Most Helpful Customer Reviews
549 of 570 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Pretty Presentation But Short on Substance, August 15, 2000
This review is from: First Meals (Hardcover)
I've read most every baby food/nutrition book on the market. This book is by far the prettiest: it has beautiful color illustrations that make you feel as if feeding your baby will be an exciting and colorful journey. However, once the romance of the first feeding is gone (and after you've scrubbed dried brown banana off your child's tray for the thousandth time), I fear that this book will get lost in the dusty recesses of your kitchen bookshelf, as my copy has. My main criticism is that the book doesn't deliver what the cover promises: "Fast, healthy, and fun foods." The book should be subtitled "Fun foods to make if you are in culinary school and have a whole lot of free time on your hands." Check out these suggestions: vegetable croquettes, apple, mango & apricot muesli, paella, chocolate profiteroles & puff pastry mice. Even the purees are exotic and complicated: dried apricots with semolina, spinach, potato, parsnip & leek, tasty ground meat with rutabaga & tomato. Now if someone wants to really knock themselves out for a special occasion, I think that these menu suggestions could be very inspirational. But, the average parent just needs someone to tell them that they can steam carrots in the microwave with a little water then mash them with a fork. I really lost hope when I noticed that they devote an entire page to "making purees with a mouli." Where would I even begin to find a mouli, and if I did, where the heck would I find room to store it? Have these folks never heard of a food processor or blender? Why make life so complicated? I've got to imagine that the authors of this book live a very priveledged life or that they've never had small children clinging to their legs! I also think that the time estimates for the recipes are inaccurate. Many of the recipes involve quite elaborate decoration suggestions, yet the prep time is listed as only 20 or 30 minutes. Again, the pictures are lovely, and I really do wish my food could be so inventive. But the pictures remind me of the Christmas cookie covers of magazines that showcase all those elaborately decorated cookies that I could never hope to reproduce. Hey, we are not talking high art here, a good day for me is when there is more food in the baby than there is on the floor. Another complaint I have with this book is that it covers too much ground without much depth. This book begins at birth and goes to five years, and it's only 145 pages. With so much space taken up with glossy pictures and exotic recipes, there is not much room to cover any one topic effectively. All in all, I think this book might be a good supplement cookbook to have. You might pull it out some day when the sun is shining and you are feeling especially ambitious. But, on the average day, I can think of five other cookbooks I'd pull out before it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
153 of 159 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Are you sick of PB&J? Are you ready to actually cook?, February 7, 2001
This review is from: First Meals (Hardcover)
If you are looking to move beyond the usual middle American repertoire of macaroni & cheese, fish sticks & fries, chicken nuggets, etc. then I think you will be very pleased with this book. I am a mother of two toddlers (ages 14 mos and 3 yrs) and I am sick to death of prepackaged foods. I checked this book out from the library before deciding to buy it because of the mixed reviews. It is very presentation-heavy, but that's what makes it fun to look at and gets you inspired. I wouldn't really make mini pizzas with vegetable toppings cut out to look like animal faces, but I would still use the same ingredients to top my pizzas. Just because the author makes her homemade chicken nuggets in star shapes doesn't mean you HAVE to do that too! But it's a good trick if you have a really reluctant or picky eater. Many of the recipes use "exotic" ingredients, like parsnips, shallots, etc. (OK, you foodies, stop snickering.) They are exotic to most mothers of babies and toddlers who can't remember the last time they ate something you wouldn't find in a school cafeteria. But part of the appeal of this book is branching out into new foods, almost all of which are available at your local Safeway. Another reviewer complained that some of the food choices were unsafe (choking or allergy hazards), but obviously you have to use your common sense and listen to your doctor's advice too. I found many references in the book where the author warns against giving berries, nuts, honey, etc. too early, marked prominently in the sidebars. The meal planners for the different ages were great. Most of all this makes you think about what you are feeding your child instead of slinging out just whatever you have in the cupboard. I don't have any of this fancy equipment (mouli, food grinder, etc.) but most of that is only needed for the baby food recipes. If you have a food processor and a blender, you're probably fine. If you're ready to move beyond Gerber pureed peas or Easy Mac N Cheese, give this book a try!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
59 of 60 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Great for baby, with a few shortcomings, December 26, 2002
By A Customer
This review is from: First Meals (Hardcover)
First Meals seems to be about how a Cordon Bleu chef, obsessed with nutrition, cooks for her own kids. It is very healthful approach to infant's needs, challenging to the ordinary mom's cooking skills, and tends to yeild a few disappointments the more you use it. I started using this book for my 8 month old son about 5 months ago, with great results-- at first. The baby is in excellent health and spirits, after eating home prepared baby food that was easy to make. Ms Karmel's baby recipes are wonderful, resulting in foods far superior in smell and taste to what comes in jars. The first sets of recipes taste good: Ms. Karmel is dead on when she gives advice about the foods that babies like. My son really does enjoy parsnips, for example. I am grateful for the first sections of the book, where Ms. Karmel opened my family's world to a lot of new and healthy foods. In addition to this, the charts and suggestions I found dead on for my son's introductions to solids, as well. His pediatrician has approved of all the advice for feeding my son that was in this book, so for my infant's needs, this was a very happy fit. Ms. Karmel's recipes for toddlers and older children did produce some disappointments, unfortunately. While the time allowances for the baby foods and purees were accurate, it took me much, much more time to prepare foods in the latter sections than was indicated by the recipe. In addition to taking more time than she allows, many of the latter recipes simply didn't taste very good. This was particularly inconvenient, because many of the recipes in these sections are merely variations of each other, sometimes resulting in one flop after another. Ms. Karmel's Tomato Soup, for example, was a busy mom's nightmare. It called for three steps of proceessing and after two hours of cooking and a big mess to clean up, I ended up with soup that was less than tasty. Both of my sons refused to eat it (and I didn't blame them.) Other recipes suffered because they simply call for too much onion, in my opinion. For example, my whole family found the Turkey Balls and Pepper Sauce particularly objectionable, being too spicy and greasy. My final complaint is that the recipes are too fatty for the whole family to enjoy. I know that this is good for the baby, but it seems to me that a Cordon Bleu chef can invent some way to adapt the recipes for so that you could prepare meals for not only your baby, but for older kids and adults at the same time. Ms. Karmel should also become more aware of how much time her recipes really do call for, including clean up time afterward. Not all of us are trained cooks working in a well equipped lab kitchen. In sum, I like this book and use it, but I think it could be more realistic about the cooking needs of an average family. I don't want my children's memories to be of me slaving away at a stove. I want more time to play with my kids; I'd like to cook once for everyone and get it over with! That in mind, I'd like to see a revised edition of this book that includes more basic recipes for the whole family to enjoy. I would like to learn how to modify the recipes so that my baby can get the fat he needs, but in a format that can be modified for my husband, my older son and myself.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|