From School Library Journal
Kindergarten-Grade 4-A story of differences and similarities, compassion and generosity. Reenie and her mom, who are black, love to fish from the banks of the aptly nicknamed Jim Crow River. Peter and his dad, who are white, fish at the same river. However, the two families never speak to one another because, as the girl's mother reminds her, "We and white folks have kept our distance here, for as long as memory serves." While the females catch fish, the males are frustrated in their attempts. They need help, and Reenie decides to take the initiative and offer the boy some assistance and advice when he is alone. Evans takes Pinkney's words and transforms them into powerfully expressive images. Readers will easily identify with the emotions of the characters, and gain a sense of time and place. The illustrations spill across double pages in Evans's characteristic warm shades of blue, brown, green, and gold. The river flows across most of the spreads, sometimes at the top, other times at the center or bottom of the page. This heartwarming story has broad appeal and ends on a hopeful note; the children are no longer the strangers that they once were. In an author's note, Pinkney explains the term "Jim Crow" and how she came to write this book.
Mary N. Oluonye, Shaker Heights Public Library, OHCopyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
PreS-Gr. 2. Like Jacqueline Woodson's
The Other Side (2001), this picture book tells a moving story about children who make friends across the barriers of segregation. Reenie loves to fish in a stream that folks call Jim Crow River, and she learns from Mama how to catch carp by baiting her hooks with kernels of corn. When a white boy, Peter, and his dad come to fish, their noise frightens the fish away. The adults, especially the white man, try to keep the kids separate, but Reenie (with Mama's support) reaches out to the needy white boy and shows him how to catch fish. Evans' poignant pictures, many of them portraits, show the kids apart, and then, in a beautiful close-up, picture Reenie helping Peter bait his hook with corn. In the final double-page spread Peter waves to Reenie from the flatbed of his dad's pickup, and Reenie waves back. Pinkney's personal afterword talks about her childhood memories of prejudice and segregation, and the historic fact helps document the friendship story.
Hazel RochmanCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved