First Thought Best Thought

Arthur Russell | Format: Audio CD

Product Details

• Audio CD (April 4, 2006)
• Original Release Date: April 4, 2006
• Number of Discs: 2
• Label: Audika Records LLC
• ASIN: B000ELL63U
• Also Available in: Audio CD  |  Vinyl  |  MP3 Download
• Average Customer Review: 4.0 out of 5 stars  See all reviews (1 customer review)
• Amazon Best Sellers Rank: #167,740 in Music (See Top 100 in Music)

Track Listings

Disc: 1

1. "Instrumentals" Volume 1

2. "Instrumentals" Volume 2

3. Reach One

Disc: 2

1. Tower Of Meaning

2. Sketch For The Face Of Helen

Editorial Reviews

Jess Harvel/Pitchfork Media April 2006

Audika's reissue program is an act of devoted, obsessive, scholarship and deserves every bit of acclaim it's received

Product Description

Before Disco, and before the transcendent echoes, Arthur Russell wanted to be a composer. His journey began in 1972, leaving Iowa to study Indian classical composition with Ali Akbar Khan in Northern California and ending two years later in New York at the Manhattan School of Music. In that brief period Arthur met and worked with several musicians and poets that would guide his work throughout the remainder of the decade: Allen Ginsburg, Christian Wolff, Jackson MacLow, Rhys Chatham, Philip Glass, Elodie Lauten, and Ernie Brooks. Initially intended to be performed in one 48-hour cycle, “Instrumentals” was in fact only performed in excerpts a handful of times as a work in progress. The legendary performances captured live in New York at The Kitchen and Franklin St. Arts Center include the cream of that eras downtown new music scene including Ernie Brooks, Rhys Chatham, Jon Gibson, Peter Gordon, Garrett List, Andy Paley, Dave Van Tiegham, and Peter Zummo. Included here is the previously unreleased “Instrumentals” Vol. 1 along with “Instrumentals” Vol. 2 that has been out of print for over twenty years. Originally released in 1984, sections of “Instrumentals” Vol. 2 were incorrectly mastered at half speed, and have been corrected for this compilation. Reach One is one of Arthur’s earliest compositions dating back to 1973. The hypnotic soundscape was written and performed for two Fender Rhodes pianos, and is previously unreleased. One of the holy grails in Arthur’s discography, Tower Of Meaning is a beautiful and stunningly moving orchestral work. Conducted by the late Julius Eastman, Tower Of Meaning was originally released in a limited private edition of only 320 copies. Sketch For The Face Of Helen shares only the same title as the previously released excerpt from 1981. Inspired by his work with friend and composer Arnold Dreyblatt, this previously unreleased version was recorded with an electronic tone generator, keyboard and ambient recordings of a rumbling tugboat from the Hudson River. FIRST THOUGHT BEST THOUGHT is an essential collection of the lost instrumental treasures from Arthur Russell’s vast archive and brings the genius of his legacy closer into focus. Packaged with a 16 page color booklet + O-card of archival images and essays by former Modern Lover Ernie Brooks and Audika’s Steve Knutson.

Customer Reviews

Most Helpful Customer Reviews

5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:

4.0 out of 5 stars A batch of unique instrumental music, November 29, 2006

By 

somethingexcellent (Lincoln, NE United States) - See all my reviews
(VINE VOICE)   

This review is from: First Thought Best Thought (Audio CD)

A couple years back, a good friend of mine told me that I should really check out the music of Arthur Russell. It was just about that time that Audika had re-released the brilliant World Of Echo, and I fell in love with the downright timeless release. After that, I sought out other work of his, and began to appreciate his wide range of largely under-appreciated music, sadly long after he was already gone. He was an artist who could create something as funky as the disco hit "It's All Over My Face," as beguiling as Calling Out Of Context, and as devastating as the aforementioned World Of Echo. When it was announced that Audika was combing through his hundreds of unreleased tapes, I held my breath in anticipation.

First Thought, Another Thought is the latest release in a long line of re-issues of Russell's work, and it's also the first batch of which is instrumental. If you've followed Russell to date, it might be the most confusing as well, but there are still treasures to behold in this sprawling 2CD set of work. Some of the work has already been released in limited forms, but it's the unreleased music that's really the standouts here. Originally composed back in 1974, "Instrumentals Volume 1" (which is actually ten different pieces) was envisioned as a 48-hour musical cycle to accompany the nature photos of Yuko Nonomura. On the release, the ten pieces feel somewhat rough, usually starting with a count-in and often ending just as they seem like they're getting going. That said, they're absolutely stunning in places. with lovely percussion, horns, guitars, and a loose improvisational feel that bleeds them all together into one uplifting suite of gentle music that sounds like the perfect soundtrack to a sunny, temperate morning.

"Instrumentals Volume 2" shifts pretty dramatically in feel, dispensing with percussion after the opening piece and evolving into longer, droning pieces that incorporate horns and overlapping tones in a much more dour way. The long "Reach One," which closes the first disc, seems to be an even further extension of that idea, with reverberating Rhodes organ notes pushing outward over a bleak landscape.

The second disc of the set continues with some of his more experimental work, and "Tower Of Meaning" (which comprises seven tracks and over forty minutes) continues with a more droning, textural feel, and a gloominess that's just plain hard to shake. Tracks end abruptly, due to lost master tapes, and the result is something that's devastating at times, yet slightly frustrating in execution. "Sketch For The Face Of Helen" goes even further, mixing a field recording of a tugboat firing up with some minimal electronics that sounds far ahead of its time. While it's definitely not his best work to date, First Thought, Best Thought is another entry in what will hopefully be a continuing unearthing of material from the intriguing, stylistically-varied, and amazing Arthur Russell.

(from almost cool music reviews)