Most Helpful Customer Reviews
23 of 25 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
6 Stars!! It's that good!, February 2, 2001
This review is from: Flash 5 Magic (Paperback)
I thought Flash 4 Magic was great, but this version, which is a Totally different book, is in a category of it's own. But be warned, when the category listing says intermediate to Advanced, it means it. Of course that's what useres at that level want. If you want a beginners book, check out Friends of Ed foundational book or the Idiots book (I hate that title) but Mr. Karlins did a great job for the beginner. You want the meat and potatoes of Flash, this is a great book. It uses Real World projects such as managing your assests, designing a shared library, and tons of ActionScript. Is this the "pretty" stuff, no, but it sure helps you get the job done. Don't get me wrong, there is plenty of the pretty stuff too, but with the pretty comes setting up rotation and alpha transparency, animating mouse effects, randomized arrays. There is just so much in this book, I couldn't begin to tell it all. You will even implement databases and add content to an XML document. This is a very deep book and the tough subjects are not avoided. You will not regret investing in your future by purchasing this book.Even if you are new with ActionScript you will be able to figure it out with this book. Not to say a total novice opening Flash for the first time would be comfortable.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
36 of 42 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
This is NOT it!, February 17, 2001
This review is from: Flash 5 Magic (Paperback)
* If you are trying to learn to integrate Flash with middleware scripting, i.e. asp, cfm, jsp, or php, this book will drive you nuts. The examples DO NOT work and the authors DO NOT have a support site with corrected code. The book sends you to URLs that don't exist, and requesting technical support from the included phone number sends you to an answering machine. After discovering that no one was interested in supporting the information contained in this book, I emailed a couple of the other folks who left "5 Star" reviews and asked them, "were you able to get the example in chapter 13 to work?" (the first real example of asp integration). I received a reply... "There is no way that I could possibly check all the code for review". To me, that's bad. Don't believe the 5 Star reviews. I've actually READ the book, DONE the examples, and SPENT the time to discover the authors pushed this book out the door without debugging it. It's up to you. You can take a chance and spend the time and money to discover for yourself, or you can pass this book by. If ANYONE can get this code to work as stated in the book, email me at hays@semp.net and I'll eat my Windows 2000 server! *
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
18 of 20 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Fancy Picture Book with Frustrated Results., September 24, 2001
By A Customer
This review is from: Flash 5 Magic (Paperback)
This is strictly my opinion, thus it is not empirically verifiable, but I found this book to be extremely disappointing! To me, it seemed as if the authors of this book wrote it the night before it was due to the editors. Until I had read a few other books on Flash 5, I thought it was me. The book takes you through a tutorial on updating a flash movie, say "megansdiary_start.swf," and your updated flash movie should come out exactly like the author's included final flash movie for that tutorial, "megansdiary_final.swf." However, there are lines of syntax that the tutorials fail to mention need to be added to the *_start.swf in order for it to come out like the *_final.swf. Also, what the authors tell you to input into ActionScript for your *_start.swf differs from what they have input in their *_final.swf, not only in location, but in content as well. They might make the claim that I read the book wrong, but that's only because the authors are catering to themselves as readers, not as an intermediate, or let alone a beginner in Flash 5. If I were one of those authors, I would ask for all copies to be recalled to update it in an edited version or I would ask for all copies to just be recalled giving a refund, to avoid future embarassment. I can't believe I wasted [my money] on this book. Oh well, it has neat pictures!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|