, and the central concept so well imagined, that it became my favorite story in the volume. 5 out of 5.
"Black Sun" By David Tallerman. A team gets stranded in a strange place, and have to survive long enough to understand why. I found this one kinda muddy, and I kept getting distracted while reading it. 3 out of 5.
"Pop Quiz" By Curtis James McConnell. A team of investigators must decide: is their prisoner human, or a human possessed by an alien? Being wrong either way will spell disaster. I'll give this one 3 out of 5, but I can't explain why without spoiling it.