Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
10 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Two Gorgeous Late-Romantic American Symphonies, May 7, 2008
If you like the music of, say, Barber, Hanson, Diamond or Creston, I can pretty much guarantee you will like the music on this CD. It is a mystery to me that the music of Nicolas Flagello (1928-1994) and Arnold Rosner (1945-) is not proudly and frequently played by American orchestras. It has everything the concert-goer loves in symphonic music: soaring melodies, extravagantly rich orchestrations, inventive and yet easily assimilable harmonies, and creative formal construction. The two symphonies presented here are in the tradition of the so-called 'symphonic mass', that is music built on the Catholic mass but without vocal soloists or choir. Earlier examples of this genre are Britten's 'Sinfonia da Requiem' and Honegger's Symphony No. 3 'Liturgique'. However, I strongly suspect if one were to hear either of these works without knowing their provenance, one would be hard pressed to recognize either as a sacred work. No, I suspect one would simply respond to each of them as beautifully constructed and immediately appealing late Romantic symphonies, albeit each with five movements corresponding to the Kyrie, Gloria, Credo, Sanctus/Benedictus and Agnus Dei.
Flagello's Missa Sinfonica (1957) is arranged so that the succeeding movements correspond to an opening allegro (a slow one, in this case, really more moderato), first scherzo, meditation, second scherzo and majestic finale. The feel of the first movement Kyrie is dark, pensive, maybe even slightly melancholy. The Gloria is nervous, skittish, and almost jazzy. The Credo is the work's centerpiece; I hear it as a slow, brooding, meditative, even pleading crisis of faith. It is followed by another scherzo (Sanctus et Benedictus) which could only have been written by a New Yorker. One hears the bustle of the city that seems, to me, to be describing almost frantic searching. The Finale is a cautious assertion of faith seeking reassurance in the intercession of the Lamb of God. I hear this music not so much as the composer's assurance of the value of faith as a questioning of it, with quiet but not necessarily final resolution in the affirmative.
Arnold Rosner is of Jewish background and one could legitimately ask why he has written a symphonic mass. He himself addresses this question in his fine booklet notes, pointing out that any composer in the Western tradition has absorbed a great deal of religious music and especially the form of such music, and that this provides an indispensable framework for much non-sacred music. He has composed his Fifth Symphony (subtitled 'Missa sine Cantoribus super Salve Regina' ['Mass without Singers on "Salve Regina"']) to correspond formally with the sung Ordinary Mass and using plainchant (and thus modal harmonies). The work was written at the height of the Vietnam War and was explicitly conceived as a peaceful anti-war work; it was even dedicated to the anti-war candidate for President, George McGovern. I will admit that I am not familiar enough with the 'Salve Regina' chant to be always able to pick it out in the symphony. although some of its appearances are obvious. But certainly one can hear the marvelous workings of its implied modal harmonies here, often being reminded of such works as Hindemith's 'Mathis der Maler' or Vaughan Williams's 'Fantasia on a Theme of Thomas Tallis.' There are also sections that sound a good deal like Renaissance dance music. There is even a marvelous modal fugue in the Gloria. The Sanctus begins with the unaccompanied Salve Regina which then develops into a joyful dance with interspersed modal brass and wind harmonies. The Agnus Dei is the work's crowning glory beginning with a serenely angelic melody followed by noble and reassuring passages that ultimately convey an ineffable sense of peace and psychological resolution.
Both these symphonies have about them the sense that they are intensely personal statements, the one about faith and doubt, the other about war and peace. And both of them are exceedingly effective. The direction of conductor John McLaughlin Williams is sensitive, masterly and committed. His orchestra is the National Radio Symphony Orchestra of Ukraine, one he has conducted and recorded with often, including a previous Flagello disc Nicolas Flagello: Piano Concerto No. 1; Dante's Farewell; Concerto Sinfonico and several containing music by the underrepresented American composer, George Frederick McKay McKay: Violin Concerto, 16th Century Hymn Tunes. Although not a world-class ensemble the Ukrainians play their hearts out in convincing interpretations of these works.
Recommended.
Scott Morrison
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
 
|
|
|
|
|
|
7 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Music of (as) Religion, June 25, 2008
This new Naxos disc, part of the American Classics series, represents the work of Nicolas Flagello (1928 - 1994) and Arnold Rosner (born 1945) in the genre of "sacred symphony." Flagello's five-movement "Missa Sinfonica" dates from 1957, the height of his creativity; Rosner's Symphony No. 5, "Missa sine Cantoribus super Salve Regina," dates from 1973.
As a genre, "sacred symphony" might be defined as a purely instrumental suggestion of the stages of the Roman Catholic Mass, possibly but not necessarily drawing on music of the liturgical tradition, such as Ambrosian or Gregorian Chant. The form has a distant relation to the Eighteenth Century church sonata, so-called, and to works such as Haydn's "Seven Last Words of Christ on the Cross" in its orchestral version. Often in Bruckner's symphonies, one senses that the notion of a "sacred symphony" is in play.
Thanks to the work of musicologist Walter Simmons, Flagello has finally (posthumously) begun to receive some of the attention and admiration that he deserved, but did not always receive, during his lifetime. In Simmons' landmark study - "Voices in the Wilderness: Six American Neo-Romantic Composers" (2005) - readers will learn that Flagello belonged to the school of serious American music that, in the mid-Twentieth Century, refused to assimilate to the modernist style stemming from the Second Viennese School, Stravinsky, and other attempts to break radically with the musical past. Flagello stuck to a recognizably tonal idiom rooted in Nineteenth-Century practice but unmistakably "au courant" in its rhythmic vivacity and wide emotional palette. At times, Flagello employed a chromatic harmony and dense polyphony that Simmons characterizes as "expressionistic."
