Product Details
Would you like to update product info or give feedback on images?
|
|
Share your thoughts with other customers:
|
||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
18 of 18 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
single most disappointing technical book I have ever purchas,
By
This review is from: Flash MX Application Design and Development (Paperback)
This is the single most disappointing technical book I have ever purchased.It will be obvious to anyone that an editor has not properly reviewed this book. It would seem impossible to have missed such basic and numerous errors in the text. It is equally obvious that the final code, at least for the first lesson on the disk, was not even run once because it can't function. For example, there is a basic error in one of the calls to a java class that prevents the project from working. It is unlikely that anyone who purchased this book to learn flash would be able to fix this mistake. This may seem like a petty complaint but realize this is just one of hundreds of error that will make it impossible for you to complete the lessons. Unless you already skilled in the subject that this book is teaching its unlikely you will be able to get much out of it. When your projects fail to run correctly you will never know if they are your errors or one of the myriad problems inherent in the book's text, images, or code. How are you supposed to learn? Frankly, the quality of this book makes me angry. For the 45 dollars Newriders asks you to pay you should expect the book to have at least a basic level of quality. It does not. It makes me twice as angry because I can see in this book the awesome potential it could have had, instead of being a confusing and frustrating text. The editors of this book should be ashamed. As a general criticism the book is not well written as a teaching tool. There is no doubt in my mind that Mrs. Speigel knows flash cold but that does not make her a good instructional writer. I do not blame Mrs.Speigel for this nature of the book because it is her editor that should have improved the quality of the text by helping her understand what sections need a little more explanation. A little more explanation mixed with the "do this do that" text would have made this a better book. Do not misunderstand me. I would by another book written by Mrs. Speigel. But do not buy this one. There is much more wrong here than a few missing data base files. There is an absolute lack of pride. Once again the editors of this book should be ashamed. Problems Major problems List of Errors
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Too many errors and absolutely no depth,
By
This review is from: Flash MX Application Design and Development (Paperback)
If I could give this book less than one star I would. I was very excited about this book when I heard about it. The back cover promises to "Deconstruct" three web applications. What it really does if give you a list or error filled instructions with little information about why things are being done. This book reads more like a poorly created web tutorial than a book authored by a professional "award-winning designer". By page 31 I had already encountered over a dozen errors in the writing and illustrations. This book was obviously not tested in any way. My favorite error so far is on page 20 and 21. In the right column of page 20 on step 2 it reads: "In the Linkage Properties dialog box (shown in Figure 2.3)..." If you look at figure 2.3 on page 21 you see a picture of a "Registration Agreement"... doesn't look like a property box to me... These types of errors continue on up at least to page 31 where I decided this book was better as firewood than an instructional tool. I skimmed forward through the book and discovered that there is absolutely no information about the server side content. You get a short text file on the CD that tells you where to download the Java Development Kit (JDK), Apache Tomcat, and MySQL. It's up to you to find the instructions on installing them. Good luck, you'll need it. I was most interested in the Flash based chatroom that the "Mult-Player Tag Game" web application promised. Unfortunately there is so little described about the server end that I doubt anyone could create their own using this as a guide. This book seems to promise to teach about the interaction between a flash web application and a server but it only concentrates on the flash client leaving server side information out completely. The server side components exist as a set of three java servlet web apps from the CD. All you get are the class files. There are no source files on the CD so that you can see what is really happening on the server end. Do not buy this book. It promises much but only delivers errors and shallow content. ...
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
don't buy this book,
By A Customer
This review is from: Flash MX Application Design and Development (Paperback)
great learning tool my ... , this book has tons of errors, no errata, and no companion webpage. it was poorly written, and poorly edited, remind me never to buy another new riders book again. it doesn't matter how well you know flash, you shouldn't have to go through a book and fix all the errors to get something to work. from the publisher "she heard of a need for this type of book, where none existed." there are plenty of books out there that cover server side flash and flash app dev., if i were you reading this review, thinking about buying this book, i would go buy anything from the "friends of ed" series. they have excellent books, coldfusion for flash, php and advanced php for flash, flash and xml, dynamic content studio, i recommend any of those over this book. there are some others also, "reality coldfusionmx and flash mx integration", "server side flash," these are just a few well written books that are coming to mind.
Share your thoughts with other customers: Create your own review
|
|
Tag this product(What's this?)Think of a tag as a keyword or label you consider is strongly related to this product.
Tags will help all customers organize and find favorite items. |
|
This product's forum
Active discussions in related forums
Search Customer Discussions
|
Related forums
|