Most Helpful Customer Reviews
30 of 30 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The BEST in a long, long while, September 13, 2006
This review is from: The Floating Island (Lost Journals of Ven Polypheme (Hardback)) (Hardcover)
I bought two books two weeks ago--this one and another I shall not name here that came out on the same day. The latter, while highly promoted and hyped. was a piece of trash. This book was absolutely fantastic. The author is a wordsmith of the highest order, and while I have not read her other books, I will now. The dialog flows beautifully, the characters are perfectly drawn, but most importantly, the story is AMAZING. Ven Polypheme, the young Nain hero and 'author' of the lost journals, may be the best first-person hero ever in fantasy. Ven has all the best characteristics of an adventurer, endless curiosity, modesty and honesty, without any ridiculous powers or bravery beyond that of any other human being, blah blah. The world he travels through is full of magic and danger, beautifully drawn by Haydon as if she were an artist painting a masterpiece on canvas. Whether or not you like fantasy, I highly recommend this book and yes, I have actually read it. The humor in it is perfect and will appeal to kids from 1 to 92.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
20 of 21 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A soarkling, magical CLASSIC for young and old alike, March 26, 2006
This review is from: The Floating Island (Lost Journals of Ven Polypheme (Hardback)) (Hardcover)
I got an advance copy of this book at a recent library meeting, along with several others, and read it cover to cover on my way home on the plane. And in the cab. And once I got home, to the annoyance of my wife and kids, until it was done. This book is amazing. Finally there is a new Young Adult classic in the making that really captures the magic of storytelling. I haven't been this excited by a book since the first Harry Potter, and readers who enjoy that series will love this one.
Young Ven Polypheme is a boy itching for adventure, even though he is from a race of people that hate to travel and like to keep to themselves. He gets his wish in an unfortunate way, following a spectacular pirate attack, and finds himself in the midst of a magic-filled and threatening world of gigantic sharks, floating islands, gypsy-like Rovers with secret boxes, spice folk, mountains that act as guardians, ghost wolves and an endless amount of danger and intrigue. Haydon's world, an earlier era of the masterful creation in which her adult series THE SYMPHONY OF AGES is set, is so real that one can almost believe that archaeologists really DID find these ancient journals from a more magical time in history, as she claims.
I am especially impressed with the characters in the book. Ven is a terrific hero, plucky and curious but with many of the doubts and issues of a real-life teenager. He and the other young characters in the story are complete people, with flaws and strengths and the ability to screw up, as well as to come through heroically. The girls in this tale are especially wonderful; for all that I love Harry Potter, it suffers from a lack of interesting female characters other than Hermoine. Haydon treats us to a host of them, from a mermaid-like creature called a merrow who has a sea-dweller's odd perspective on the world, to a snotty thief, a boisterous den-leader type and a tiny, shy creature who speaks by making flowers grow. The boys are awesome as well; I'm very fond of the cook's mate, Char, who has a miserable life and really resents anyone feeling sorry for him because of it. The messages in this book are some of the healthiest I've seen in a long time, but they don't compromise the sheer fun of the story.
This is an utterly wonderful book, and I cannot wait to read the next one. With any luck, it will fill the void that the upcoming ending of the Harry Potter series will leave with a story every bit as compelling.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
11 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Classic in the Making, September 5, 2006
This review is from: The Floating Island (Lost Journals of Ven Polypheme (Hardback)) (Hardcover)
This book will grab you from the very first page, and will not let you go until the last past page has been turned. It will be a classic, a legend of one of the very best Young Adult adventure stories to exist. It is profoundly good, extremely well written, and immerses you into a world of lovable characters, creative worlds, and blends action, adventure, magic and horror in a unique and creative way. With an elusive and strange Albatross, a wise-cracking mermaid with an attitude, a Jules-Verne-like mysterious island, one heck of a big ship-eating shark, fire throwing pirates, a sweet and friendly ghost, and whole host of good guys and bad, this is one exciting book! I am so eager to read the next installment of Ven's adventures and hope that this series will be at least a trilogy if not more of an ongoing saga. Two thumbs up, five stars, just wonderful!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|