Flagello's "Missa Sinfonica," in five movements, follows the usual order of the Catholic Mass; its movements are (I) Kyrie, (II) Gloria, (III) Credo, (IV) Sanctus et Benedictus, and (V) Agnus Dei. In it Flagello largely avoids his "expressionistic" side to create movements of lyrical solemnity appropriate to the atmosphere of the Eucharistic Service. Moments of a more outspoken and colorful spirit do occur, as in the Gloria and the Benediction, while the overall character remains somber. The Credo is the most "imitative" or "picturesque" movement. The opening woodwind solo presents priestly incantation translated into purely instrumental terms and seems to incorporate the rhythmic structure of the first phrase of the "Credo" of the Latin Mass: "Credo in unum Deum." Those familiar with the Flagello's flamboyant side, as expressed for example in the First Symphony or the Symphonic Concerto for four Saxophones and Orchestra, will be surprised at the fascinating quietness that Flagello can achieve.
Rosner's Symphony No. 5 is larger in scale than Flagello's "Missa Sinfonica," by forty minutes in performance to thirty-four. Rosner's is perhaps also the more variegated and outspoken of the two works. It is more immediately arresting to a listener in both its melodic content and orchestration, at one or two moments approaching something like flamboyance, but without violating the spirit of the genre. (Mozart, after all, wrote a C-Major "Missa Brevis" which is as extravert and colorful as one might wish.) In the 1970s Rosner worked in a personal idiom that he calls "Neo-Modalism." Cognoscenti of his marvelous string quartets (recorded on the Albany label) will know the style, which manages successfully to combine modern sonata-type structures on a large scale with the harmonic patterns of the Elizabethan motet and Italianate Renaissance music. This synthesis has a few precedents: in Ralph Vaughan Williams' "Tallis Fantasia," for example, and in Ottorino Respighi's "Church Windows." Rosner nevertheless achieves a personal and original and not an imitated formula.
The sequence of movements in Rosner's Symphony follows the Mass, as in the Flagello score: (I) Kyrie, (II) Gloria, (III) Credo, (IV) Sanctus et Benedictus, and (V) Agnus Dei. The center of gravity lies in the Credo, extravert in comparison with the similarly named middle movement of Flagello's score, which manages the extraordinary task of finding its climax on a modulating chord-sequence that thickens each passing vertical structure chromatically while still sounding like a vast extended plagal cadence in a major key. Rosner likes to dance as much as he likes to sing. The rhythms of the galliard, the pavane, and the bransle everywhere animate his lyrical motion.
John McLaughlin Williams takes robust command of the National Radio Symphony Orchestra of Ukraine, who tackle the unfamiliar music with professional aplomb.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|
|
|
8 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
3.5 stars -- a pair of American curiosities, July 19, 2008
This is the kind of CD that has made Naxos famous: delivering heretofore unknown and probably never before recorded repertory for an audience thirsting for something new and different. In this case, Naxos delivers a set of oddball symphonies to worldwide buyers -- the Missa sinfonica of Nicholas Flagello and the Symphony No. 5 of Arnold Rosner -- a pair of post-romantic symphonic edifices constructed on something other than sonata format.
American composers Flagello (1928-94) and Rosner (born 1945) were/are New Yorkers whose compositions reflect their influences among 20th century composers in America and elsewhere. Both compositions on this disk are developed from the Catholic mass without voices, placing them in league with the "Ring Without Words" recordings people like to give us. However, unlike the dynamic originality of Richard Wagner relfected ring without words, the contents of this recording are too readily derivative of the composers' source inspirations. While both pieces are original in design, it is little wonder after hearing them why they've never before been recorded. They simply don't have very much original to say.
Flagello's Missa sinfonica is built on a five-part mass structure of kyrie, gloria, credo, sanctus e benedictus and agnus dei. The kyrie is essentially some Howard Hanson thematic material melded to the passion of Samuel Barber. It's followed by a Stravinskian gloria that also reminded me of Poulenc, and is followed by a meditative credo that is about as far removed from the big heroic voicing you typically hear in this movement. Nor is the character of the following sanctus e benedictus in keeping with what you may be used to; it is a quietly jovial yet discursive piece that reminded me of the orchestral music of Robert Simpson. The whole thing closes with a passive, genial agnus dei that meditates of themes and ideas of Ralph Vaughan Williams.
The Rosner symphony is built on almost the exact same format and does not reflect as many sources. It does, however, mightily imitate Vaughan Williams' Symphony 5, Pilgrim's Progress and Variations on a Theme of Thomas Tallis. Later on, the composer reflects his keen interest in the Scandinavian composer Nielsen before returning to VWs' roots. Like the Flagello, it receives a committed performance in sound that is up to Naxos' typical 21st century standard.
I don't deny the excitement the other reviewers found in this recording, nor do I deny the wet pants press this recording has gotten around the world from places like MusicWeb International and Fanfare, both of which recommended it most highly. I would caution prospective buyers that this music, while unusual, is hardly original. It sounded really great after one hearing but, upon repeated playing, it lost its edge. Its curiosity value is good for a time but, if your main interest is in original voicing, you'll tire of this very quickly. If, on the other hand, you are a most adventurous buyer that looks for something out of the way, you may find some longlasting value in this. Even if not, the Naxos price won't break you trying.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
~ Rosner
~ Imreh
~ Richard Arnell
, recommendations and new releases on SoundUnwound 
