From Publishers Weekly
Wells refashions the Brothers Grimm tale, retaining the moral but casting a sunny glow over the proceedings. Most of the action is familiar?a fisherman spares the life of a talking fish and has his wishes (and those of his increasingly dissatisfied wife) granted in return?but there are numerous fun embellishments. The setting is Norway and a pair of cats, Ragnar and Ulla, are the main characters. A peddler delivers the fruits of Ulla's wishes, everything from a larger kettle to the keys to a mansion ("Already paid for" is his refrain). When the fish turns down Ulla's grandest request?to be queen of Norway?the couple is not punished (as in Grimm), but learns a lesson about true contentment. Too, there's an upbeat ending, as the peddler makes a final visit bearing just the thing the couple does need?their very own kitten (which, neatly, has a few distinguishing characteristics in common with the talking fish). As always, Wells distills the essence of her story in precise, descriptive language: "They were happy with no more than the taste of homemade bread and the smell of the west wind." In debut artist Hubbard's gouache, watercolor and pencil illustrations, cozy touches abound, from the traditional Scandinavian-patterned wool socks and sweaters to the dried flowers hanging from cottage rafters. However, her color choices occasionally clash and her draftsmanship is uneven; the cover illustration, for example, is far bolder and more decisive than most of the art within. But it's still a pleasant outing, and certainly one of the livelier versions of this tale. Ages 4-8.
Copyright 1998 Reed Business Information, Inc.
From School Library Journal
Kindergarten-Grade 3?A retelling of the Grimms' tale of a talking fish and of good fortune gone awry. This version is set in Norway, and all the characters, except the fish, are cats. Ragnar, a humble but content fisherman, hooks a fish with "scales like sapphires, eyes green as emeralds, and ruby red lips." In exchange for sparing its life, it promises to grant its captor any wish. Ragnar starts off modestly by asking for some lobsters at his wife's behest, but soon nothing will satisfy her greed short of being made queen of the country. When the fish refuses this outlandish request, the fisherman suggests a turn by their old abode on the Torva Fjord, and the couple soon rediscovers the simple pleasure of their earlier domestic life. The story ends somewhat facilely with the appearance of a stray kitten with emerald eyes and ruby red lips who bears a striking resemblance to the fish. The attractive, detailed illustrations, many full page, combine gouache, watercolor, and colored-pencil mediums. This book will be enjoyed by both listeners and independent readers. Although not a necessary purchase, this rendition of the familiar story is fun and appealing.?Rosalyn Pierini, San Luis Obispo City-County Library, CA
Copyright 1998 Reed Business Information, Inc.