As a mother who screens everything my 13-year-old daughter reads, I really enjoy reading about the growing-up-ethnic-in-a-non-ethnic-world challenges young people face. I find, however, that most experiences are terribly similar within a group, so what is really appealing to me are those stories that feature something different, while still keeping ethnic identity crises as a major theme. Mitali Perkins' "First Daughter" books, which hit the bookshelves with "First Daughter: Extreme American Makeover" when Barack Obama was poised to be President of the United States in an incredibly astute marketing move, are two of those that meet that criterion.
This review is actually for the sequel to "Extreme American Makeover" because, inexplicably, "Extreme American Makeover" is not yet Kindlelised. "First Daughter: White House Rules" is a very perceptive look at what challenges an adopted Pakistani girl would face if her family achieved overnight international affirmation - especially if she was part of the planning team.
I'm sure I don't need to point out that if this series was written by and about the first-ever Chinese-American First Child, it would not have enjoyed the same level of interest - but, to be honest, the one part about the book that did annoy me quite a bit was that I had to stop myself from seeing Natasha and Malia Obama in my mind while reading the book. It would been nice if Sameera had been more interested than she was in the more serious international issues - but that would take away from the generally light tone of the book(s). Any fan of Meg Cabot's "The Princess Dairies" series would enjoy "First Daughter", but unlike Genovia heir apparent Mia Thermopolis, Sameera Righton takes on the role of king-maker (okay, president-maker) rather than actual ruler. I think the series has the potential to go a lot further than just these first two books, and I certainly look forward to reading "Extreme American Makeover" on Kindle as well. My own daughter's review of the book (which was also submitted to our local library as part of their online summer reading program.) follows:
"'First Daughter: White House Rules' by Mitali Perkins is a really interesting, funny read.
"About-to-turn-seventeen-years-old Sameera Righton is just like any other kid - she *loves* writing her blog, SparrowBlog, her cookie-making skills are amazing, and, of course, fashion is v-e-r-y important. Of course, Sameera is *also* the daughter of the President of the United States of America. *And* she's adopted from Pakistan at birth, which, according to the press, makes her a 'role model for South Asian kids everywhere.'
"Living in the White House is pretty fun - you get to wear fancy dresses and go to balls with cute Austrian guys, you have your own private movie theater, and you get to have a gazillion chefs ready to help you out when your cookies didn't come out exactly as planned.
"But life's not all fun and games for Sameera:
"Her almost-boyfriend might not be even that anymore.
"Her cousin is seriously prickly about Sameera paying for everything.
"The reporters and Secret Service dudes follow her *everywhere*, 24/7.
"And people are starting to say that Sameera is just a pampered pooch, and that she couldn't last a day in the `real world.'
"The problem is, they just might be right - and if they are, well, Sameera's just going to have to fix that.
"Even if it means breaking a few rules.
"I thought that the book was really good - Sameera is amazing, and I *loved* her blog. I also thought that the plot was really good as well: it had just the right bit of seriousness in it, but enough silliness to make it not-so-depressing. The only problem I had was that Sameera kept saying, whenever her parents or friends or whoever, made a comment about how she sounds 'just like a Pakistan girl', she always mutters how 'she *is* a Pakistan girl.' I didn't like how she was always muttering that, yet she never told the friends and family that it bugged her.
"I would give the book five stars: two stars for the plot, two stars for the characters, and one star for Sameera's blog posts, which were really cool."